most realistic sub sim?
 

hello!

a question from a newbie.....which ww2 sub sim is the most realistic out there? i played sillent service 2 a long time ago and thought it was pretty realistic...any comments?

what about silent hunter 3?

Re: most realistic sub sim?
 

Bingo! :yep:

thanks.....i´ll try it out!
 

thanks.....i´ll try it out!

Re: most realistic sub sim?
 

SH3 is good...but with mods it is great

Combine the best characteristics of Silent Hunter 3 with those of Dangerous Waters, and you would have the ultimate submarine simulation, regardless of whether it is modern or period.

Agreed.

SHIII all modded up
AOD or SHII modded up comes second

SH3 :up:

Have Sonalysts said they intend to adress the bugged diving and steering behavior of subs? And if so, in what quarter of the year?

http://www.subsim.com/phpBB/viewtopic.php?t=48327

Yeah have to go with SH3. I was gonna say Aces of the Deep, for its time.

I don't know, Sky. I was simply commenting and did not intend to engage in a tirade against SCS. We already have a DW forum, perhaps you could ask there.

I did not want to start a tirade, Tak, and I already visited the DW forum with that thread (link), after several months of absence. They did not take my input too friendly :) My impression is, judging by other guy's critical comments in the first months after release, that any reminder of the sim's weaknesses is not too welcomed over there, that's why I gave up there and only occasionally scan for news on patches (which additionally take too long to come). For me a sim with such ridiculous vehicle behavior is a non-starter. It's like a rally sim without 2nd and 5th gear.

Fair enough. I apologize for being so snippy.

i'm afraid non are that realistic 99% boredom punctuated by 1% pure adrenalin rush