SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   Favorite WWII Sub Movie (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=82439)

Spaxspore 07-25-05 08:59 PM

Favorite WWII Sub Movie
 
Was just curious to see what you guys fav WW2 sub movie is.

Well mine undoubltably would be dasboot.

If its other then the ones i got listed please share it with the rest of us :)

Duncan Idaho 07-25-05 09:03 PM

I picked Run Silent, Run Deep, for reasons other than it's greatness. Sure, by todays standards, it's a bit old and tired. Wasn't really very accurate either. But, see, I've watched that movie a hundred times. (Probably more). Grew up with it, I did. I'm sure a lot of others feel the same way.

Hard not to associate all those years it gave me pleasure when I vote, you know?

So there's my vote. :)

edit: Yay! Finally got rid of that $&*#*$ Medic avatar. :rock:

CCIP 07-25-05 09:03 PM

Gah, Das Boot is my favorite war movie of all time, forget sub...

I'll never get enough of it :up:

KodiakPA 07-25-05 09:05 PM

Das Boot :up:

Spaxspore 07-25-05 09:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Idaho
I picked Run Silent, Run Deep, for reasons other than it's greatness. Sure, by todays standards, it's a bit old and tired. Wasn't really very accurate either. But, see, I've watched that movie a hundred times. (Probably more). Grew up with it, I did. I'm sure a lot of others feel the same way.

Hard not to associate all those years it gave me pleasure when I vote, you know?

So there's my vote. :)

edit: Yay! Finally got rid of that $&*#*$ Medic avatar. :rock:

Run silent, Run deep is a classic, and it was the first ww2 sub movie ive ever saw.

But you just cant bring out the realism like u can with dasboot, and i think thats my fav warmovie. Band of brothers runs a close second

Kondor77 07-25-05 09:35 PM

IMO, U-571 is a farce of a movie, way too many things wrong with it. Sure its entertaining, but for me personally as a historian, its one jagged pill to swallow.

JohnnyPotPie 07-26-05 12:36 AM

Das Boot.... but fav. sub movie of all time is by far Hunt for Red... "be carefull what you shoot at Ryan, some things dont react to well to bullets!"

"russian capt. dont take a dump without a plan son."

love that movie :arrgh!:

Woof1701 07-26-05 02:55 AM

When it comes to uboats: It's definitely "Das Boot". I also quite liked "The Enemy Below.", but they built a very poor uboat interior in that movie.

When it comes to modern subs there's no way around "Hunt for Red October" for me

In addition I personally love "Operation Pettycoat" It's simply hilarious although it has little to no realistic aspect.
"We sunk a truck! Let's get the hell out of here!" :rotfl:

Duli 07-26-05 03:33 AM

Das Boot is the best in my opinion.

Fritz 07-26-05 03:50 AM

u left out 2 movies

U-boat (In enemy hands)[2004]
and
LORELEI - Witch of the pacific [2005]


havent seen Lorelei yet, doubt it'll come here (Norway)..

anyways, until i see Lorelei, Das Boot is my favorite

Spaxspore 07-26-05 06:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnnyPotPie
Das Boot.... but fav. sub movie of all time is by far Hunt for Red... "be carefull what you shoot at Ryan, some things dont react to well to bullets!"

"russian capt. dont take a dump without a plan son."

love that movie :arrgh!:

Yea thats my fav non WW2 sub movie, it roxs

Sixpack 07-26-05 06:37 AM

'Down Periscope' features a WW2 sub as well :ping:

Nopileo 07-26-05 07:10 AM

I haven't seen the third alternative, so I voted Das Boot.

By the way, I recently ordered a copy of the original, full length version of Das Boot. That was awesome! I couldn't understand it lasted for almost 5 hours. It seemed like 2 hours tops!

So anyone not seen that version yet - go get it! :up:

Shadow9216 07-26-05 07:35 AM

Here's my list, can't pick a favorite since I like something different about each one (Das Boot is my favorite U-boat movie though)

Das Boot
Operation Pacific (typical John Wayne movie, but I love it)
Operation Petticoat (hilarious, based on several actual events)
Run Silent, Run Deep

Destination Tokyo is pretty good, too.

Spaxspore 07-26-05 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nopileo
I haven't seen the third alternative, so I voted Das Boot.

By the way, I recently ordered a copy of the original, full length version of Das Boot. That was awesome! I couldn't understand it lasted for almost 5 hours. It seemed like 2 hours tops!

So anyone not seen that version yet - go get it! :up:

I bought the directors cut about 4yrs ago (dvd). At that time there was no word on the uncut ver. Now its out?!!? I didnt know, orderin now for amazon, 23$ for 5hrs+ of Uboat action cant beat that, ive never seen the uncut ver :)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:49 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.