SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)

- General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)

- - Bill Whittle (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=209129)

A friend just turned me on to him and I haven't read much of his stuff yet but he speaks with absolute truth here:

Quote:

Well, it’s the Youth Craze that’s sweeping the nation: Silent Saturday.
Yup, that’s what they called it in the New York Times: a chance for kids playing in soccer leagues to do so without all of the annoying cheering and rooting and encouragement from parents on the sidelines, and in some cases, even the coaches have to keep it buttoned so that they don’t put too much pressure on the kids by, you know, reminding them to fall back when the other team has the ball… stuff like that.
I’ve actually been to one of these Silent Saturday games. It’d be a stretch to say the kids were miserable – they weren’t. They were just confused. They looked to coaches who couldn’t coach; they scored a goal, let’s say, and watched their parents leap to their feet, lean forward, and almost literally put their hand over their mouths to stop from shouting “Way to go Jordan!” which I suppose could have been damaging to the ego of any kids out there not named Jordan.
I’ll tell you what else was forbidden on that Silent Saturday: Parents were not only not allowed to cheer the kid who got the goal – they were also not allowed to comfort and reassure the kid who had to be the goalie.
It was Silent Saturday, all right. It was Solemn Saturday, is what it was. It looked to be about as much fun as silently staying home and taking a nap – both for the kids and the soccer moms, and dads, who had parted with their money and their precious free time to get their children out for team sports.
Look, the people who came up with this stuff are not bad people. But what things like Silent Saturday have really done is to rob these children of something very, very precious: because the main reason to enroll your child in team sports is so that they can learn how to lose.

https://www.billwhittle.com/afterburner/silent-saturday

75 views and not one comment. :hmmm:

I wonder who had the idea and why ??

I kind of agree with the coach keeping silent. Give them a chance to think for themselves.

Quote:

Originally Posted by August (Post 2141653)

75 views and not one comment. :hmmm:

It's 'Silent Saturday'. :03:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Betonov (Post 2141667)

I wonder who had the idea and why ??

I kind of agree with the coach keeping silent. Give them a chance to think for themselves.

Well I don't get how a coach can coach by remaining silent. His job is to advise, instruct, correct and motivate the players. How's he going to be able to do that if he can't even signal them?

He has 6 other days to coach and one day to let them figure it out themselves.

OK, 1 day for self governing and 2 days for coaching, I doubt they have practice every day

Quote:

Originally Posted by Betonov (Post 2141685)

He has 6 other days to coach and one day to let them figure it out themselves.

OK, 1 day for self governing and 2 days for coaching, I doubt they have practice every day

Yeah i imagine their playing/training time limited to a couple of hours a week.

Being kids though their handle on the rules and tactics of the game are tenuous at best. The coach can't run out on the field to tell a kid where he should be standing or to pay attention to what's coming their way every time a kid gets confused or distracted.

Quote:

Originally Posted by August (Post 2141684)

Well I don't get how a coach can coach by remaining silent. His job is to advise, instruct, correct and motivate the players. How's he going to be able to do that if he can't even signal them?

Quote:

Originally Posted by August (Post 2141691)

Yeah i imagine their playing/training time limited to a couple of hours a week.Being kids though their handle on the rules and tactics of the game are tenuous at best. The coach can't run out on the field to tell a kid where he should be standing or to pay attention to what's coming their way every time a kid gets confused or distracted.

All in all it's a brilliant technique; Having spent much school and college at wrestling, soccer and Rugby and four years beyond on a Rugby club touring side, the noise and cruel comments are distracting if not unnerving. A coach, by placing his 'trained miñions' in play, is transmitting the implied message that they are 'ready to face off' and he knows they will "amaze him with their brilliance" (if not somewhat elevated ineptness:wah:). Patton and R E Lee actually employed this technique. Everyone who steps into the arena is there to perform and in the instant of the match, training is over and silence to apply what has been imparted is golden...and the little buggahs will show ya' and not disappoint unduly!:up:

Quote:

Originally Posted by August (Post 2141653)

75 views and not one comment. :hmmm:

Needs more Obama or guns.

Anywhooo, here's your fix:

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/i...sm_3CYvPXF__am