SUBSIM Radio Room Forums - Hello everyone, and questions...

Page 1 of 2

Show 20 post(s) from this thread on one page

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)

- Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)

- - Hello everyone, and questions... (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=200257)

Wolfwind

12-02-12 05:11 AM

Hello everyone, and questions...

Hello everyone!

I finally got active on Subism, after reading it for a while.
I've got two questions:

1. I've got some strange problem (in SH3) with torpedo tubes hatches. From time to time, I cannot open them, separately from firing (i.e. the "q" key doesn't work). Normally, loading a previous save helps it, but I am a bit annoyed with crap. Had anyone encountered similar bug? What can I do about it ?

2. I recently turned on the event camera on, just to check my torpedo runes, for a sake of training. What I've seen, made me happy, as ma manual targeting proves quite alright, but very often my torp hits the ship, only to bounce off it, without exploding. After that, it drowns, hits the bottom, and then explodes. While it happens very often within 090 degrees shots, it is probably not the matter of angle being too wide, but also can it be a dud, if it finally explodes ? What makes them glance off?

Happy to get any answers.

Take care
Wolfwind

sublynx

12-02-12 06:06 AM

1. If I remember correctly I have had this bug once or twice after trying to open an empty torpedo tube with the Q command. I can't remember what needs to be done to make the tube loadable again. I'd try shooting to "empty" the empty tube, and then diving to 50 meters and trying to close the tube again. Then I'd surface and try there as well. Maybe some-else remembers what needs to be done. (You do have enough crewmen in your torpedo compartments, don't you - once I tried to load a torpedo, but the crewmen were too fatigued for it)
2. I guess that's a dud, although I don't know if that kind of behaviour is realistic for a torpedo. I would think there could be a kind of "detonate at the end of the run so as not to detonate under a friendly ship later on" kind of mechanism in torpedoes that could work independent from the impact pistols.

Welcome to the forum :salute:

u crank

12-02-12 02:37 PM

Welcome to SUBSIM Wolfwind. :salute:

Jimbuna

12-02-12 04:12 PM

Welcome to SubSim, could you advise what setup and mods (if any) you are using.

Wolfwind

12-02-12 04:15 PM

None. I use vanilla.

Laufen zum Ziel

12-02-12 05:00 PM

Welcome mate.

Pisces

12-02-12 05:53 PM

1: Don't know for sure, but could it be a lack of manpower in the torpedo rooms. Are they too tired perhaps. Anyway, in the conning tower should be a switch panel with which you can open the doors also.

2: It's probably the curvature of the hull. Impact torpedoes work best when they hit a vertical section of the hull with their front. Set the depth a little higher so they avoid the curved section. But in heavy waves this may not be possible to be avoided. Ships move up an down on the waves so it's just a matter of being lucky.

Gerald

12-02-12 09:46 PM

Welcome to SubSim Wolfwind!

:sunny:

Wolfwind

12-03-12 03:55 AM

Well,I just found out, that my "q", floods the tubes, only it won't put the acknowledgment in the news scroll.

HW3	12-03-12 09:34 AM

Welcome aboard!

There is a 300M minimum arming distance on the torpedoes. Any shots closer than that will bounce off.

:salute:

Steve Gad

08-04-13 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wolfwind (Post 1969175)

(snip)......very often my torp hits the ship, only to bounce off it, without exploding. After that, it drowns, hits the bottom, and then explodes. While it happens very often within 090 degrees shots, it is probably not the matter of angle being too wide, but also can it be a dud, if it finally explodes ? What makes them glance off?

Happy to get any answers.

Take care
Wolfwind

They did have massive problems with duds early on in the war, so maybe the sim models that same frustration. I know I've had a ship at point blank range, already wounded, and with 2 Torps left, only to lose them both to the bottom. I finally figured I was way too close for the Torps to be effective - as I'd imagine less than 50ft to be. In frustration - and having emptied my useless flak ammo at it - I took to ramming my adversary. All I ended up doing was alerting half the Atlantic to my efforts, so the British Navy could have a good belly laugh.

I'm not 100% sure but I'd imagine there to be some kind of delayed arming (as in the RPG) to prevent premature detonation, but as I say I can't be sure if I read that, or I'm just trying for an educated guess. It IS frustrating for sure to steam out to sea, wait hours then watch what is essentially just a big sausage tap gently on Tommy's hull. :down: :subsim:

BassII

08-04-13 11:18 AM

Many old WWII torpedoes didn't explod when hitting outside 70+ degree on the target, and when using a higher torpedo run in rough water, they exploded when lift off water and hit a wave!

Jimbuna

08-04-13 11:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wolfwind (Post 1969175)

The Germans had torpedo problems early in the war:

http://www.uboat.net/history/torpedo_crisis.htm

All torpedoes need to run 300m before they are armed, the exception being the Falke which requires 400m.

Brag	08-05-13 07:55 AM

Wolfwind, welcome to this nest of murderous vipers :D

Ligne Maginot

08-05-13 10:17 AM

Maybe I do not understand your question, but with the stock of sh3 when selecting a tube and you open it, switching tube with the "Y" (or click on another tube) has the effect of closing the previous one. But if you like you can do the following:

1. - Look for the "Commands_en.cfg".
2. - Open it and look for the following entries:

[Cmd309]
Name = Close_torpedo_tube
Ctxt = 1

[Cmd312]
Name = Toggle_open_close_torpedo_tube
Ctxt = 1

3. - Now, these should look like:

; [Cmd309]
, Name = Close_torpedo_tube
; Ctxt = 1

; [Cmd312]
, Name = Toggle_open_close_torpedo_tube
; Ctxt = 1

So you can have open several tubes without having to fire a salvo ... I do not know if this is realistic, commanders always fired a torpedo or a salvo. The idea seems to be of makman94.

Good Hunting. :salute:

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:30 PM.

Page 1 of 2

Show 20 post(s) from this thread on one page