SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)
-   -   40 of the most powerful photos ever taken (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=195834)

JU_88 06-02-12 05:31 PM

40 of the most powerful photos ever taken
 
Worth a look, some of them are quite moving :)

http://www.buzzfeed.com/expresident/...phs-ever-taken

u crank 06-02-12 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JU_88 (Post 1892666)
Worth a look, some of them are quite moving :)...

Yes, some of them are very moving. Thanks for sharing.:up:

Karle94 06-02-12 06:15 PM

Damn, some of them were very powerful. My favourite is John Kennedy junior saluting his fathers coffin.

TLAM Strike 06-02-12 07:56 PM

I see a photo from Operation Overlord made it in but why didn't the flag raising on Mount Suribachi make it in?

Also they had the photo of the Earth from Apollo 8 but not Aldrin saluting the flag from Apollo 11. :hmmm:

Platapus 06-02-12 08:12 PM

Glad I was alone in my study so no one saw me bawling.

Some of those are incredible pictures.

sharkbit 06-02-12 09:20 PM

The one that got me was the picture of the marine presenting the flag to the 8 yo son of Marine Staff Sgt. Marc Golczynski, killed on his second tour in Iraq. :cry:

TarJak 06-02-12 09:34 PM

I may be old and cynical, but none of them really moved me much at all. I've seen some much more powerful photographs of events and even sunrises and sunsets that moved me more.

I don't understand how the Vietnamese monks self immolating were excluded or the image of the young Vietnamese girl running down the road with major burns to her body after her village was napalmed were excluded as these were far more powerful than say, the soldier sweating under his beret.

How about images from Belsen or Auschwitz?

Just another dumb list showing another sign that news should really be called views.

Tribesman 06-03-12 02:11 AM

Quote:

I see a photo from Operation Overlord made it in but why didn't the flag raising on Mount Suribachi make it in?

Also they had the photo of the Earth from Apollo 8 but not Aldrin saluting the flag from Apollo 11.
Maybe because people without a flag fixation wouldn't find them powerful photos.
If you take the two pictures with the stars and stripes the power of the photo is in the faces of the people, in the one of the union flags it is in the young lady that conveys the reality in the image.

BossMark 06-03-12 03:22 AM

Hmm yes some are rather moving indeed :yep:

Schroeder 06-03-12 03:58 AM

Thanks for sharing.

JU_88 06-03-12 04:50 AM

@Tarjak and Tribesmen, yes admitadly the selection in biast, there are more powerful photos out there that we know of, Im guessing they wanted to go for powerful without the 'shocking' and 'depressing' so burning monks and children have obviously been excluded.

To be fair to the author though, the title is "40 of the most" not "The top 40 most" ;)

Kongo Otto 06-03-12 05:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 1892737)
I may be old and cynical, but none of them really moved me much at all. I've seen some much more powerful photographs of events and even sunrises and sunsets that moved me more.

I don't understand how the Vietnamese monks self immolating were excluded or the image of the young Vietnamese girl running down the road with major burns to her body after her village was napalmed were excluded as these were far more powerful than say, the soldier sweating under his beret.

How about images from Belsen or Auschwitz?

Just another dumb list showing another sign that news should really be called views.

Spot on!

Takeda Shingen 06-03-12 06:28 AM

I found the one with the dog sitting by the grave of his owner particularly moving.

Platapus 06-03-12 06:33 AM

In any list of photographs that contain less than 100% of all the photographs ever taken, will naturally have photographs missing that some would like, and include photographs that some don't like.

Whether a list includes your personal favourite photographs does not diminish the value of any list.

I am sure I am not the only one who could quickly think of 50-100 historical photographs that are good and not included on this list.

It would be impossible to create a list of only 40 photographs that everyone would agree on.

u crank 06-03-12 07:07 AM

Number 33. Young woman beside hearse made this old boy weep.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.