SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   That's it. Never another Passenger/Cargo (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=176783)

desirableroasted 11-04-10 09:00 AM

That's it. Never another Passenger/Cargo
 
Is the Passenger/Cargo a sort of a programmer's joke?

For five years, I have torped them in the bow, under the stack, in the stern. I have ripped out keels. I have personally given them 20 below the waterline deck-gun shots. :damn:

Yeah, they will sink, someday. Once I had one sink just after Willy Brandt became Chancellor.

Seriously, is there a sweet spot for them? Or is every last one of them transporting balsa wood and ping-pong balls?

I play "take what you get", so I feel duty bound to sink them. But I am about to make an exception.

krashkart 11-04-10 09:05 AM

Maybe the ones you hit are loaded with inflated Mae Wests? :har:
Seriously, I have no idea what the deal might be with those.

Yoriyn 11-04-10 09:09 AM

It's becouse on that ship is to many passengers, so you have no chance to sink that ship. Simply calculation to sink any shipis:
Number of people on the ship X number of buckets, glasses, barrels or anything what can bu use to pure the water outside the ship X tonnage = chances the ship survive the attack.

As you see better stick with fishing boats :)

Gerald 11-04-10 09:19 AM

Some, of them here Passenger / Cargo, sometimes need more eels..

K-61 11-04-10 09:38 AM

I aim for about 1/3 of the way from the bow and that seems to put them under with one shot. But yeah, I hate them, too. I've put as many as three torpedoes into one of them before she'd go down. I much prefer to use the gun on them if the weather is not too rough.

Brag 11-04-10 09:43 AM

These torpedo guzzlers are full of hot air generated by Subsimers. Best to just let them go. :haha:

HW3 11-04-10 12:51 PM

Bow shot under the forward mast at 2.5M and they will go down due to flooding within the hour.

Jimbuna 11-04-10 02:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by desirableroasted (Post 1528931)
Is the Passenger/Cargo a sort of a programmer's joke?

For five years, I have torped them in the bow, under the stack, in the stern. I have ripped out keels. I have personally given them 20 below the waterline deck-gun shots. :damn:

Yeah, they will sink, someday. Once I had one sink just after Willy Brandt became Chancellor.

Seriously, is there a sweet spot for them? Or is every last one of them transporting balsa wood and ping-pong balls?

I play "take what you get", so I feel duty bound to sink them. But I am about to make an exception.

Some of them also carry a hold full of lifejackets on occasion :DL

In all seriousness though, at 90 renown I sometimes wonder if they're worth the effort.

Here is a shipchart link showing the 'sweet spots'...I'm not sure if it is on here but it's worth a look:

http://www.filefront.com/13792872/shipchart.pdf

desirableroasted 11-04-10 02:07 PM

I will try HW3 and K-61's advice, then. 1/3 back/under the foremast.

The next time that is..... this one already got one torpedo and he is not going to get another one. I will follow him to Tahiti, first. It violates my theology and geometry to use more than one torpedo on anything bigger than 7000 tons.

Edit: Thanks @jimbuna. Our messages crossed. That chart, even though it is for stock, should be enormously useful for new captains; I remember having it at some point. Thank you!

raymond6751 11-04-10 03:45 PM

Props?
 
One would think a hit at the stern would blow off or damage the props and/or rudder. That would at least halt the ship.

If nobody is around, deck gun at the waterline? Pick a second shot at the best guess and leave her to wallow.

Gerald 11-04-10 03:53 PM

Deck gun at the water line, is a good option if weather permits, and you do not have other unwanted guests, :lurk:

desirableroasted 11-04-10 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vendor (Post 1529271)
Deck gun at the water line, is a good option if weather permits, and you do not have other unwanted guests, :lurk:

Vendor, if weather permitted, I wouldn't be wasting a torpedo on an 3K tonner. Not in 1940, anyway.

Anyway, you try putting 20 under the waterline of a Passenger/Cargo. She'll sail off at 7 knots, bobbing along like a rubber ducky.

Gerald 11-04-10 04:09 PM

True! If you are unlucky it may be so, otherwise leave her and move on

Gargamel 11-04-10 04:59 PM

Just snuck up on one, fired one 110mm round at it, thing immediately split in half. Got credit for it, but i then spent 3 hours waiting for the 2 halves to sink. Never did, so I got bored and left.

/ducks.

Arael 11-04-10 06:31 PM

I've found that putting a torpedo directly under that little box flanked by lifeboats directly aft of the smokestack kills passenger/cargos pretty easily.



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.