SUBSIM Radio Room Forums - Help with Norway

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)

- Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)

- - Help with Norway (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=170127)

pickinthebanjo

05-24-10 07:23 PM

Help with Norway

http://img249.imageshack.us/img249/1936/58432470.png
The war with Norway is about to start up and I am positioned and in wait. I Chose Narvick as the port that I will focus on for my first patrol (In Norway). I was wondering what areas are used for shipping lanes, I figure Narvick and Bergen.

My plan is to wait in that zone I chose and sink whatever is heading in/out of port. Are ships scripted to head ALL the way to the port of destination or do they disapear outside of the port?

What are your opinions of the Battle of Norway?

Leandros

05-25-10 03:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pickinthebanjo (Post 1402371)

he war with Norway is about to start up and I am positioned and in wait. I Chose Narvick as the port that I will focus on for my first patrol (In Norway). I was wondering what areas are used for shipping lanes, I figure Narvick and Bergen.

My plan is to wait in that zone I chose and sink whatever is heading in/out of port. Are ships scripted to head ALL the way to the port of destination or do they disapear outside of the port?

What are your opinions of the Battle of Norway?

While there was quite a lot of action in the fjord leading in to Narvik on 10th and 13th of April (1st and 2nd battle of Narvik) little else happened until end of May. I don't know if the game follows this but there is a single mission depicting Warspite going in on April 13th. Apart from that most activity should be around Harstad, in Vågsfjord, as that was the main Allied base with lots of transports, etc. This should be in the whole period of May. Again, not sure what is done in the game.

Leg	05-25-10 04:56 AM

If you are playing GWX there will be definately some action there in Norway and Narvik as well.

RawJoh1

05-25-10 06:38 AM

I've never been around Norway in vanilla SH3, but both the first and second battles of Narvik are depicted in GWX. The Warspite's not in GWX, and is replaced by the Nelson. However, Wreford Brown has a mod that puts the Warspite where she should be.

Have fun!

Jimbuna

05-25-10 03:21 PM

You will find that both the 1st and 2nd Battles of Narvik are scripted into GWX3.0 pretty accurately.

Here we have the 5 British destroyers leaving the area after the first initial engagement on 10th April.

http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/8752/66897413.jpg

Here we have HMS Warspite approaching with her attendant destroyers and a flight of Swordfish on 13th April.

http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/2887/69966317.jpg

Here you can see the Royal Navy leaving the area approx. 2 hours later.

http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/7162/64927441.jpg

Bonus: Look at all that renown lying north and north west of the area.

pickinthebanjo

05-25-10 04:51 PM

:o Damn, I guess I'm in the wrong area, at least the warspite is due to roll along through

Jimbuna

05-26-10 02:55 AM

LOL :DL

Leandros

05-27-10 04:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbuna (Post 1403039)

Pretty accurately....?.....To my knowledge only 3 British destroyers left the area as two were sunk. The third was being towed with its bow blown off. Of course, it is more fun for the Kaleu to have 5 ships to torpedo than 3...:yeah:...

Bosje

05-27-10 05:22 AM

every career i start, i make a point of being in that fjord :)

never thought of checking that bonus Jim just pointed out tho, i'll need to have a look at that on my next happy times career

Leandros

05-27-10 07:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bosje (Post 1404464)

every career i start, i make a point of being in that fjord :)

never thought of checking that bonus Jim just pointed out tho, i'll need to have a look at that on my next happy times career

Remember to have your torpedoes checked thoroughly, that is where the Germans realized their Torpedokrise. Use impact, not magnetic, and adjust for a couple of meter shallower running than standard. Then you are being realistic....:know:..

Jimbuna

05-27-10 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leandros (Post 1404429)

Pretty accurately....?.....To my knowledge only 3 British destroyers left the area as two were sunk. The third was being towed with its bow blown off. Of course, it is more fun for the Kaleu to have 5 ships to torpedo than 3...:yeah:...

The units involved are accurately scripted in at the beginning.....what happens during the course of the game is down to the game engines hypothetical throw of the dice as to how a surface engagement pans out and of course the actions of the human player.

Similarly, the rest of the true life events that are scripted into the game.

The question or test for the player is quite simply, "Can I do better than what happened in RL"?

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:04 PM.