SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 5 (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=244)
-   -   below (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=166531)

Nico09 03-29-10 06:47 PM

below
 
Anyone watching below?

oscar19681 03-29-10 08:34 PM

I did.

kylania 03-29-10 08:40 PM

:hmmm::06:

TheBlobThing 03-29-10 09:18 PM

It's 4 am here, so that post just seemed very creepy... you know, in the dark:oops:

Edit: yay! Post 1-2-3! It's the little things in life that counts... Okay, I'll get some sleep.

BlackSpot 03-29-10 09:47 PM

Good to see Dadaism is alive and sheep tank :woot:

Nico09 03-30-10 04:09 AM

I quite like the film, obvious but ok all the same http://http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0276816/

Zedi 03-30-10 07:27 AM

Took my time to watch it now, it's pretty good. Never was interested to see a ww2 american sub interior, but if they were as is in the movie.. hm, that look more than an underwater luxury cruise ship than a battle ship. No wonder that some people demand a wardroom in SH5 :D

Was weird to see a german destroyer to hunt an american sub in the Atlantic :D Also, was a bit creepy the way he did.. with hooks. Never saw or heard about something like that, this was new for me. Anyway, nice movie, liked it.

Nico09 03-30-10 07:57 AM

Not sure if they used the hooks in reality. As for the sub interior they made it larger, apparently for ease of filming, although that was the only difference everything else is allegedly realistic.

Nico71 03-30-10 08:14 AM

Hooks were used in WW1. Not sure about WW2.

Onkel Neal 03-30-10 08:51 AM

Saw that film a while back, was really impressed with the fleet boat set they built. Now if they would only film a serious WWII sub movie using it, like Thunder Below or Wahoo, we could have an American Das Boot. :smug:

Sonarman 03-30-10 11:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neal Stevens (Post 1340625)
Saw that film a while back, was really impressed with the fleet boat set they built. Now if they would only film a serious WWII sub movie using it, like Thunder Below or Wahoo, we could have an American Das Boot. :smug:

That very nearly happened to quote Wikipedia...

"Salerno's first feature screenplay was the World War II submarine thriller 'Thunder Below' for Steven Spielberg and DreamWorks Pictures based on the book by Congressional Medal of Honor recipient Eugene B. Fluckey."

Unfortunately although the script was completed the project sadly sunk without trace. Maybe if Spielberg/HBO's "The Pacific" is a success we could hope for a ressurection. Let's hope for a TV series rather than a movie though.

Nisgeis 03-30-10 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonarman (Post 1340836)
Unfortunately although the script was completed the project sadly sunk without trace.

The rumour, or internet fact is that U-571 was already in production and Dreamworks didn't want to go head to head with another sub movie. So, another reason to dislike U-571 then.

jerm138 03-30-10 01:39 PM

I liked it a lot. One of my favorite sub movies. I thought the crew acted very realistically. Not like the typical Hollywood submarine garbage. They were dirty, ugly, foul-mouthed... just like the real thing!

Also, anyone using TMO will recognize some of the dialogue. :03:

I also liked...

*possible spoiler here, stop reading if you haven't seen it*

...that they never really confirmed that it was a ghost.... so that a really skeptical person could still believe that it was just a major coincidence spurred by a widespread psychological breakdown. Very cool.

Zedi 03-30-10 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nisgeis (Post 1340841)
The rumour, or internet fact is that U-571 was already in production and Dreamworks didn't want to go head to head with another sub movie. So, another reason to dislike U-571 then.

Ow what a mega fail movie was that. Germans are already used to be threated as retards in every Hollywood movies, but to drag the Enigma success on the american boat even if is a fiction movie, epic fail. Sadly, many americans are very convinced that they were the first to get their hands on the enigma code and when you ask them to prove it, they point out U-571. It's a shame.

janh 03-30-10 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magnum (Post 1341053)
Ow what a mega fail movie was that. Germans are already used to be threated as retards in every Hollywood movies, but to drag the Enigma success on the american boat even if is a fiction movie, epic fail. Sadly, many americans are very convinced that they were the first to get their hands on the enigma code and when you ask them to prove it, they point out U-571. It's a shame.

But you can't ask an average American about (European) history, especially about a very particular event therein that basically only and expert on this era would know... I have had hilarious experiences with that even at Harvard, and I would have expected my students to be a bit smarter than the average... But on the contrary you can't ask a European about the American Civil War either (though even that seemed to be quite an unkown variable here...).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:25 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.