SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 4: Wolves of the Pacific (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=202)
-   -   Hello, what is the arming range on the torpedoes? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=143171)

subchaser12 10-14-08 08:32 AM

Hello, what is the arming range on the torpedoes?
 
I think I read where it was 500 meters. Is it that, feet or what. I am trying to hit zig zagging ships close and I wanted to know. Thank you!

banjo 10-14-08 09:00 AM

This came up some months back and I seem to remember in TMO the arming distance is 411 yards. Not sure though. I do know that I've had torpedos not explode if the distance was under 550 yards. I use that as my personal minimum.

tater 10-14-08 09:33 AM

In the stock game (unless it changed with 1.5) it is 220m—which is way too short for US fish. Mods have properly increased it to 400-450 yards (which is realistic).

SteamWake 10-14-08 09:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by banjo
This came up some months back and I seem to remember in TMO the arming distance is 411 yards. Not sure though. I do know that I've had torpedos not explode if the distance was under 550 yards. I use that as my personal minimum.

Ive had them 'not explode' at 1,800 yards :rotfl:

But yea good rule of thumb is @ 500 yards.

Quillan 10-14-08 10:33 AM

Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!

SteamWake 10-14-08 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Quillan
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!
Torpedo is a dud sir!

Ah... youve been on my boat?! :rotfl:

By the way I have noticed of late if you set the triggers on Mk14's to impact/magnetic regardless of what type of shot your going for the dud factor seems to be reduced.

LukeFF 10-14-08 03:37 PM

In Real Fleet Boat:

-450 yards for Mark 10, 14, and 18
-350 yards for Mark 23
-100 yards for Mark 27

LukeFF 10-14-08 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteamWake
By the way I have noticed of late if you set the triggers on Mk14's to impact/magnetic regardless of what type of shot your going for the dud factor seems to be reduced.

You're seeing things. :D

The only things that reduce the chance of a dud are (1) the angle of the shot and (2) setting the torpedo to low speed.

Task Force 10-14-08 04:06 PM

Use MK 10, thats my favorite for early war.:yep: They pack one heck of a punch.:up:Sadly Im getting charged for them, 100 points for one.

tater 10-14-08 04:41 PM

LukeFF,

did you ever find a definitive statement of the mk10 arming range? I never managed to find one, myself. The 14s were so long because of the mk6 detonator. My gut says that the mk10 should be shorter, but I have no data at all.

tater

Webster 10-14-08 06:47 PM

i have done repeated tests at close range and determined the stock game will arm and detonate at 350 range and nothing less.

but depending on your mods it may change so try my torpedo test missions and see for yourself

LukeFF 10-14-08 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tater
LukeFF,

did you ever find a definitive statement of the mk10 arming range? I never managed to find one, myself. The 14s were so long because of the mk6 detonator. My gut says that the mk10 should be shorter, but I have no data at all.

No, I never have found any data about the arming range on those. It's probably stuffed away in some old file in an archive, never to see the light of day again. Nor have I found arming range data about any other torpedoes contemporary to the Mark 10, so the best we can do at this point is just go with the Mark 14 arming range data.

LukeFF 10-14-08 11:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Task Force
Use MK 10, thats my favorite for early war.:yep: They pack one heck of a punch.:up:Sadly Im getting charged for them, 100 points for one.

You get charged for them like that in RFB so people can't "game the game" with the early fleet boats by just just swapping out all those crappy Mark 14s for Mark 10s. While fleet subs did carry Mark 10s on patrol early in the war, it wasn't a regular thing, which is what we try to simulate. Actually, with all equipment and weapons that are acquired with renown points in RFB, we use a "rarity scale," so to say, to determine how much a weapon or piece of equipment "costs." In simplistic terms, the more rare an item is at a given time, the more in renown it will cost.

Task Force 10-15-08 06:16 PM

Yea, I cant stand those MK14, Sunk three ships in one patrol, I used all my foward torpedos just to do this.:huh: Il just hijack a S boat and steel there torpedos.:lol:

subcpo 10-17-08 06:38 PM

Right now, Captain Tupolev is removing the safety
features on all his weapons.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:29 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.