![]() |
GW Opening Screen Music
Can someone tell me what the music is that plays once Grey Wolves is loaded?
Thanks scrapser |
Quote:
Nemo |
Quote:
What is the name and artist (composer) of the music? Is it Wagner's "The Ring"? I'd reall like to know so I can buy the full work. Thanks scrapser |
"Escape from Mantua" from the movie "Romeo and Juliet" composed by Craig Armstrong
|
I just checked the listen files on Amazon for the CD and that title sounds nothing like the music in Grey Wolves. Are you sure this is the track?
Thanks scrapser |
Quote:
|
Thanks...I just dug down and found the same document. I guess the clip provided on Amazon is another segment from the track (sounds like disco music...really!).
scrapser |
Quote:
The music is "Escape," composed for the movie soundtrack "Plunkett and Macleane" by Craig Armstrong. You can find it on a CD of Armstrong's collected movie soundtracks at Amazon.com, here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...music&v=glance Pablo |
Quote:
scrapser |
And good music it is, too. Very atmospheric.
What surprised me was the Suicide Run theme from Call of Duty being used in the Death Screen. I never saw that coming. |
Sorry but...
I'd point out that unless the GW team have express permission from the copyright holders of those music pieces, it is illegal to distribute them with the GW mod.
|
Quote:
Your versions of IUb also use a Das Boot periscope movie sequence by W_Clear. (That I had the pleasure of working on with him more than a year ago...) Were you granted legal permission to use Das Boot footage? ...Or were you doing it for the love of the game for no profit like the rest of us. People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. |
Quote:
|
No matter if it's in a free mod or one for profit, it's illegal to use unless you have been granted permission by the original artist, or whomever hold the copywrite. Why do what we're all against. It only adds fuel to the fire of the copywrite issues that have been ongoing.
|
Quote:
Strictly speaking, you may be correct. However, using tracks and video segments in mods is pretty common practice (for example, you use tracks and video from Das Boot in your Iub 1.2). Also, GW and GWX are not a commercial enterprises, so we are not selling the tracks any more than they are sold through the radio. If the copyright owner objects, we would gladly remove the tracks. In the meantime we are more than happy to ensure that proper crediting and reference to the full original works is given... so that users may be able to find and buy more than the little teasers they get from us. What we have done in the end is nothing more than give these guys free advertising, and helped sell their product. |
Ok, these are my personal opinions, nothing to do with the rest of the dev team.
If IŽd make a list of all the mods that use something copyrighted, the list would circle the earth 50 times. Of course, you are right that we, and you and some other modders here have broken the copyright law. But think about it. Almost everything in commercial games, movies and music records have been copyrighted. Most of the soundpacks made for SHIII are breaking the law, what about the gramophone packs? The copyright owners have much bigger things to worry about than a one of their tracks used in a freeware mod; piracy. |
I don't maintain IuB anymore but there was no music or video from Das Boot used, just a few short sound samples (from other mods, I didn't sample them myself). This would probably fall into the "fair-use" category. Some old 1920's gramophone music was there too, most of which would be public domain by now. I believe the video was added by the maintainer of 1.03, nothing to do with me. I was also going to make a "copyright-free" version of the mod for inclusion on magazine CD covers and so on but never got around to it.
In this case the music tracks are added gratuituously in their entirety and are done so entirely knowingly. It is risky to have that sort of music as part of any mod, so my advice would be to remove it and replace it with original or non-copyrighted music. The music industry has a notorious record for prosecuting even minor cases, which is why I bring this up. |
But can you give me one example where mod has been sued for having copyrighted music on it? The loss to copyright owner is so minor, that it is not worth the money nor time to sue a mod. Even Youtube has videos taken from movies and the site is still standing and the videos are there. There is of course always a chance that the copyright owner of the music/movie clip plays the mod and takes action. But I find the chance to be almost as low as winning in lottery.
|
Dont want to listen to so called " copyrighted " music / sound bites simple
A) Download the mod and remove the sounds B) Dont Download the mod C) Download the mod and play with no speakers / headphones plugged in |
The very worst thing that can happen is that... if in the very unlikely event that the copyright holders find the mod and actually care about enforcing it in such a fickle thing... then they will ask us to remove it. No big deal.
We are certainly not using their material for profit, we acknowledge it's use, and if anything it's publicity and is to everyone's advantage. The fact is that GW is better with this material than without it, and it hurts no one. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:03 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.