SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   Could someone kindly recommend a good U-Boat novel? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=92793)

tiger_tim_34 05-04-06 11:43 AM

Could someone kindly recommend a good U-Boat novel?
 
I have a couple of good historical books (currently reading 'Business in Great Waters) but would also like to dive into (no pun intended) a really immersive U-Boat novel.

Which would you Kaleuns recommend?

Best regards, and happy hunting to you all

Myxale 05-04-06 12:04 PM

Well "Das Boot" by Lothar-Günther Buchheim is a good one. :hmm:
This is one of the "you must read" on this board.
It's probably one of the best known U-Books ever. :rock:

Well this is a somewhat baised opinion, but generally you can't do wrong wit this one for starters.
The same goes for the Movie "Das Boot" :hmm:

KL Seestern 05-04-06 12:04 PM

Well, I think there's one obvious answer to this question: Lothar-Guenther Buchheim's Das Boot, the 1973 novel which inspired the film. It's available in various English translations, of which I have two: one by J. Maxwell Brownjohn (published in 1974) which reads very well but is a little 'loose' with the German, and another recently re-printed in the Cassell Military Paperbacks series (no translator named: just says 'this translation copyright Alfred A. Knopf 1975') which is a little more faithful to the German in some respects (e.g. present tense narration), but annoyingly not in others: all the measurements have been converted into Imperial units, which somewhat ruins the 'immersion' factor (another pun ;) ).

But it's a great novel, whatever translation you can get hold of. Or if you can read German, even better!

Threadfin 05-04-06 12:29 PM

Iron Coffins is a good novel ;)

Oleif 05-04-06 01:44 PM

iron coffins

U-Dog 05-04-06 02:14 PM

Operation Drumbeat reads as well as a novel.

There is on out there about a U-boat stranded off the coast around new orleans and one of the officers falls for a Cajun girl or something like that. Can't seem to find it at the moment tho.

don1reed 05-04-06 03:10 PM

With Honor in Battle by J.T. McDaniel

U-Boat:Typ XXI

tiger_tim_34 05-04-06 06:22 PM

re: recommendations
 
*Many* thanks indeedy. As I know the Superbit (Director's Cut) version of Das Boot very well and have just ordered the mini series, I have just placed an Amazon order for Iron Coffins and With Honour in Battle.

Now, all I need is a sufficiently debilitating cold that confines me to bed for a week, yet allows me concentrate on reading. <-- There's GOT to be a market for selling a bug like that. :-)

Joe S 05-04-06 07:32 PM

Das Boot is a fabulous novel. If you want non-fiction, Operation Drumbeat is excellent and Night Raider of the Atlantic is very good also. For US Sub action, Thunder Below by Fluckey is the best in my opinion. Have Fun, Joe S

CptGrayWolf 05-05-06 01:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Threadfin
Iron Coffins is a good novel ;)

:rotfl: Poor Werner...

tiger_tim_34 05-05-06 02:58 AM

Thanks guys! Starting to look forward to my 3 hour daily commute now. :-)

PeriscopeDepth 05-05-06 03:09 AM

For non fiction you should also read Doenitz's memoirs, Ten Years and Twenty Days. Provides an interesting insight into the U-boat arm from BdU himself.

PD

hairydynamicist 05-05-06 03:09 AM

Any of you guys read 'The Real Cruel Sea'? Non-fiction based around the allied merchant navy during the battle of the Atlantic. Not read it myself, but sounds very interesting.

don1reed 05-05-06 10:19 AM

It's great. The British side of the story from the skipper's point of view from the bridge of the "Compass Rose".

edit: Low budget movie, with Jack Hawkins as the skipper, is also pretty dang good.

Cheers,

Myszkin 05-05-06 10:24 AM

"Peter Erich Cremer. U-333" by Fritz Brustat-Naval
"Another Place, Another Time" by Werner Hirschmann
"U-38" by Max Valentiner (I WW)

jaxa 05-05-06 11:03 AM

"Das Boot" - Bible of subsimers, "must read"
"Iron coffins" - probably the best

Myszkin - duże brawa za hasło pod Twoimi postami, chociaż podejrzewam, że wielu z uzytkowników forum będzie miało co do tego wątpliwości

Myszkin 05-05-06 11:29 AM

"Hirschfeld. The story of a U-Boat NCO 1940-1946" by Geoffrey Brooks - This is a unique book based on a highly secret diary kept by Wolfgang Hirshfeld during the war.

Jaxa - wątpliwości można mieć, ale faktom nie da się zaprzeczyć :)
Pozdrawiam!

retired1212 05-05-06 12:48 PM

U-571 :rock:

Ducimus 05-05-06 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oombongo
U-571 :rock:

Someone get a rope! We's gonna have us a hangin'! :-j

Quote:

Could someone kindly recommend a good U-Boat novel?
My order at Borders has come in:
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/steelboat.gif

I just havent had a chance to pick it up yet.

To wet your whistle, heres a 10 page excerpt from it.
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/books.cgi?a=4


Theres another one out there, i dunno where it is, theres like two excerpts from the book you can read on the net,

Ping Jockey 05-05-06 05:04 PM

Operation Drumbeat :up: :up: :up:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.