SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Helosim.com and Flight Sims (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=216)
-   -   Helosim Black Shark review (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=149338)

Onkel Neal 03-13-09 03:31 PM

Helosim Black Shark review
 
Full review by our very own "Periscope Depth".

http://www.subsim.com/nucleus/media/...-Ka-50_cut.jpg

Now that I have a new, mega powerful computer, I am going to download this sim tonight!

Kratos 03-13-09 03:36 PM

Good review :up: But HEY HUNTER is the boss allowed to put stickies in our little corner :03: :rotfl:

HunterICX 03-14-09 06:37 AM

Good Review,
but the green background colour made it hard to read.

HunterICX

Skybird 03-14-09 10:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HunterICX
Good Review,
but the green background colour made it hard to read.

HunterICX

Green? Check your monitor, maybe it is broken, or colour template needs to be adjusted. The background for me is light brown/dark beige, a bit darker than in this forum.

HunterICX 03-14-09 10:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird
Quote:

Originally Posted by HunterICX
Good Review,
but the green background colour made it hard to read.

HunterICX

Green? Check your monitor, maybe it is broken, or colour template needs to be adjusted. The background for me is light brown/dark beige, a bit darker than in this forum.

My Monitor is NOT broken.
when I posted I was at work, and at home the same thing.

Helosim frontpage:
http://img213.imageshack.us/img213/7517/82955808.jpg

the Black shark Review:
http://img530.imageshack.us/img530/7020/bgc.jpg

HunterICX

Fincuan 03-14-09 11:29 AM

The background is bright green(about 00B020, ie. very annoying) with Opera. Using Firefox it looks the same as Hunter's, and Helosim frontpage looks the same as Hunter's with both browsers.

Nice review though :up:

Onkel Neal 03-14-09 11:40 AM

Green? Huh, you must be using one of those outlaw browsers, you know, the kind that gag over every little thing :haha:

oookkkk, I'll fix it for all the non-IE users :shifty:

Stupid firefux :stare:

:fff:

Fincuan 03-14-09 11:53 AM

Psst: According to most comparisons IE is the worst standard-follower of the three browsers mentioned here :yeah:

Here's one test you can run on your own browser:
http://acid3.acidtests.org/

At my end the scores are(with default settings in all browsers):
Opera 10 100
Minefield 3.2(Firefox 64-bit version) 93
Opera 9.6 85
IE8 64-bit version 21
IE8 32-bit version 21

Onkel Neal 03-14-09 11:56 AM

Hey, standard followers, smollowers... IE can show the page correctly.

FF is like an ex-gf who has to have EVERYTHING just exactly her way or she goes crazy. :O:

Anyway, I didn't code that page, it was Lionpride.

Onkel Neal 03-14-09 11:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HunterICX
Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird
Quote:

Originally Posted by HunterICX
Good Review,
but the green background colour made it hard to read.

HunterICX

Green? Check your monitor, maybe it is broken, or colour template needs to be adjusted. The background for me is light brown/dark beige, a bit darker than in this forum.

My Monitor is NOT broken.
when I posted I was at work, and at home the same thing.

Helosim frontpage:
http://img213.imageshack.us/img213/7517/82955808.jpg

the Black shark Review:
http://img530.imageshack.us/img530/7020/bgc.jpg

HunterICX

Hey, at least you didn't block my Google Ads :salute: For that, I'll go through and fix every page :)

Onkel Neal 03-15-09 04:25 PM

...and I'll go on to say that Firefux is like Windows 3.1, while IE is like Linux (how's that for irony?). IE deals very well with the odd error and rogue html and as a result, you are very unlikely to have the whole page crash on you....

...oh, wait, is this discussion already done? :O:

Fincuan 03-15-09 06:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neal Stevens
IE deals very well with the odd error and rogue html and as a result, you are very unlikely to have the whole page crash on you....:

You might want to try to run the test I linked on IE and rethink that statement after that :D It was the only one of my browser that fubared the entire test-page. The practical problem here is of course that some sites are designed for IE and not by the standards, so they'll work on IE but possibly not on other browsers.

Anyway the review now works fine(thanks for that), so I guess we're done here.

Lieste 03-15-09 09:34 PM

I'd already read it by the simple expedient of selecting the text and reading it white-on-black... but it was definately broken ;)

porphy 03-16-09 03:28 AM

Nice review Periscope, thanks.

I agree with everything said in the write up, and I also like Black Shark very much. This is a very good study sim and it deserves a high star rating. It's simply wonderful to fly the Shark around the map, doing the occasional cool helicopter move. :cool:

There is one thing though which isn't mentioned in the review, and that is the "tree problem".
Trees are plenty and they look good in the sim when you have all the graphics enabled. The thing is that they are not solid. You can fly through them. But even worse is that the AI can see through them, but you can not... Using trees as cover is a non option. If you do that you might very well take a good hit from SAMs, AAA gunfire or mandpads coming through the foliage. :nope:

To be honest. I haven't had big issues with this so far. Mainly because you are flying very low when staying behind trees, anyway, which tend to be sufficient to keep you out of harms way. But on a few occasions I have suffered from this problem. Especially if you are getting a bit too close to the bad guys. You have to remember that the enemy is probably tracking you already, and as soon as you are within firing range they will shoot. As you do a bob up attack from behind trees and try to quickly get a lock, they are already firing at you.
The thing is to think and perform the attack and approach as if the trees were not there. Use ridges, small elevation differences and even houses for cover. Stand of tactics and coordinated attacks with wingmans also do wonders. This works very well indeed, just remember that there is no hiding in the trees here.

ED is fully aware of the problem and there might be a solution for this coming up.

cheers Porphy

Skybird 03-16-09 06:26 AM

For the record, over here both the helosim frontpage and the review page are brown. The review with a lighter brown, but still: brown (or beige).

On IE, security-wise it is better than it'S reputation - if you set the security settings to high. And whether Firefox loads a page a second faster than IE or not, is so absolutely uninteresting for me. All in all FF2 and 3 have given me many, many more troubles, than IE ever had. Therefore I no longer constantly fiddle around with FF3 which I tested for 2 months last year. Neal's description of it being something like a teenage primadonna is hitting the nail on top.

PeriscopeDepth 03-17-09 02:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by porphy
Nice review Periscope, thanks.

I agree with everything said in the write up, and I also like Black Shark very much. This is a very good study sim and it deserves a high star rating. It's simply wonderful to fly the Shark around the map, doing the occasional cool helicopter move. :cool:

There is one thing though which isn't mentioned in the review, and that is the "tree problem".
Trees are plenty and they look good in the sim when you have all the graphics enabled. The thing is that they are not solid. You can fly through them. But even worse is that the AI can see through them, but you can not... Using trees as cover is a non option. If you do that you might very well take a good hit from SAMs, AAA gunfire or mandpads coming through the foliage. :nope:

To be honest. I haven't had big issues with this so far. Mainly because you are flying very low when staying behind trees, anyway, which tend to be sufficient to keep you out of harms way. But on a few occasions I have suffered from this problem. Especially if you are getting a bit too close to the bad guys. You have to remember that the enemy is probably tracking you already, and as soon as you are within firing range they will shoot. As you do a bob up attack from behind trees and try to quickly get a lock, they are already firing at you.
The thing is to think and perform the attack and approach as if the trees were not there. Use ridges, small elevation differences and even houses for cover. Stand of tactics and coordinated attacks with wingmans also do wonders. This works very well indeed, just remember that there is no hiding in the trees here.

ED is fully aware of the problem and there might be a solution for this coming up.

cheers Porphy

Thanks for the comments porphy. I didn't know about the tree issue. I've had one incident where an ATGM seemed to come out of the trees at me, but I just assumed it had skimmed over them.

And BTW, I understand Neal's downloaded Black Shark recently. Liking it Neal?

PD

Onkel Neal 03-17-09 02:58 AM

Doggone server transition is getting in my way of installing it :wah:

Soon!

porphy 03-18-09 03:29 AM

Nice work. The forum is really fast now Neal. :up:


Time for you to start up the Shark, me thinks. Be careful the first time taking it out though, it can be a bit wild. :DL Link

I guess you already have read about how trim works in the Shark, but it really is essential for flying this one! All kind of bad things happened to me before I got that technique down.

cheers Porphy

Konovalov 04-20-09 11:26 AM

That was a nice review. :up: I just love the attention to detail in the startup process. The amount of detail in the cockpit is immense. What was written in the review sounds spot on. You could immerse yourself in this simulation just flying it without geting to the part of employing it's weapon systems.

While I haven't yet installed the game I did watch a display of it by the owner of RCS Simulations here in the UK on his full on fancy simulation machine with triple screens, mounted on a moving platform. Ayway the purpose of the demo was to look at how the Track IR4 Pro works with DCS Black Shark.

First he flew it without TRack IR 4 Pro. I was struck by just how much of a workload the Blackshark pilot has. Then he ran a demo with the track IR and it's full 6DOF functionality. This display convinced me to finally purchase a head tracking system beng te Track IR4 Pro. Quite frankly I'm not sure why I didn't get around to it a while ago cnsdering how many hours I have spent in IL2, Janes F15, Janes F18, and so on.

Ayway the drive to Bristol was well worth it and I have my Track Ir4 Pro which is great in GTR2 and no doubt will come in for some heavy use with DCS Blackshark. So my advice is to purchase hardware such as the Track IR4 Pro. I also own a Saitek X52 Pro HOTAS system along with the Saitek Pro Flight Rudder Pedals. :D

Fingers crossed that there is more to come frm DCS with at least another module being the A10.

Arclight 04-20-09 03:40 PM

If all goes according to plan, there should be quite a number of modules. Possibly Apache, Flanker, Eagle, Fighting Falcon and Hind. Just rumors as far as I know, but very promising.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:29 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.