SH IV, worth purchasing?
 

Or is SHIII+GWX the better option for now?
How is the bug situation, when d'ya think most problems will be solved?

Thx,
SBJ

Really it all depends on how badly you want to sail in the Pacific. I couldnt wait to play and spent over 300 to be able to play it. Dont regret it. Yes, it has bugs, but they seem less serious to me than when SHIII was launched. The game is playable despite what some naysayers claim. So, if you have a desire to sail a new ocean and fight a new enemy, then yes, by all means, get it. If you get annoyed and shelf a game because of some bugs (many of which you can work around) then i would say wait.

There are bunches of threads voicing all different opinions on that question, from "It sux!" to "I love it!" Just take a look around; it's all been said.

I've got both, and play them about equally. SHIV will better when the next patch is released, and the modders hit their stride, but it's still very playable as it is.

OMG, he´s back! Run for the hills!!!!!!! Just kidding... ;) Welcome back, mate!

Yes, it's worth it. :up:

I'm loving it

Is a six pack and large pizza with the works worth it? So what are you waiting for....go pick it up:yep: Pick up that pizza and six pack on the way home because once you load and get it running....your not going to want to get up.;)

I've got three copies....
One for me
One for myself
and one for I..

Seriously, I do have three copies. The USA version from Amazon, The Limited Edition Super Collectors version direct from UBI, and the UK Collectors version. I am playing off of the UK Collectors version DVD which arrived first.
I like to collect different versions of releases that I am particularly fond of.

Go ahead and get you a copy of SH4. Install it with the 1.1 patch and the Real Fleet Boat Mod, The CBS Radio Mod, and the Pearl Harbor Menu Mod. I tell ya, FDR's Day of Infamy Speech brought tears to my eyes and I couldn't wait to get my orders and set sail for the Bungo Suido.

Read this...

http://www.subsim.com/sh4/silent_hunter4.php

and if you are still on the fence then it probably isn't for you.

JCC

OMG, crewmen aboard surface ships?
That's it I'm getting it straight after easter.

Thx again,
Brewster


:roll::sunny:

Personally, I'd say hold off - its not worth having as it stands, the bugs cripple it.

I have no doubt that it will be fixed in due course and then be great value, but what reason is there to waste your money right now - there is no guarantee that patch 1.2 will fix it to the extent it needs fixing. it won't get any more expensive to buy over time.

Hmm... What are the majority of the bugs related to, ie graphics, historical accuracy etc?

Maybe SH III+GWX is still the better option?

Worthwhile if you want to muck around with a beta submarine 'game' but if you want to play a campaign and or a semi-realistic simulation I dont think this is the one your after.

The game killers imo are the sudden damage of essential systems (like your periscopes being destroyed out of combat from diving surfacing the boat) for no 'apparent' reason, the sudden death of crew members for no 'apparent' reason and the damage control model (I spent 45 minutes yesterday babysitting the DC and managed to recover the boat from serious damage yet 3 seconds after I had all systems back in order, all the newly repaired systems suddenly sustained extreme damage, were all destroyed and my career ended yet I was out of combat and at periscope depth).

There are a lot of other problems, such as realism aspects (destroyers exploding while ramming your sub and single deck gun battle victories against multiple gun multiple warships) as well as crashing and imcomplete systems.

most of the bigger bugs are more related to interface than anything else.

the game is a good game, but it was released far too prematurely with very poor quality assurance and has a lot of maturing to do.

But it IS worth purchasing. IMHO

I'd say the problems are mostly related to game play, the previously noted damage control issues are a real pain in the proverbial, the torpedo speed/TDC issues don't help, the swarm of beelining a/c are a pain etc etc.

Put together it blows the ability to get into the game for me.

I genuinely believe that it WILL be a great game, but right now it ISN'T a decent game.

I suspect that the 1.2 patch will fix a fair few of the glaring problems, but the 1.3 and 1.4 patches (traditionally 1.4 is the final patch) will take a very long time to come out, because there will still be a lot of detail to fix and only two chances to fix it.

This game released too early, I'm back on SH 3 and monitoring developments with SH 4.

Of course YMMV.

Its worth every damn penny in my books, just got the game less than 24 hrs ago and ive had very little sleep :) My first career ending in a disaster on the first patrol got sunk by two bombers while crash diving. Second career also ended in a disaster,:roll: just finish dropping off a spy near japan recieved message to head to another hell on high water Jap infested patrol( what was my commander thinking this is my first patrol man i am yet to figure out the manual targeting.:o:D). Heading to my next objective i am hassled continously by aircraft - zeros & bombers then i finally get owned by what i think was mines :shifty: while crash diving all hell breaks loose, depth gauge showing 387feet and sinking, deeper i go into the abyss...

Thats two careers ended on first patrol:88)alot was through my careless use of gameplay -im trying to master the controls, I thought yeah first couple of patrols will be pretty relaxed no problem.

Started up third career and i am carefull as, plus pretty jumpy :rotfl:

Get SHIV its a blast.

Yes.

Dude don't just change your mind cause of one perosn, or get it because of what the others say. Read what is good/bad, the reviews, bug reports (sticky up top) keep in mind some bugs are not really bugs and the same went for SH3 ...oh and look what the modders are already doing. :up: There are genuine bugs, others are stuff the modders will have to fix (I am half convinced the devs set some things like air attacks to cater to the "action" crowd while allowing us realism types to tweak the cfgs.)

Anyway I will pick it up even if I can't play it yet just becasue I have faith in the devs and modders. :arrgh!:

Personally, I'm really looking forward to patch 1.2. And if it fixes some of the major bugs that are troubling my patrols then it'll be like Christmas Day. If you don't play it now you'll miss out on that experience. That's one way to look at it :p