SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)
-   -   Conflict in Syria (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=257885)

Dargo 12-17-24 03:07 PM

Russia will withdraw all its military forces from Syria within a month, information from sources close to the military operations department in Syria told The New Arab’s Arabic language sister publication, Al-Araby Al-Jadeed on Monday. Moscow has already withdrawn part of its combat military forces from the Hmeimim base, its largest base in Syria located in the Jableh region of Latakia’s countryside, the report said. Russia withdrew 10 percent of its combat military forces from Syria to Russia over the past two days as two aircraft had transported military equipment from the Hmeimim base to Russia daily, in batches of two or three, the report added. Citing information from the Abu Amin Observatory, a local war observer also known as Observatory 80 and works alongside the military operations department, Russian military forces in the Hmeimim air base, Jableh region, Tartous and Qamishli airport will all withdraw successively within a maximum period of one month. https://www.newarab.com/news/russia-...a-within-month

Skybird 12-17-24 06:14 PM

The Economist gets quoted in German media with a report on that the HTS and Russia have started formal negotiations. The HTS demands full diplomatic recognition and economic aid and cooperation for leaving the bases to Russia. A HTS spokesman gets quoted with that "it is not about ideology, but about interests." The HTS obviously wants to avoid getting isolated and cut off from foreign aid like the Taleban in Afghanistan. So far Russia has offered only humanitarian aid, The Economist reports further. It remains to be seen if they value their bases that much that they will comply with the Syrian demands.



According to military analysts, Russian bases moving to Libya would be more vulnerable to NATO attcks in case of a war, Syria is seen as the safer of the two safe havens.

Gorpet 12-18-24 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird (Post 2936849)
The Economist gets quoted in German media with a report on that the HTS and Russia have started formal negotiations. The HTS demands full diplomatic recognition and economic aid and cooperation for leaving the bases to Russia. A HTS spokesman gets quoted with that "it is not about ideology, but about interests." The HTS obviously wants to avoid getting isolated and cut off from foreign aid like the Taleban in Afghanistan. So far Russia has offered only humanitarian aid, The Economist reports further. It remains to be seen if they value their bases that much that they will comply with the Syrian demands.



According to military analysts, Russian bases moving to Libya would be more vulnerable to NATO attcks in case of a war, Syria is seen as the safer of the two safe havens.

Look,Turkey backed by the NATO collapsed Syria.It's just another chess move against Russia.I for one if i live long enough want to see NATO destroyed. They have become not the World's Defender's.The Ideology of Democracy is no different than the past Ideology's is it ? I live in the country where you would think freedom exist.I can't afford to leave this country and see what is across the ocean that separates us.
And this government.Will not allow it. We would never come back. World dominice and if it means billions will die so be it. As long as Democracy has its own thousand year existence. And the worst for you is knowing your country will be obliterated again. All because the world's wealthiest will kill to stay in power,.

Gorpet 12-18-24 02:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gorpet (Post 2936884)
Look,Turkey backed by the NATO collapsed Syria.It's just another chess move against Russia.I for one if i live long enough want to see NATO destroyed. They have become not the World's Defender's.The Ideology of Democracy is no different than the past Ideology's is it ? I live in the country where you would think freedom exist.I can't afford to leave this country and see what is across the ocean that separates us.
And this government.Will not allow it. We would never come back. World dominice and if it means billions will die so be it. As long as Democracy has its own thousand year existence. And the worst for you is knowing your country will be obliterated again. All because the world's wealthiest will kill to stay in power,.

Oh, Damn the restrictions are strong on Subsim. Do not think you will get 2 paragraphs of opinion here if your not blue.

Exocet25fr 12-18-24 06:02 AM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHtTrWbxSEc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIMWfJmti7E

Dargo 12-18-24 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird (Post 2936849)
The Economist gets quoted in German media with a report on that the HTS and Russia have started formal negotiations. The HTS demands full diplomatic recognition and economic aid and cooperation for leaving the bases to Russia. A HTS spokesman gets quoted with that "it is not about ideology, but about interests." The HTS obviously wants to avoid getting isolated and cut off from foreign aid like the Taleban in Afghanistan. So far Russia has offered only humanitarian aid, The Economist reports further. It remains to be seen if they value their bases that much that they will comply with the Syrian demands.



According to military analysts, Russian bases moving to Libya would be more vulnerable to NATO attcks in case of a war, Syria is seen as the safer of the two safe havens.

The new rulers face a huge task. More than 14 million refugees and displaced persons cannot return home properly until there is indeed a home. Most of the time, there is none. Reconstruction requires something of an economy, which also barely exists, plus some stability. That too is lacking in parts of the country where rival, sometimes Mafioso rebel groups call the shots. The new Syria lies in ruins, after 13 years of war. Car rides through Idlib province and around the city of Aleppo leave no doubt about that, elsewhere in the country it is no different. Entire villages and urban neighbourhoods have been shot to pieces. At best, concrete skeletons stand tall. Not a mortal to be seen.

The new government will have 14 provinces under its control, with a multitude of armed groups and minorities like alawites, Christians, Druze, not to mention the Kurds with their fait accompli, an autonomous region. If HTS makes a deal with the Russians, they will never get the foreign support Syria so desperately needs. Sanctions will not be lifted if we see the creation of an Islamic state, which none of the other factions will accept. The democratic Kurdish faction will not, and the Druze have already indicated that they would rather live under Israeli rule than under the next dictator, HTS. Who will help them Russia? Nah, so this rumor of Russia keeping its bases is just rumours there are no indications otherwise Russian FSB playing the western media.

Skybird 12-18-24 09:47 AM

^ That might be Western reasoning - but not nessecarily that of HTS.


Meanwhile it gets reported Turkey mulls a larger scale invasion of Syria, probably to go after the Kurds, and to widen its own influence inside Syria, Greater Turkey and Osmania 2.0 and all that... Confidence of such reports is undeclared.

Dargo 12-18-24 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird (Post 2936909)
^ That might be Western reasoning - but not nessecarily that of HTS.


Meanwhile it gets reported Turkey mulls a larger scale invasion of Syria, probably to go after the Kurds, and to widen its own influence inside Syria, Greater Turkey and Osmania 2.0 and all that... Confidence of such reports is undeclared.

This is reasoning of the HTS the economy of Idlib that is sanctioned HTS wants to get those lifted else HTS can not rule. Turkey does this for years not with boots but with air force support to the SNA turkey backed IS/Al-Qaeda groups. Nothing new, we know who is IS/Al-Qaeda and Turkey is one of them. Kurds fight for at least a decade on two fronts, IS/Al-Qaeda and Turkey.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sens. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) and Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.)
Attacks from Turkish-backed forces on our Syrian Kurdish partners undermine regional security and efforts to prevent an ISIS resurgence. Turkey must accept a ceasefire and demilitarized zone, or we’ll move forward with bipartisan sanctions legislation.https://thehill.com/policy/internati...asefire-syria/


Jimbuna 12-18-24 11:20 AM

Netanyahu's bold move: Israeli forces claim buffer zone in Syria

Quote:

The Prime Minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu, announced that Israeli troops would occupy a buffer zone in Syria "for the foreseeable future." This marks the first occurrence of an incumbent Israeli leader advancing so far into Syrian territory.

The decision to occupy the buffer zone has sparked a wave of criticism. Opponents accuse Israel of breaching the 1974 ceasefire and exploiting the turmoil in Syria to annex new territories.

In addition to conducting military operations against Hamas in the Gaza Strip, Israel has resolved to seize further areas in Syria.

According to Palestinian doctors, the Israeli assault on the Gaza Strip resulted in the deaths of at least eight family members, including women and children. The international organisation Médecins Sans Frontières reported the closure of the emergency room in southern Gaza due to the threat posed by Israeli military actions.
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world...89bb7713&ei=19

Skybird 12-18-24 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dargo (Post 2936911)
This is reasoning of the HTS the economy of Idlib that is sanctioned HTS wants to get those lifted else HTS can not rule.

Thats why HTS negotiates with Russia over diplomatic recognition - and economic support. If Russia gives that, they can do a deal. Who gives them that - is of secondary interest, and the Russians would not mind if the HTS later lets the mask fall and pisses the Western philantropists. "Interest before ideology." (^) Also, HTS is aware of Western concerns for Syria falling into a multi-front civil war, and that this outlook may prevent the West from being a reliable economic supporter. Hence, Russia maybe even is the preferred option, even if the civilian population hates them - the HTS seems to look at it quite pragmatic.



The Russian manouvering to bring their troops to the airfield maybe is just negotiation tactic, to mount pressure on the HTS: "We are on our way out anyway, so tone down your demands if you want aid from us, else we are gone."



Its all open, I only say that I do not take any results this or that way as granted in advance. Maybe the Russians leave for Libya for sure. But its premature to say already now that they do. What we know is that Russia and HTS hold negotiations. And apparently on a higher intensity level than with the envoy of the EU.

Dargo 12-18-24 12:27 PM

^Russia can not invest in Syria, it does not have the means or can lift the sanctions that are main reason for the state of the Syrian economy could not support Syria in the past also never in the future. If Russia could it had not let the Assad regime fall they had a stable person in power with HTS they have none certainty it will become unstable. Russia could/can only offer a lifeline, no structural aid for the Syrian economy. Nobody and utterly nobody will invest in a Russian vassal.

The situation in Libya is different from Syria; there, the Russians had official agreements with Assad, the country's sovereign leader. Haftar does not have that status, which means the Russians cannot set up an official air base either. Added to this, Haftar is 81 years old. His sons are already fighting over who will take over after their father's death, according to analysts. This does not help the warlord's stability as a potential partner of the Russians. A naval base near Port Sudan would give the Russians strategic access to the Red Sea. From there, the Russians would be able to reach more western countries in the Sahel by land. This would require an end to the Sudanese civil war, which has been raging in the East African country since April. Djibouti is strategically located on the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, through which a lot of cargo traffic between Europe and Asia passes. For this reason, China, Japan, Italy and France have bases there. The largest US army base on the African continent, Camp Lemonnier, is also located in Djibouti. The Russians first expressed in 2012 that they also wanted to settle in Djibouti, a request that Djibouti later rejected under US pressure, as the Djibouti government ‘wanted to prevent the country from becoming terrain for a proxy war’.

For HTS the only pragmatic option is going for the western and Arab block, they can lift sanctions that destroyed the Syrian economy and have the means to boost it. Russia, the pariah never it, is an origami tiger.

Russia is withdrawing advanced air-defense systems and other sophisticated arms from bases in Syria and shifting them to Libya, U.S. and Libyan officials said, as Moscow scrambles to preserve a military presence in the Middle East... https://www.wsj.com/world/russia-air...bya-25810db0?2 <- Paywall!

Jimbuna 12-19-24 12:34 PM

Syria not a threat to world, rebel leader Ahmed al-Sharaa tells BBC

Quote:

The de facto leader of Syria, Ahmed al-Sharaa, has said the country is exhausted by war and is not a threat to its neighbours or to the West.

In an interview with the BBC in Damascus, he called for sanctions on Syria to be lifted.

"Now, after all that has happened, sanctions must be lifted because they were targeted at the old regime. The victim and the oppressor should not be treated in the same way," he said.

Sharaa led the lightning offensive that toppled Bashar al-Assad's regime less than two weeks ago. He is the leader of the Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), the dominant group in the rebel alliance, and was previously known by his nom de guerre of Abu Mohammed al-Jolani.

He said HTS should be de-listed as a terrorist organisation. It is designated as one by the UN, US, EU and UK, among many others, as it started as a splinter group of al-Qaeda, which it broke away from in 2016.

Sharaa said HTS was not a terrorist group.

They did not target civilians or civilian areas, he said. In fact, they considered themselves to be victim of the crimes of the Assad regime.

He denied that he wanted to turn Syria into a version of Afghanistan.

Sharaa said the countries were very different, with different traditions. Afghanistan was a tribal society. In Syria, he said, there was a different mindset.

He said he believed in education for women.

"We've had universities in Idlib for more than eight years," Sharaa said, referring to Syria's north-western province that has been held by rebels since 2011.

"I think the percentage of women in universities is more than 60%."

And when asked whether the consumption of alcohol would be allowed, Sharaa said: "There are many things I just don't have the right to talk about because they are legal issues."

He added that there would be a "Syrian committee of legal experts to write a constitution. They will decide. And any ruler or president will have to follow the law".

Sharaa was relaxed throughout the interview, wearing civilian clothes, and tried to offer reassurance to all those who believe his group has not broken with its extremist past.

Many Syrians do not believe him.

The actions of Syria's new rulers in the next few months will indicate the kind of country they want Syria to be - and the way they want to rule it.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c05p9g2nqmeo

mapuc 12-19-24 04:41 PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=efKFRgGzI80

Markus

Jimbuna 12-20-24 01:45 PM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7pt9xXIP0s

Dargo 12-20-24 07:36 PM

‪After a US meeting with HTS leader today, Barbara Leaf said Ahmad al-Sharaa (AKA Jolani) had committed to not allowing terror groups to operate in Syria and threaten US or neighbouring countries. As a result, the US won’t pursue $10 million “reward for justice” on al-Sharaa. https://www.axios.com/2024/12/20/us-...eet-hts-leader


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:54 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.