SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 4: Wolves of the Pacific (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=202)
-   -   Is this it? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=118431)

John Channing 07-14-07 05:51 PM

Quote:

Quote Skybird:

Spare your sighs. I talked critically about publishing companies, not developers.

Which, in this case, are one and the same.

And I doubt my wife would let me show some adultry. I'll ask.

JCC

scrapser 07-14-07 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird
I cannot different than agree with the starting post of scrapser - essentially it is the same that I have preached since years, especially where he says:

Quote:

The solution here is to stop buying software from a company once it's known they will release incomplete products to the public. Make them accountable or this will only get worse. Of course I realize the vast majority of the buying public knows nothing of this issue and is out there blindly buying garbage and being wowed by all the pretty bells and whistles, so I'm not expecting anything but it still remains that our purchase is our vote and as long as people keep buying crap, the companies out there will gladly supply more.

Actually, I think I've changed my tune on that statement. It sounds good on paper but is never really going to happen...and besides, where would we draw the line on what constitutes an acceptable product and who's not making it? It would be unrealistic I think.

I think the more constructive approach is what is happening here...having a dialog of ideas and things tried. This is where we are and where we must move forward from.

kiwi_2005 07-14-07 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scrapser
This is not a rant. :roll:

Anyway, I'm hoping there will be another patch that brings this sim to the standard we all expect (i.e., "finished"). I bought the game the day it was released and still have not played it. I patched 1.3 last night but today have started reading about the issues that still remain (mag torpedoes always on, transparent crew on deck, non-functioning periscope animation, to name a few). Incredible!

Go on install the game!

Mag Torpedoes? I have no idea i just load and fire away.
Transparent crew always on? Nope mine dont look transparent.
Non function periscope animation. Nope it works.

Played one patrol since patch 3, SS boat 1941, and must of had one of the best patrols since owning the game. Attacking a taskforce the AI do now ping and attack you like they should i spent more time evading the taskforce than attacking them. Plus it was just on evening, a storm happening and only 180 feet of water beneath me.

This is a great game. You should first load her up and try the game yourself then come back here and see if you have the same thoughts.

[ A little Aussie gaming magazine gave Silent Hunter 4 a 9/10 score said its the best subsim to come out since Aces of the Deep a better update from silent hunter 3. Just recently SH4 was added in their top 100 of best games. The reviewer has been reviewing subsims since Fast Attack so is no noob. Yes shock horror i expected a score of 7, yet he gave it a 9. PCPowerplay might not be known in the states or UK well enough but they have a 300 thousand plus following of gamers.]

9 out 10. Gotta love the aussies :arrgh!:

jdkbph 07-14-07 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kiwi_2005
9 out 10. Gotta love the aussies :arrgh!:


Does UBI advertise in that mag?

:D

JD

Von Tonner 07-15-07 07:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Channing
Which in this case are one and the same.

And I doubt my wife would let me show some adultry. I'll ask.

JCC

That is an interesting point you make there John, (not the adultry one:D), but the one that the publishers and developers are one and the same. Are any of the developers also on the Board of Directors of Ubi that you know of?

John Channing 07-15-07 07:28 AM

Nope... they are not. They are employees of Ubisoft Romania Studios.

Ubisoft is a huge, international corporation.

JCC

PS She said "No way, even if Skybird advises it".

Shiplord 07-15-07 07:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kiwi_2005
Transparent crew always on? Nope mine dont look transparent.

- activate environment effects
- activate volumetric fog
- start quick mission "Against all odds"
- go to bridge
- look at the sailor behind you

Quote:

Non function periscope animation. Nope it works.
not the scope animation itself, the animation of the moving brass scope pipes inside the coning tower is now switched off (worked until this patch)

Von Tonner 07-15-07 12:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Channing
Nope... they are not. They are employees of Ubisoft Romania Studios.

Ubisoft is a huge, international corporation.

JCC

PS She said "No way, even if Skybird advises it".

:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

You are right about Ubi. Until I googled it I did not realise just how big this company is. My first game (apart from arcade) was Myst and I still think the graphics in that game have not been surpassed.

Kippling 07-15-07 01:50 PM

In response to OP:

I agree wholeheartedly. It was totally unacceptable for UBI to release this game when they did, in it's unfinished state. I too bought it soon after realease and I was dismayed at the state it was in. Yes, there are pressures to release a game as soon as possible, but that does not mean a game should be published when it is essentially not finished.

I do some coding as part of my job too, I'm a control systems engineer. I too am under pressure to get projects finished within a certain time frame, but at the end of the day if something doesn't work as intended it simply shouldn't be considered finished and ready for use. Imagine this: You've bought a new car, but everytime you use the air conditioning or open a window the engine cuts out. You'd want your money back, right? Just because a game costs less than a car doesn't invalidate that reasoning, it's still acceptable to want it to work as it should when you buy it.

As for the people saying 'I dont care, thats just the way it is with software', you're not helping the situation. The fact that you're willing to just suck it up and get ripped off without complaining just means it's going to happen again. Make some noise and try and get your money back, whatever. Dont let this big publisher get away with selling you faulty software.

maerean_m 07-15-07 05:16 PM

It's called greed http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/64.gif.

They let the dev team work for 2.5 years on SH3 and it got the 100 mark from Neal.

When it was time for SH4 they gave it 11 months. When the time was up, they sent it to be written on the dvd. The game manual was hit even harder since it had to be translated in so many languages. Many of the game's features where not even implemented when the manual had to be finished. That's why many "screenshots" in the manual are actualy design mock-ups done in Photoshop (e.g. Crew management screen).

In short, it's called greed and greed dehumanizes people (and ruins perfect games like Silent Hunter).
It's plain wickedness to not have let Silent Hunter shine out of the box and be a contender for the game of the year, the way SH3 was.

It was only the quality of the dev team that managed to get these results in such a short time http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/77.gif.

Vorkapitan 07-15-07 07:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dean_acheson
Creative Labs X-Fi Elite Pro

have you used this with Vista yet?

I have an audiology 2 ZS and since installing Vista it only will give me 2.1. With headphones I only get sound out of the left ear.

I've used about sixteen different drivers from Creative, both for XP and the new, wonderful vista drivers that took Creative about ten months to make.

Still no *^%*@#^ surround sound. No EAX. The only options are 'mono' and 'stereo.'

So, I was wondering, does YOUR creative sound card work with 5.1 or 6.1 or even 4.1?

Oh, my periscopes work, and I've heard the new surround sound stuff is pretty cool. Too bad that I don't know because my STUPID sound card wont' work with this OS.

That's not a rant. I just hate creative, dell, and microsoft at the moment. My SH4 seems to run pretty well, and all the junk works.

If UBI decides to build anyother cool WW2 sim, I'll buy it.

Hi Dean,
I have Audigy 2z.....at first no sound with Vista, messed with everything, got the vista drivers, but no go. I removed all drivers, installed my orig. drivers, no go. I removed the sound card, tried again and now got some sound. Insalled Vista drivers again over the orig. drivers and "WALLA" sound again. (be sure to set the speakers to the right setting) :know: :know:

Joe

Skybird 07-15-07 08:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Channing
Nope... they are not. They are employees of Ubisoft Romania Studios.

Ubisoft is a huge, international corporation.

JCC

PS She said "No way, even if Skybird advises it".

Hm, wondering what the hell you are meaning, I invested some time into online research (I do not have the word in qestion in my two dictionaries) - and just learned how terribly off track I was :lol: Please take it with humour - this is, after all, a very foreign language for me, so sometimes... :lol: - the word I wanted to express was adulthood, of course. :dead:

:-j

SteamWake 07-15-07 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird
Quote:

Originally Posted by John Channing
Nope... they are not. They are employees of Ubisoft Romania Studios.

Ubisoft is a huge, international corporation.

JCC

PS She said "No way, even if Skybird advises it".

Hm, wondering what the hell you are meaning, I invested some time into online research (I do not have the word in qestion in my two dictionaries) - and just learned how terribly off track I was :lol: Please take it with humour - this is, after all, a very foreign language for me, so sometimes... :lol: - the word I wanted to express was adulthood, of course. :dead:

:-j

I think you mean 'mature' ;)

dcb 07-16-07 12:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maerean_m
It's called greed http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/64.gif.

They let the dev team work for 2.5 years on SH3 and it got the 100 mark from Neal.

When it was time for SH4 they gave it 11 months. When the time was up, they sent it to be written on the dvd. The game manual was hit even harder since it had to be translated in so many languages. Many of the game's features where not even implemented when the manual had to be finished. That's why many "screenshots" in the manual are actualy design mock-ups done in Photoshop (e.g. Crew management screen).

In short, it's called greed and greed dehumanizes people (and ruins perfect games like Silent Hunter).
It's plain wickedness to not have let Silent Hunter shine out of the box and be a contender for the game of the year, the way SH3 was.

It was only the quality of the dev team that managed to get these results in such a short time http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/77.gif.


:huh: WOW. I'm speechless. This! Coming from a dev! You must have been put under a real stress, guys, by the suits back at UBI HQ, to write this post. If things really got this bad for you, you are commendable for getting this game out, in whatever state it may have come. i always had the impression you got 2 years to develop it, but 11 MONTHS! That's tight schedule, indeed. And one more bravo for fully fixing it with patch 1.3. Now I understand even this patch had to be "fought over" with the UBI suits. I think you really earned this::rock:http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/77.gif.

heartc 07-16-07 01:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcb

:huh: WOW. I'm speechless. This! Coming from a dev! You must have been put under a real stress, guys, by the suits back at UBI HQ, to write this post. If things really got this bad for you, you are commendable for getting this game out, in whatever state it may have come. i always had the impression you got 2 years to develop it, but 11 MONTHS! That's tight schedule, indeed. And one more bravo for fully fixing it with patch 1.3. Now I understand even this patch had to be "fought over" with the UBI suits. I think you really earned this::rock:http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/77.gif.

Wtf. I'm pretty sure maerean_m is not a dev. Not everybody from Bucharest, Romania is a SHIV dev. As far as I know we only have one dev participating in this forum from time to time - I forgot his name right now, but it wasn't maerean.

And pls, stop this "big evil companies" talk. It's getting old and it's making you all look like a bunch of losers.

Navarre 07-16-07 02:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heartc
Wtf. I'm pretty sure maerean_m is not a dev. Not everybody from Bucharest, Romania is a SHIV dev.

one cannot say it exactly, but at least the link in his profile refers to a side of a SHIV dev. http://maerean.3x.ro/iSite2/index.html

from the SHIV dev bio
http://silenthunter4.us.ubi.com/devbio.php

MIHAI MAEREAN Game Programmer
http://silenthunter4.us.ubi.com/imag...ai_maerean.jpg

dcb 07-16-07 03:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heartc
And pls, stop this "big evil companies" talk. It's getting old and it's making you all look like a bunch of losers.

Well, sir, you are entitled to your own opinions. But I don't feel one inch like a loser, and insulting this whole community isn't very nice of your part. Anyway, please make clear who - in your opinion - would qualify as a "loser" here. Now bring on your flammenwerfer and start flaming here as much as you'd like.

ReM 07-16-07 04:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shiplord
[not the scope animation itself, the animation of the moving brass scope pipes inside the coning tower is now switched off (worked until this patch)

If you have nothing else to worry about, consider yourself lucky.......it has nothing to do with the game, it's only eye candy....

I couldn't care less....

TDK1044 07-16-07 06:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heartc
Quote:

Originally Posted by dcb

:huh: WOW. I'm speechless. This! Coming from a dev! You must have been put under a real stress, guys, by the suits back at UBI HQ, to write this post. If things really got this bad for you, you are commendable for getting this game out, in whatever state it may have come. i always had the impression you got 2 years to develop it, but 11 MONTHS! That's tight schedule, indeed. And one more bravo for fully fixing it with patch 1.3. Now I understand even this patch had to be "fought over" with the UBI suits. I think you really earned this::rock:http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/77.gif.

Wtf. I'm pretty sure maerean_m is not a dev. Not everybody from Bucharest, Romania is a SHIV dev. As far as I know we only have one dev participating in this forum from time to time - I forgot his name right now, but it wasn't maerean.

And pls, stop this "big evil companies" talk. It's getting old and it's making you all look like a bunch of losers.



Yes he is a Dev. We have several Devs as Forum members here, including the lead game designer.

Herr Karl 07-16-07 07:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by maerean_m
It's called greed http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/64.gif.

They let the dev team work for 2.5 years on SH3 and it got the 100 mark from Neal.

When it was time for SH4 they gave it 11 months. When the time was up, they sent it to be written on the dvd. The game manual was hit even harder since it had to be translated in so many languages. Many of the game's features where not even implemented when the manual had to be finished. That's why many "screenshots" in the manual are actualy design mock-ups done in Photoshop (e.g. Crew management screen).

In short, it's called greed and greed dehumanizes people (and ruins perfect games like Silent Hunter).
It's plain wickedness to not have let Silent Hunter shine out of the box and be a contender for the game of the year, the way SH3 was.

It was only the quality of the dev team that managed to get these results in such a short time http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/...ticons7/77.gif.

I can appreciate your frustration and I believe it to be true, that the game you put your time into developing would have easily been the Simulation Game of the Year and possibly Game of the Year if given adequate time for a realistic release schedule.

That said, I really like that you have been visiting us on a regular basis. No other game I've ever purchased, have the developer(s) been this pro-active.

It is a great game. I believe as a developer you deserve better than what you have recieved from Ubi management.

Kudo's to you maerean_m :up:

Thank you for your time and commitment.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:52 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.