SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)
-   -   Wallabies vs Lions (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=205275)

TarJak 06-29-13 08:45 AM

Bad call Bossmark. Great game. Wallabies FTW.

Jimbuna 06-29-13 08:53 AM

Was another close run game.

Final game to be the decider then.

troopie 06-29-13 08:56 AM

Good to see the lads get up! Bring on game three!

BossMark 06-29-13 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 2077145)
Bad call Bossmark. Great game. Wallabies FTW.

Yep very bad, I sky+ it as was going to watch it when I got in from work, but you always get one gobby git who cant keep it shut :stare:

TarJak 06-29-13 05:21 PM

Good to see the Poms and paddy's kept tryless this match. The decider is shaping up to be a cracking game.

bertieck476 06-30-13 02:26 PM

Didnt see the match but when I saw the team selection I just thought we wouldnt do it.
Well done oz,all down to last test.

TarJak 07-01-13 06:16 PM

Disappointing to hear Warbuton will be out for the decided. Horwill will find out if he joins him on the sidelines today.

TarJak 07-01-13 09:42 PM

Horwill has been cleared a second time: http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-union/un...702-2p8yj.html

I can't understand the IRB taking the unprecedented step to review the case, given he was already exonerated.

Anyway it will be interesting to see how the two camps react. One losing their captain the other retaining him for the final game.

Can't wait till Saturday night!

Jimbuna 07-02-13 10:24 AM

This may well tip the scales against the Lions and if so will be a talking point of contention for quite a while after the series ends.

TarJak 07-02-13 04:58 PM

I agree. Shame Warburton is injured as he's a great captain who does a lot for the morale of the team. I still think it will be close and of course hope the Wallabies came make it an historic series win. Best of luck to the Lions though, they are a very good side.

bertieck476 07-02-13 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 2078604)
I agree. Shame Warburton is injured as he's a great captain who does a lot for the morale of the team. I still think it will be close and of course hope the Wallabies came make it an historic series win. Best of luck to the Lions though, they are a very good side.

I believe warburton is not the best 7 in wales let alone the 4 nations and his form did not warrant selection, the irb appeal is probably because if you look at the footage it seems incomprehensible that he didnt tread on him on purpose.

TarJak 07-02-13 06:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bertieck476 (Post 2078628)
I believe warburton is not the best 7 in wales let alone the 4 nations and his form did not warrant selection, the irb appeal is probably because if you look at the footage it seems incomprehensible that he didnt tread on him on purpose.

So why is he on the squad as captain?

Clearly both IRB tribunals thought otherwise on Horwill. Read the article I linked to whcih explains the process and decisions of both. I watched the game live and there was absolutely no comment about it at the time it occured. Looking at the footage, I'd say he was rucking as he is allowed, but don't think it was definately a deliberate act. If you stick your head in a ruck, expect to get it kicked.

bertieck476 07-03-13 02:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 2078640)
So why is he on the squad as captain?

Clearly both IRB tribunals thought otherwise on Horwill. Read the article I linked to whcih explains the process and decisions of both. I watched the game live and there was absolutely no comment about it at the time it occured. Looking at the footage, I'd say he was rucking as he is allowed, but don't think it was definately a deliberate act. If you stick your head in a ruck, expect to get it kicked.

This to many people is baffling, some suggest its because of the working relationship sam and gatland have in the wales setup, bear in mind sam does not even captain his club side his recent performances before the lions tour were ordinary at best even though gatland said he would pick the touring party on merit, granted he communicates with the ref well which sometimes is the only time you realise he is even playing.

I understand the process of the tribunals but I am dubious about his defence, admittedly when I watched the match I did not even see it but when its slowed down you can clearly see him tread on him, the laws on rucking have changed from the day when you could rake a player out who was laying in the way but even then you didnt touch the head and in this case it was a lions ball that was never going to be turned over, so no justification for a shoeing in the old fashioned way as he was not slowing oz ball or laying in the way.

I have just seen the lions team for the final test and would like to congratulate the wallabies on there series win.

Jimbuna 07-03-13 06:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bertieck476 (Post 2078818)

I have just seen the lions team for the final test and would like to congratulate the wallabies on there series win.

Have you recently received a blow to the head? :):03:

bertieck476 07-03-13 08:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jimbuna (Post 2078864)
Have you recently received a blow to the head? :):03:

Unfortunately no, its just how I see it.

Jimbuna 07-03-13 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bertieck476 (Post 2078916)
Unfortunately no, its just how I see it.

Actually, having just watched the BBC news I must agree :-?

TarJak 07-05-13 12:07 AM

Deans picking George Smith and Gatland dropping O'Driscoll. The coaches are certainly pulling some surprises.:huh:

Jimbuna 07-05-13 05:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 2079686)
Deans picking George Smith and Gatland dropping O'Driscoll. The coaches are certainly pulling some surprises.:huh:

At the end of the game Gatland will either be a phenomenal head coach or a dismal failure.

TarJak 07-05-13 05:37 PM

Deans the same.

BossMark 07-06-13 04:14 AM

Should be a great game too close to call


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:33 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.