SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 5 (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=244)
-   -   What do you feel about SH5 now? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=169376)

GerritJ9 05-12-10 02:58 PM

"Haven't bought it, and never will" has been my position from the start, and still is. I hoped for further expansions for SH4, which would add RN, IJN and RNethN, thus making SH4 represent all nations whose navies used subs in the Far East as the Atlantic is less interesting to me.
No such luck. Instead, another U-Boot sim. It got worse: one sub type only, and only until 1943. Interest dropped further. Then the killer: DRM. I already had two sims with DRM (Distant Guns and Jutland) and much as I love these, I would definitely not buy them again because of the DRM SES use, even though it's by no means as intrusive as UBI's. This applies to ALL sims with DRM as far as I'm concerned. And judging by the reviews and everything that has been posted here and elsewhere, I'm not missing anything, really. The only things about SH5 that interest me are the ships such as "Emden", which hopefully will be reverse-engineered for SH4. Firstly, they would make great additions to the "Battle for the Baltic" campaign. Even more importantly, "Emden" would make a useful stand-in for the "Java" and "Sumatra" until somebody makes an accurate model for them- the RNethN's cupboard is rather bare :(.

mikeydredd 05-12-10 04:05 PM

I voted "haven't bought this game and I will probably not buy it".

From what I'm reading version 1.1 with mods is far superior to version 1.2 without. Ubi seem to have dropped the ball again.

My real position is will NEVER buy this as long as it is hamstrung by this version of DRM.

EVER.

Dredd :arrgh!:

Méo 05-12-10 04:18 PM

I wonder how long the obsession around this game will last...

Nordmann 05-12-10 04:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Méo (Post 1390423)
I wonder how long the obsession around this game will last...

The obsession with DRM you mean? They'll probably never get over it, unfortunately.

commandosolo2009 05-12-10 04:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins (Post 1389811)
Until the DRM is eliminated the game can be pure gold and it will STILL be a case of a game company treating us like criminals and asking us to trust them to continue to run a miserly three servers. Trust is a two way street and I don't trust 'em. End of story.

agreed capt. robbins 100%:yeah:

Méo 05-12-10 04:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nordmann (Post 1390439)
The obsession with DRM you mean? They'll probably never get over it, unfortunately.

DRM or not, patch or no patch, rely on mods or not...

I just wonder for how long people who hate so much this game will feel the need to express their obsession.

Nordmann 05-12-10 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Méo (Post 1390448)
DRM or not, patch or no patch, rely on mods or not...

I just wonder for how long people who hate so much this game will feel the need to express their obsession.

Well, they obviously don't hate it as much as they claim, if they are viewing/posting in the SH5 board.

You have to wonder at the logic of these people at times.

krashkart 05-12-10 05:00 PM

Wow, I'm one of six that might buy it at some point. :yawn:

robbo180265 05-12-10 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by krashkart (Post 1390465)
Wow, I'm one of six that might buy it at some point. :yawn:

I saw that:up:

flag4 05-12-10 05:21 PM

i will buy this sim, but i'll probably be pushin' 50 when i do - please take into account how long it has taken SH3 to get to the glorious game/sim/passion that it has become; some idea how old i am now:woot:

sarcastic remarks welcome:salute:

IanC 05-12-10 05:37 PM

Total fiasco, no doubt about it.
I always believed that in a couple of years we could play SH5 with some kind of Super-Mod and it would be a great subsim, right up there with SH3+GWX.
But now, I'm even doubting that. There's a limit to what modders can do, so if this game doesn't get patched properly there might be some hard-coded holes they won't be able to fill.

Sailor Steve 05-12-10 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flag4 (Post 1390481)
sarcastic remarks welcome:salute:

I would never do that...junior.:O::D

janh 05-12-10 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Méo (Post 1390448)
DRM or not, patch or no patch, rely on mods or not...

I just wonder for how long people who hate so much this game will feel the need to express their obsession.

The ones who truly hate it are probably long gone. But there are a quite a few persistent onlookers here, me included, that still hope that all this makes a turn to the better. One can only hope that Ubi Romania was not already completely put on a different project but will finally deliver some better patches and content additions than thus far. That, and if the DRM goes one day, I bet Ubi will report a surge in SHV sales. My money they still might get, but only if they start returning value for dollar.

However, presently it looks worse and worse with every week that passes to me as an outsider. Happy news on SHV? Where? When?

JackAubrey 05-12-10 06:40 PM

With this kind of DRM, I will never buy *any* game.

mobucks 05-12-10 06:46 PM

you guys are such aggressive haters haha

Madox58 05-12-10 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mobucks (Post 1390594)
you guys are such aggressive haters haha

Now I've added you to my Hate list Mate!
Just kidding.
:haha:
:hmmm:
Or am I?
Sometimes I hate my wife.
But don't tell her I said that.
I'd be doing dishes for ever!

No Dear, I'm not on the internet!
Was just checking my E-Mail and sorry I didn't get the trash............

Méo 05-12-10 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by janh (Post 1390568)
The ones who truly hate it are probably long gone.

Not all of them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by janh (Post 1390568)
However, presently it looks worse and worse with every week that passes to me as an outsider.

Well, you've said it, it looks. There are folks here who really enjoy to make things worse than they really are. (and still some of them never played it at all...)

Quote:

Originally Posted by janh (Post 1390568)
Happy news on SHV? Where? When?

I guess we'll just have to be very patient.

7thSeal 05-12-10 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by janh (Post 1390568)
My money they still might get, but only if they start returning value for dollar.

Sadly, we don't live in that type of gaming world anymore... really,,, a console game $60 is value for dollar? yeah for them you bet it is. ;)

krashkart 05-12-10 09:02 PM

I'm still evolving a little on this. Just waiting out the hard evolution this portion of the series seems to be going through... kinda reminds me of the scenes in "The Search For Spock"; after Spock is reborn he is in constant agonizing pain because of his accelerated growth. :)

V.C. Sniper 05-12-10 09:04 PM

won't ever buy it.

sh5 sucks plain and simple... just like how the game is


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.