I agree with a 3
 

If they would have released this game with fewer bugs and some better visuals It would have been Better. I say take SH3 and put SH4's graphics to it And you would have an unstopable killer game!! But instead I get to drop off a spy on Honshu for EVERY SINGLE MISSION OF THE ENTIRE WAR!!!!! :arrgh!:

For those of you that are not familiar with Morgan and Adam' style, I doubt they have ever given a serious review of any game. Satire and humor always at the games and their expense. They will only review games as released, never patched.
Game reviews are rarely longer than 1 to 2 minutes....and they're trying to put out some information along with the jokes, it's TV folks its supposed to be entertaining.

The review was accurate....3 out of 5....hardcore submariners will love. Face it people its a niche game, it ain't gonna out sell God of War II. I personally give it a 3 out of 5, with the hope that it will be fixed and then earn the seldom issued 5 out 5.

It's got to be a joke review because the unpatched game isn't worth 1, let alone 3. Patched maybe a 3. Everything working it would be a 6.


I don't understand why people belittle FPS games though. FPS games are the reason that PCs can play games at all. FPS games were at the forefront of pushing hardware along. Without them SH4 would consist solely of the map screen and some paper cutouts. Yes they aren't for everyone (I'm too old and have played too many to be interested any longer), but they aren't solely the province of the labotomy-class gamer.

VB