SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   Surface Surprise. Good tactic against light escorts. (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=102805)

Jimbuna 12-30-06 08:22 AM

Yeah...the mods have absolutely no bearing on patrol grid allocation. It tends to happen randomly and that's just one of many reasons I use SH3Commander (to enable me to change the grid) :up:

RAM 12-30-06 08:50 AM

I found a list of all HMS Storm's surface actions in uboat.net. The surface action I was talking about is the noted under the 23th July entry. Note the two escort ships sunk by the british submarine in that battle:

Also note that Lt. Young conducted an attack against one U-boat sent to resupply the monsun boats based at Penang (The action is described in the book, but it's not said that it was a german U-boat, I didn't know this)


12 Mar, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks a small Japanese vessel with gunfire in the Malacca Strait.

15 Apr, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) torpedoes and sinks the Japanese minesweeper W 7 (738 tons, offsite link) off the Andaman Islands in position 11º34'N, 93º08'E. (see map)

18 Jun, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) torpedoes and sinks the Japanese auxiliary gunboat Eiko Maru (3011 BRT) in the Strait of Malacca off off Penang, Malaya in position 05.59N, 99.10E. (see map)

20 Jun, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) attacks the German submarine U-1062 with torpedoes in the Malacca Strait. The torpedoes however miss their target. The u-boat had left Penang the previous day.

23 Jul, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks the Japanese army cargo ship Kiso Maru (554 BRT) and two Japanese patrol vessels with gunfire off Port Owen, Andaman Islands in position 14.00N, 96.50E. (see map)

1 Aug, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks 4 Japanese sailing vessels with gunfire of the Mergui Archipelago, Burma.

2 Sep, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks five small Japanese vessels with gunfire.

29 Oct, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks two Japanese sailing vessels with gunfire in the Gulf of Boni, Celebes, Netherlands East Indies

1 Nov, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks two Japanese sailing vessels with gunfire in the Gulf of Boni, Celebes, Netherlands East Indies.

2 Nov, 1944
HMS Storm (Lt. E.P. Young, DSC, RNVR) sinks seven Japanese sailing vessels with gunfire in the Gulf of Boni, Celebes, Netherlands East Indies.


http://uboat.net/allies/warships/ship/3450.html

Sailor Steve 12-30-06 11:56 AM

Is there any indication of what types the two patrol vessels were? How were they armed.

An interesting discrepency. I'm not saying it means anything, as I have found many different reports that don't always match other reports; as I say, it's just interesting:

Quote:

14 April 1944:
Indian Ocean. Arrives at Port Blair, Andaman Islands. Unloads. [1]


Author's Note:
[1] Some sources claim W-7 was attacked by Royal Navy (Volunteer Reserve) LtCdr Edward Young’s submarine HMS STORM and sank at 11-34N, 93-08E.

http://www.combinedfleet.com/W-7_t.htm

Also, looking at various ship sinking lists, I've found 3 other Kiso Marus, one sunk by US aircraft, one sunk by USS Bonefish and the third sunk by USS Tinosa. I'm trying to find out why so many ships had the same name.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.