SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 5 (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=244)
-   -   The gawd-almighty merged DRM in Silent Hunter V thread (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=160764)

sergei 01-27-10 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248643)
Go fire up Fallout 3 without an internet connection, smart guy. Tell me how that works out for you.

Seems to work out just fine for me.
For some reason my copy of Fallout 3 does not insist that I stay connected to the internet whenever I play it.
Strange.

bigboywooly 01-27-10 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sailor Steve (Post 1248694)
I don't have an internet connection at all. Do I count?

Apparently not
Nor large parts of Aus as posters have already posted
Or those in rural areas
Meh
As long as Trenken can play all is well and the rest of us can go whistle

mookiemookie 01-27-10 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248682)
Well I just dont see things that way.

Then it's absolutely crystal clear that you have no idea what you're talking about in terms of modding as it relates to the SH series.

simsurfer 01-27-10 04:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248564)
No, it allows them to create their own expansions and actually try to turn a decent profit on this franchise. When they can make more money, thats good for us too you know. Thats means we get more games.

None of us knows if this would have been the end of the road for SH, its certainly always possible in a genre like this. But if they can put a great expansion out, get a bunch of us to buy it, well that certainly helps raise the chances for SH6. Or if SH6 was going to happen either way, then it gives them some more $$ to dump into it. That works for me.

Thats how I look at things. I dont think about things in just the short term all the time, all negative about everything, hanging on to the past, only worried about myself. I actually want them to make as much money as possible, and ill give some of mine to them if I feel the expansions are good enough. Many people will regardless. You dont have to buy SH5 if you dont want.

You actually "believe" this?

trenken 01-27-10 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sergei (Post 1248700)
Seems to work out just fine for me.
For some reason my version of Fallout 3 does not insist that I stay connected to the internet whenever I play it.
Strange.

Noone said it needs constant connection, just that it needs internet to launch it, unless you're using FOSE, which I dont. Its a way to bypass the Steam and GFWL log-ins. I dont use it though.

If you have internet to launch a game, you should have it to run it. This is a single player game, its using the server for very minimal tasks. You could probably stream a movie while playing this game and I think you'll be just fine.

Sailor Steve 01-27-10 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248697)
I dont mean YOU by the way, obviously you're on the internet, I mean those without it.

No, I'm not. I'm posting from my local library. I'm on a very limited income, and the simple price of a regular connection is way out of my league. If the wave of the future is doing things that way, then I guess I'll go back to playing the old games, and maybe read more.:dead:

karamazovnew 01-27-10 04:03 PM

Trenken really now... for someone accusing us of having zero knowledge about DRM... it's just.... GOD!

DRM has been around since the first game where you had to put a floppy in just to play it. Double so for Cd's back in the 90's. Back then a hard-disk was sometimes 10 times smaller than a CD.

After the CD blanks and recorders came around, the companies had to implement disk-checking. That was also broken either through emulating the disk or changing executable files.

Fallout 3, Spore, Mass Effect 2 all fall into this category. Even Steam games! Heck, it only took a month to crack GTA4. Most games get cracked before they get to the shops!

99.9% of games share this easy to brake DRM that is more or less intrusive on the player that actually buys the game:
- some require online activation at first start (Spore)
- some require online check at every start (3d Sex Villa, shut up :oops:)
- Most require the DVD to be in the drive through Starforce, Securom or other DRM's
Most players just get cracks for them to prevent damaging their disks. I have a few mint-condition games myself, never removed from box.

Then there are games that have been cracked but also provide Online features for which you do need to register online and BE online: L4D, all MMO's, Rise of Flight. Again all of these have MULTIPLAYER as their main attraction.

SH5 will be the first game ever to require you to stay online permanently to play in OFFLINE! What part of that don't you get? If you have a good net connection, good for you, most of us don't.

trenken 01-27-10 04:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mookiemookie (Post 1248703)
Then it's absolutely crystal clear that you have no idea what you're talking about in terms of modding as it relates to the SH series.

You're right, ive only been playing these games for many years now. Im just not stuck in the past, thats all. Modding is over, let it go. Its up to ubi, so ill just roll with the flow. Crying about it here will do nothing for me.

trenken 01-27-10 04:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sailor Steve (Post 1248708)
No, I'm not. I'm posting from my local library. I'm on a very limited income, and the simple price of a regular connection is way out of my league. If the wave of the future is doing things that way, then I guess I'll go back to playing the old games, and maybe read more.:dead:

Yeah thats just the way it will be. Everything is on the internet now, a time will come when you cant even buy physical media anymore, digital distribution is the natural progression of things. That wont work for you at all.

Just saying, they cant worry about every soul on earth.

badkarma 01-27-10 04:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248697)
They'll be left behind, happens every generation, people unwilling to accept the new ways of things. Its happening on this very site today.

Yeah, how dare they not be willing to move house. Absurd!
I've never seen someone on these forums in all my time here that acted like a little self-absorbed child playing some Halo game.. I guess no forum is free from such "people".

Sailor Steve 01-27-10 04:06 PM

Poor you when you have a total power outage. You might not survive it.

sergei 01-27-10 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248707)
Noone said it needs constant connection, just that it needs internet to launch it

But the point is that SH5 WILL need a constant connection the whole time you are playing.
Which is one of the reasons why people here are getting so annoyed.
Not really comparing like with like are you?

badkarma 01-27-10 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248711)
Crying about it here will do nothing for me.

But repeatedly arguing your opinions is giving you thrills?

floundericiousWA 01-27-10 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1248669)
Because, then you get people creating their own content and they dont see any money out of it. Its just the way it is, people forget that these are businesses, they need money to survive.

We're all adults here, you cant see things from their perspective as well? With DRM, it kills modding, and allows them to make some more money selling maybe a dev tool for the community which ive seen, and sell expansions. Its good for them and turns out to be good for us in the end as well.

It could kill modding (though that didn't stop SHIII from having some truly awesome, epic mod content added over time)...but here's the problem with that: The ability of modders to keep people interested and active and excited about a game is one of the KEYS to having a long-lived series with a strong sales base. Without the ability to mod the silent hunter games, their appeal wanes over the course of a few months and it goes dark. :yawn:

The modding of SHIII has kept it relevant even now several years later (in the virtual computer world, that's a millenium or an age, speaking figuratively). The modding of SHIV made the game playable and fun and pushed the graphics engine to new heights. :yep:

I'd be stunned if the lead devs didn't constantly look at and play with the mod content for these games to mine the best ideas out and incorporate them in the next evolution of the SH family. The release of garysmod has kept HL2 and the source engine relevant even now several years after its release. Community modders are, again, pushing the source engine to its limits and I'd bet valve are constantly watching and taking notes for their own benefit. :yep:

Freespace 2 has/had the same thing going for it. :yep:

The common vein of ALL of these examples is the same. Free use of the software without cumbersome DRM controls allowed people to invest the hundreds and thousands of hours of their personal effort to improve a game they love. :damn::damn::doh: :salute::yeah:

As much fun as I have playing LOTRO, I routinely get burnt out because it's all the same types of gameplay over and over and over. I get new content when the developers decide to make it and sell it. Silent Hunter is not a "game" so much as a "brand" and a huge slice of that brand is a thriving amateur programmer modding community.

We don't know how this DRM will work, but it's sounding like something that would fundamentally alter the guts of the brand and exclude the possibility to see some of the truly AWESOME mod work that this community can produce. :down:

trenken 01-27-10 04:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by karamazovnew (Post 1248709)
Trenken really now... for someone accusing us of having zero knowledge about DRM... it's just.... GOD!

DRM has been around since the first game where you had to put a floppy in just to play it. Double so for Cd's back in the 90's. Back then a hard-disk was sometimes 10 times smaller than a CD.

After the CD blanks and recorders came around, the companies had to implement disk-checking. That was also broken either through emulating the disk or changing executable files.

Fallout 3, Spore, Mass Effect 2 all fall into this category. Even Steam games! Heck, it only took a month to crack GTA4. Most games get cracked before they get to the shops!

99.9% of games share this easy to brake DRM that is more or less intrusive on the player that actually buys the game:
- some require online activation at first start (Spore)
- some require online check at every start (3d Sex Villa, shut up :oops:)
- Most require the DVD to be in the drive through Starforce, Securom or other DRM's
Most players just get cracks for them to prevent damaging their disks. I have a few mint-condition games myself, never removed from box.

Then there are games that have been cracked but also provide Online features for which you do need to register online and BE online: L4D, all MMO's, Rise of Flight. Again all of these have MULTIPLAYER as their main attraction.

SH5 will be the first game ever to require you to stay online permanently to play in OFFLINE! What part of that don't you get? If you have a good net connection, good for you, most of us don't.

I get all that buddy boy. Did you read the part where Ubi said you will need to INSTALL the game on your machine? This is NOT an MMO, data from 100s of players is not being streamed to you at all times.

My point is if youve got a connection to launch it, such as is the case with Fallout 3, then you should probably have a connection after that, and all this game is doing is dealing with game saves and stat tracking. If you're on broadband im pretty sure you could stream a freaking movie and play this game, wait and see.

If you're on dialup, well these games arent made for you. Go play checkers online or something.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:45 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.