SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 5 (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=244)
-   -   What do you feel about SH5 now? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=169376)

kylania 05-25-10 01:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by soldat32 (Post 1402515)
No crew management

It's different now, it's RPG "training" and morale now. Arguably better than moving little dolls around a play house constantly. That said, I do miss training certain guys to be good at certain things and the mortality of my crew in SH3. Never did like/understand SH4's crew system

Quote:

no full war
How many times did you get past 1943 in SH3 anyway?

Quote:

mass of different subs.
I do miss the variety indeed. Then again, I love the Type VII and ended up sailing one of them most of the time anyway. Lots of people miss the bigger boats though.

Quote:

Online saves.
Optional and better to turn them off to be honest.

jwilliams 05-25-10 02:10 AM

Quote:

No crew management
Crew management does exist. It's just different now. And most probably someone will mod it to be similar to SH3's crew management

Quote:

no full war
I'd imagine that it wont take too long before this is modded to 1945. And Ubi may even release this as an addon.

Quote:

mass of different subs
Yeah i do miss the type II. But its only a matter of time before either its modded in or Ubi release an addon.

It's also fun to be testing all these great mods. I never had the opportunity with SH3, as i hadn't discovered Subsim and all these great modders. :yeah:

So IMHO it likely to be less than a year before the playabilty of SH5 is much better than SH3. :yep:

SH3 has had 5 years of modding..... How will SH5 be in 5 years? :hmmm:

Time will tell........

JScones 05-25-10 02:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IanC (Post 1402356)
But... but... it has amazing graphics!! *insert huge SH5 screenshot*

You left out a couple of :salute::woot::yeah::up:

Elder-Pirate 05-25-10 10:41 AM

I do not know whom the so called intelligent person was to stop this poll but in any case this is my vote.

I haven't bought this game and I will probably not buy it.


Those were the words made out by the OP but in my case it will read: I haven't bought this game and I will NEVER buy it!

When will you people stop bowing to this false god UBI?

SteelViking 05-25-10 11:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elder-Pirate (Post 1402796)
I do not know whom the so called intelligent person was to stop this poll but in any case this is my vote.

I haven't bought this game and I will probably not buy it.


Those were the words made out by the OP but in my case it will read: I haven't bought this game and I will NEVER buy it!

When will you people stop bowing to this false god UBI?

No one is bowing to Ubi, I am pretty sure that everyone here greatly resents Ubi's behavior. I for one am simply not willing to give up on a game that WILL be better if given the proper time and work.

In fact, I am realizing a pattern, anyone who spends most of their time on the modding forum is up beat, and says SH5 has a future. The ones I don't see there much are making the negative comments.

I mean no offence to anyone, as everyone is entitled to their opinion, this is strictly an observation.

Zedi 05-25-10 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elder-Pirate (Post 1402796)

I haven't bought this game and I will probably not buy it.

Who cares :zzz:

Méo 05-25-10 11:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteelViking (Post 1402815)
No one is bowing to Ubi, I am pretty sure that everyone here greatly resents Ubi's behavior. I for one am simply not willing to give on a game that WILL be better if given the proper time and work.

In fact, I am realizing a pattern, anyone who spends most of their time on the modding forum is up beat, and says SH5 has a future. The ones I don't see there much are making the negative comments.

I mean no offence to anyone, as everyone is entitled to their opinion, this is strictly an observation.

Great post! :up:

tonschk 05-25-10 12:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteelViking (Post 1402815)
No one is bowing to Ubi, I am pretty sure that everyone here greatly resents Ubi's behavior. I for one am simply not willing to give on a game that WILL be better if given the proper time and work.

In fact, I am realizing a pattern, anyone who spends most of their time on the modding forum is up beat, and says SH5 has a future. The ones I don't see there much are making the negative comments.

I mean no offence to anyone, as everyone is entitled to their opinion, this is strictly an observation.


:rock: Very Good Point , :rock: I completely AGREE :up:

.

Sailor Steve 05-25-10 12:52 PM

I agree too - SteelViking hit it right on the head. :yep:

Quote:

Originally Posted by SteelViking (Post 1402815)
NoI mean no offence to anyone, as everyone is entitled to their opinion, this is strictly an observation.

Anyone who takes offence at you comments here is looking for a fight, nothing more. Very well said indeed.

Jimbuna 05-25-10 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sailor Steve (Post 1402881)
I agree too - SteelViking hit it right on the head. :yep:

Anyone who takes offence at you comments here is looking for a fight, nothing more. Very well said indeed.

Agreed http://www.psionguild.org/forums/ima...ies/pirate.gif

Elder-Pirate 05-25-10 02:51 PM

Funny how some of the agrees here on these last few posts do not even have SH5 on their hard drive and have said they would not, under UBI's now conditions to ever have ( at least by their own words in the recent past ). If you ( with SH5 ) like to play the game only when the publisher ( ubi in this case ) lets you and NOT in private offline either, then that is your business and your right but it is still bowing.

As much as I disagree with UBI I must admit that they do know how to sucker a person in. Heck even I have their SH versions 3 & 4 and love them both but they didn't at that time try and keel haul the player

I'm not looking for a fight as stated by sailor Steve but again that's his opinion.
The above is my opinion and as yours it is my right.

Nisgeis 05-25-10 03:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elder-Pirate (Post 1403011)
Funny how some of the agrees here on these last few posts do not even have SH5 on their hard drive and have said they would not, under UBI's now conditions to ever have ( at least by their own words in the recent past ). If you ( with SH5 ) like to play the game only when the publisher ( ubi in this case ) lets you and NOT in private offline either, then that is your business and your right but it is still bowing.

As much as I disagree with UBI I must admit that they do know how to sucker a person in. Heck even I have their SH versions 3 & 4 and love them both but they didn't at that time try and keel haul the player

I'm not looking for a fight as stated by sailor Steve but again that's his opinion.
The above is my opinion and as yours it is my right.

I didn't like this post, so I didn't read it.

robbo180265 05-25-10 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elder-Pirate (Post 1403011)
Funny how some of the agrees here on these last few posts do not even have SH5 on their hard drive and have said they would not, under UBI's now conditions to ever have ( at least by their own words in the recent past ). If you ( with SH5 ) like to play the game only when the publisher ( ubi in this case ) lets you and NOT in private offline either, then that is your business and your right but it is still bowing.

As much as I disagree with UBI I must admit that they do know how to sucker a person in. Heck even I have their SH versions 3 & 4 and love them both but they didn't at that time try and keel haul the player

I'm not looking for a fight as stated by sailor Steve but again that's his opinion.
The above is my opinion and as yours it is my right.

Yeah I don't like the post either - I hear it's bugged flawed and frankly unreadable , so I didn't bother.:O:

Talyllyn 05-25-10 03:17 PM

I am thoroughly enjoying this game.

Yes it has (lots) of room for improvement but for a relatively small cost it has entertained me for several hours and will entertain me for several more.

I could spend twice as much going to a soccer match to have 90mins of serious dissappointment.

I only started SH3 after GWX was around so I have no idea how good or bad that was out of the box initially, but at least it had a reasonable set of instructions.

SteelViking 05-25-10 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elder-Pirate (Post 1402796)
I do not know whom the so called intelligent person was to stop this poll but in any case this is my vote.

I haven't bought this game and I will probably not buy it.


Those were the words made out by the OP but in my case it will read: I haven't bought this game and I will NEVER buy it!

When will you people stop bowing to this false god UBI?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elder-Pirate (Post 1403011)
Funny how some of the agrees here on these last few posts do not even have SH5 on their hard drive and have said they would not, under UBI's now conditions to ever have ( at least by their own words in the recent past ). If you ( with SH5 ) like to play the game only when the publisher ( ubi in this case ) lets you and NOT in private offline either, then that is your business and your right but it is still bowing.

As much as I disagree with UBI I must admit that they do know how to sucker a person in. Heck even I have their SH versions 3 & 4 and love them both but they didn't at that time try and keel haul the player

I'm not looking for a fight as stated by sailor Steve but again that's his opinion.
The above is my opinion and as yours it is my right.

No matter what you do, you cannot get around some control by publishers anymore, you either have a cd code for the game(stops you from multiple installs), you have to register the game, you have a cd check, you have a DRM, the list goes on. If you think that putting up with restrictions such as these as bowing, then I think everyone on the planet could fit through a sub hatch no problem.

I personally am spending no time just "playing" anyway. I am either helping others with their mods, shaping up my own mods, or testing mods for people. I do that stuff because DRM or not, that is what we need right now and will need for years to come from many people who wish to help. And that, sir, is my opinion.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.