SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Dangerous Waters (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=181)
-   -   Akula 65 Torpedo (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=83519)

Amizaur 08-24-05 05:22 PM

Well, in reality there is no long-range duels between modern quite submarines. Detection ranges of 688I vs Akula II would be inside 10k yards (probably very much inside) :-).

The UGST torpedo has specs about that:

range up to 50km/27nm with speed 35kts
range up to 25km/13.5nm with speed 50kts

for gameplay we may stretch the short-range mode to 30km/16nm at 50kts but not more.

ADCAP is said to be about:

27nm at 40kts
21nm at 55kts

some sources 11-14nm/65kts
some others say also about 30nm/40kts but 27 is "about 30" ;-)

So, if currently the short-range modes are not simulated properly (torpedos have always max range regardles of speed) and range for ADCAP is hard set to 27nm, then for UGST it should be set to 27nm too, not short-range 13-16nm mode. Or decrease ADCAP range to 21nm to simulate short-range only mode :-).

I think in the future I convince Luftwolf to use my torpedo doctrines with speed/depth/range depending on each other and we will have realistic speed/range combinations. But for now, Luftwolf if ADCAP is 27nm then please increase the range of UGST to it's max value too - 27nm. It will have only speed penalty against ADCAP, but range will be the same. And... hmmm... this will be the same range and speed as for 65cm (50kts 27nm) sooo... nobody should miss guided 65cm any more I think ? :)
If you feel that it's too close to ADCAP specs (and UGST should be inferior in range/speed parametres, only the max range is similar) then we could give to ADCAP max speed of 60kts - it's credited to be capable of even more (some sources say 11-14nm at 65kts) but 60kts for sure :-).

LuftWolf 08-25-05 02:20 AM

Amizaur, you're making good sense. I think all that is a good idea. :up:

I have the next two days free. I'm ready to get down to work. :|\

Send me anything you've got. :rock:

LuftWolf 08-25-05 02:22 AM

I like making the ADCAP 60 kts and increasing the range of the UGST to 27nm.

And the torpedo seekers... and a whole bunch of other stuff I have to think about when I have had some sleep. :doh:

Bellman 08-25-05 02:42 AM

Wow - thats nice music guys. :|\

Re seeker (In mod) - Tested UGST countermeasures (no conclusion yet) but had a 53 active, enabled and at 100 mtrs depth,
wired back at my Ak and she didnt pick me up at 300 mtrs depth plus and running-in from about 2 nm.
We were both on an identical course.

I would have thought that with the 'too wide' seeker cone discussed it would have picked me up. I will try some more tests.

LuftWolf 08-25-05 03:16 AM

Yeah, I was just giving you "a glimps into my world" in the other thread... :88) but it changes quickly sometimes... :yep: ;) :sunny:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.