Quote:
Originally Posted by Schroeder
(Post 2083760)
Actually no. Sure we progress but we aren't forced to do so by playing Russian roulette. Planes can be extensively tested and we do have safe designs that are available. It's not like we have to scrap all proven designs and go with a modern, probably less safe design just because of progress. If I buy a flight ticket I want to be sure I actually arrive at the destination and I don't give a hoot whether the aircraft is a Boeing an Airbus or an Ilyushin as long as it gets me safely where I want to go. We can't risk lives just for "progress" when more reliable solutions are at hand.
|
:hmmm:
They had pretty safe, available and reliable designs for prop driven airliners. Does that mean we should have stayed with them and not developed jetliners?
No-one is asking the worlds companies to scrap all modern airliners and adopt 787s only (although Boeing would quite like to do that) so there are plenty of options for airlines to take, the 787 is just attractive because of the miles per gallon it has, and once it shakes its bad karma from the battery issue (which, I remind people, does not seem to be the cause of this latest fire in the first place) then it will likely go on to be a successful aircraft in its own right, just like the Comet which is still flying today in a modified form as the Nimrod, despite killing some 426 people durings its career as an airliner (the Comet is not to blame for all of those, five of the crashes were controlled flight into terrain from pilot error). No aircraft is perfectly safe, no machine is perfectly safe, and to be honest, every time you get on an aircraft you could very well be playing Russian roulette, just the same as if you get in a car, on a train or on a boat, sure safety records and improvements can tilt the odds in your favour but nothing is perfect, even the fabled A340 could still have a fatal accident one day, it's just been incredibly lucky so far.
Besides, as an aircraft passenger, you pay your money and take your chance, unless you have enough money to spare that you can afford to not take the cheapest fare, or reject boarding the flight if you see it's a 787.
|