SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Sub/Naval & General Games Discussion (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=177)
-   -   Anyone else burned on all SH titles? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=182479)

difool2 04-12-11 06:40 PM

For me it's the lack of strategic/operational niceties which have burned me out. SH 5 promised dynamic interactive wolfpack ops, which we once again didn't get. To have friendly subs-and other units, tho we do have planes occ. lending a helping hand (or stealing your kills, depending on your viewpoint)-out there fighting the good fight right along with you would greatly increase the depth of the operational side of things (along with a truly dynamic BDU/CONSUBPAC of course issuing substantive and timely orders left and right).

But as it stands there is absolutely no such meat on the campaign route bones, so yeah it just becomes a repetitive exercise in find/chase/ sink. You are the only effective operational sub in the entire fracking world-think about what that means, and how alone it makes you feel. Heck seeing an occ. merchant damaged by the deck gun of a friendly sub (right before the escorts undoubtedly blew his poor pathetic keyster out of the water) makes me feel even more depressed, because it reminds me of what could have been.

Weiss Pinguin 04-12-11 08:49 PM

I think something like that would add tons to the replayability of career mode. As it is now, you can have a different experience on every career, but a dynamic campaign with BdU issuing relevant orders would make it much more interesting. And wolfpacks would be the icing on the cake.

I think it's time we tried suing Ubisoft for the rights to SH3's source code :arrgh!:

Ducimus 04-12-11 10:28 PM

Quote:

I think something like that would add tons to the replayability of career mode
Heh, yeah I can too. Trouble is, it would be a gargantuan game that no developer in their right mind would or could produce. One problem i think I have as a gamer, is that my tastes have grown to be multifaceted. For example, a straight up shooter won't do it for me. I want a shooter/RPG. Which is why ive been playing the crap out of Stalker Clear sky and Call of Prypiat lately.

At this point, what I want?

-I want a full rendered interior ala SH5.
-I want something passably complex ala a Flight SIM.
-I want to be able to interact with the crew like an RPG game. Said crew is interactive in and of themselves.
-I want a campaign game that has rewards or consequences to my actions or inactions. To be put in a situation where im forced to make hard choices.
-I want a mini game like solitare or Cribbage or something during those long transits periods.
-I also wouldn't mind some FPS elements with small arms. Ethic's be damned, its a video game. If i feel like doing my own impression of Heinz-Wilhelm Eck, Or Dudley W Morton, or If i want to run to my cabin to produce a side arm via Das Boot, i should be able to. With iron sights and guns blazing, i want to be able to empty clips into whatever flotsam has drawn my ire. I don't have to have this, but it would be nice.

( I also want my cake and I want to eat it too :88) )

Show me that combination, and i'll show you a game that i'll wager most of us could play far longer then any title we have available to us.

TorpX 04-13-11 01:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus (Post 1640898)
Not sure where to post this, so im sticking it in general games. But, for awhile now, i've realized im pretty much burned out everything that is Silent Hunter.


SH3:
For some reason, i just can't go back. For one, it looks like crap now. Even though my monitor is a 4:3 aspect ratio, the game looks all fuzzy. Then the super long loading times, and... blah.. just blah. I love some parts of this title, but ultimately it plays out the same.
Find ships, chase them, sink them.

SH4:
Work work work work work work work work work. My ass should have festering, bleeding, ulcer like bed sores from the amount of sitting at a desk i've undured for this game. Frankly, I have given up ever playing this game. I don't want to anymore. I try, i see something i don't like, im back to work on it again. Every time i've quit and restarted on this game, my endurance has gotten shorter, each and every time. I suspect I may have one more go left in me, but that won't be for a very long time. But again, this game plays out the same way.
Find, chase, sink.

Sh5:
You know, i REALLY like the interactive crew, the fully rendered interiors, and the graphics. But this game is more borked then SH4. Despite the bells and whisltes, gameplay is the same.
Find, chase, sink.

So lets talk about the game play:
In terms of game play and challenge, each and every SH title is essentually the same. In fact, THEY ARE ALL IDENTICAL. The core game play, is all derived from SH3. (or perhaps SH2? I don't know, never played it). But the core mechanics of the simulation, and the AI of the simulation, IS THE EXACT SAME FOR ALL THREE GAMES, and neither has any depth or complexity to them. Well, ok.. so Ubi added thermal layers in SH4, i guess that's new. But from my standpoint, each and every game is the same, all that changes is the bells and whistles. When people complain about the AI, I just laugh. Because once you learn how it works, evading it becomes nothing more then an exercise in repetition.

I wish i didn't feel this way, i really do. I WANT to play, and I want to enjoy myself. I remember how fun and engaging SH3 used to be for me. I wish i could recapture that. But knowing these game's like i do, (and i know these games file structure like the back of my hand, probably better then most), i just can't.

I won't say I'm burned out, but my enthusiasm isn't what it was.
Partly it's that SH4 was a dissappointment to me. I enjoyed SHCE a great deal; never played SH2 and SH3 only a little. My expectations were pretty high for SH4. To me, it seems that apart from graphics and a few other things, SH4 actually regressed. But maybe that's unfair. I've never tried SH5. I doubt I would like it, as I don't have a high tolerance for bugs and whatnot. I have to admit I peak in the SH5 section just to see what's going on. I guess I'm hoping that a SH6 will come out that has all the virtues of SH5, but without the flaws. :O:

I can certainly see why doing so much modding would kill your interest in the game. Peaking under the hood spoils the mystery. I would try laying off modding and take a break for a while. If/when you play SH4 again, it might be better to play someone else's mods, if that makes any sense. You might also consider trying a different sort of computer game to play in between SH4 sessions. I have had a lot of fun with TIGER WOODS PGA TOUR '08, eventhough I have never played real golf. There are a lot of subtleties which make for a novel experience (for me anyway). I think it helps to do something completely different.

D'oh, I forgot. It might help to just get a book and read/ reread about your favorite sub campaign.
Even when I'm well and truely fed up with computer games (for whatever reason), I still enjoy a good book.

Gargamel 04-13-11 01:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus (Post 1641668)
-I want to be able to interact with the crew like an RPG game. Said crew is interactive in and of themselves.

I have visions of pressing the wrong button while interacting with the cook, getting negative rep with him, and then the whole crew dies from salmonella. But yes, more crew interaction would be cool.

And taking over the diving station, learning to actually trim a boat, etc, would be great. Dynamic campaign too.

CCIP 04-13-11 01:27 PM

Burnout happens. Don't dwell on it too much. I've had it with so many games that I don't even pay attention anymore.

The good news is that sometimes after some months, it just comes back. Sometimes it doesn't come back instantly, but if you put in a bit of effort, everything just comes back.

I'd also actually been burned out on SH for long periods of time, or I'd only have flashes of interest in it sporadically. But I got some free time in the past week, and guess what, your work on TMO has done much to get me back to SH4, which I haven't played (at least the PTO side of it) in a good year and a half. Suddenly the burnout is gone, at least for now. It's not the same as when it first came out, but it's still good. Often what will get me back is a good book or movie or visit - in this case, going on the USS Pampanito reignited my interest, so back I am.

I think the important thing is just to keep it simple. Don't feel like it? Don't bother - there's lots more you can do to take up your time. I've got so many games that I've either never played or never really got into that even if I stopped buying anything gaming-related today, I'd probably have enough to last me the rest of my gaming life. As tempting as it is to get stuck on one title passionately, sometimes cycling through different interests is better.

And I wouldn't bemoan the lack of 'deep' games either. Again, I have far more of those than I can afford to spend time on.

Major Johnson 04-13-11 08:34 PM

Well this is an interesting thread. I haven't been around in awhile I know. I seem to go on binges from one type of game to another. I loved SH1 and still have original copy with all the patrol disks, and even 2 copies of CE! I have all the SH titles except for 5. I just didn't see the need. I know most people here like the realism factor and the more the better. For me I was happy with SH1 on about 75% realism. I played it for hours on end, losing whole weekends! I bought SH2 but just never could get into it, though I tried a few times, and even recently when I saw it was the classic reinstall game in PC Gamer magazine. Alas techology has finally caught up with that game and I'm having some graphic problems. SH3 looked interesting but the learning curve was just too much for me. Plus I wanted back in the Pacific. Uboats just didn't do it for me the way the American subs did. Then SH4 came out, like 10 yrs after SH1 and I was so stoked to finally get back to the pacific. The graphics were great, but honestly there was too much realism for me. I was hoping for SH4 graphics with an SH1 interface. I wanted a game where I could play for an hour a night and still be able to relax at the same time. And then there was the bugs and CTDs! I tried a few times to get into it, and the last time, maybe a year ago, I finally did and got into a campaign. Then some where around the summer of 42 I just lost interest/got side tracked, and I haven't continued it yet. I got into a FPS mood for a few months, then an RTS, and then back to FPS. Now I'm just taking a break from everything. The job has gotten busy, some health concerns (for me and my dogs) reared their heads and the musician side of me has been busier as well. I just don't have the necessary time to burn, like I used to. But I keep thinking that one day the spark will happen again. :)

Egan 04-14-11 08:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CCIP (Post 1642119)
I think the important thing is just to keep it simple. Don't feel like it? Don't bother - there's lots more you can do to take up your time. I've got so many games that I've either never played or never really got into that even if I stopped buying anything gaming-related today, I'd probably have enough to last me the rest of my gaming life. As tempting as it is to get stuck on one title passionately, sometimes cycling through different interests is better.

And I wouldn't bemoan the lack of 'deep' games either. Again, I have far more of those than I can afford to spend time on.

I began to realise a while ago that I am not, in fact, much of a gamer. I enjoy playing games that tie in with interests I already have; Strategy, Sims and the occasional RPG and that's about it. The only shooter I've played in the last couple of years were the Stalker games but I know that 99.99999% of the titles out there I would get bored of within 15 minutes. The result is I rarely burn out too much on games. If I do, it's mostly because my interests have moved on somewhere else for a little while so I tend to play games that reflect that.

Spike88 04-14-11 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly (Post 1641323)
^ Sub sim equivalent to the DCS series would be niiiice. :yep:

A DCS subsim would be nice, especially if it was a multiplayer experience, coupled in with the ability to have the AI take over a station if you don't have enough people.

CCIP 04-15-11 01:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Egan (Post 1642671)
I began to realise a while ago that I am not, in fact, much of a gamer. I enjoy playing games that tie in with interests I already have; Strategy, Sims and the occasional RPG and that's about it. The only shooter I've played in the last couple of years were the Stalker games but I know that 99.99999% of the titles out there I would get bored of within 15 minutes. The result is I rarely burn out too much on games. If I do, it's mostly because my interests have moved on somewhere else for a little while so I tend to play games that reflect that.

Same. I keep up with the gaming outside of sims and strategy stuff mostly as a social thing these days - a group of friends always peer-pressures me into playing a bit of the usual action stuff, which is fun when I'm playing it with them and of 0 interest to me without those people. So for myself, I also see myself more as a gamer-by-association. Fortunately, I'm getting to a point in life where I have more hobbies, working directions and interests than I have time, so it's much easier for me to dismiss gaming when it bores me.

However at the same time I totally recognize the virtues of patience and the pleasure of learning, modding, tweaking, etc. as long as it doesn't take over my life. Spent the past year really brushing up on flying high-complexity payware airliners in my Flight Sim, and it's been one of the most rewarding 'gaming' experiences I could have, and it also helped me connect to aviation-related hobbyism generally. But it's not a job and when it gets to a point where it's a lot of stress and information overload for limited fun in return, I have no trouble dropping it for a few weeks.

I think the key thing is not to jump to conclusions and stay open-minded. Don't burn your manuals, break your CDs, or sell you controllers if you're dead tired of a game. Give it a rest and then give it a chance later. Usually, odds are that unlike the average action title that you have no attachment to, these 'die-hard' sims and strategies will mean something to you - even if sometimes it gets buried under frustration, there's still a sort of personal connection you have, a residue of the work that you put into it all. And I always find it cool to come back to them and remember it.

onelifecrisis 04-16-11 12:19 AM

I burned out a while ago, but I got more than my money's worth from SH3.

I actually bought SH4 but even with all the patches it's still buggy and I just can't be arsed to test all the mods (something I had to do with SH3, and I must say that 95% of all mods I tried failed to pass).

So I feel your pain Ducimus, but look on the bright side: it was fun while it lasted.

:salute:

Platapus 04-17-11 06:34 PM

This is why I think it is so important to take breaks from games. Any game, no matter how good, gets repetitive if you keep playing it.

That's why I have hundreds of games on my shelf. When I get burned out, I change to some other games and some of them are the older games and I focus on them for a while.

I love Sub Sim games, but that does not mean that they are the only games I ever play. :nope: And let's face it, submarine games are not known for their edge of the seat excitement. Honestly, I can't imagine just playing SH3/4 without something else to do at the same time. I watch movies on my other computer while playing SH3/4 and only stop the movie when something happens.

So take a break and don't feel "guilty" about taking a break. I even took a break from Subsim.com when I burned out (ok got pissed off)

Breaks are healthy and necessary.

That's the nice thing about war games... the war will still be there when you come back. :yeah:

Pisces 04-18-11 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus (Post 1641344)
Yeah it would be nice.

As an aside, it occured to me, you know what the difference between SH3 and SH4 REALLY is, in terms of what you do as a player in regards to the simulation?

How you shoot salvo's, and the 3:15 rule becomes the 3 minute rule. That's pretty much it.

Don't forget saying 'good bye' to Bernard, but meeting Dinsdale!

JU_88 05-18-11 04:33 AM

For now yes and no.

SH3,
Played it to death already, worked on modding it (so the magic has gone) and as Ducmius says its age shows, sadly I cant bear to look at it now or my eyes hurt :oops:

SH4,
I really,really,really,really,really,really,really,r eally,really,really REALLY tried to get into it and I just couldnt, I dont know why.
When I bought it I was looking forward to the PTO, then when I played it, being in the Pacific just felt abit dull somehow - for the same reason the U-boat missions Expansion was equally dull for me, I just couldn't be bothered.
However now with The Mediterenian and Baltic mods out there (amongst others) I just might just give it another go soon.

SH5,
I played a few patrols and then stopped, what IS there is some good potential, but that alone is not enough.
Lack of U-Boat types, years 43-45, lack of AI units (especially merchents) ropey AI etc etc.
Basically I want to enjoy Sh5 when its been tweaked and reworked, I dont want to play though it in its current state.... it needs to er, mature first.
I am holding off until there is hopefully a WAC/GWX type super mod, avaliable, or somthing that offers some much needed brand new content, (rather than just the much needed tweaking)
Coming from a fully modded Sh3 to the current SH5 can only be described as a giant leap fowards in visuals but a giant leap backward in terms of content.

Truth is, I dont think I will ever enjoy any subsim as much as I enjoyed Sh3, It was all totally new to me then and thats what made it exciting.

Nicolas 07-14-11 07:53 PM

It can sound crazy to you but i think your problem is sin.
When you keep things clean and nice you get bored but not burned.

joea 07-15-11 08:13 AM

Kind of, not as much as with Il-2 which I played steadily for the better part of a decade, only to dust it off anytime the Daidalos Team put out another addon (the next is supposed to include the Pe-8 VVS heavy bomber :yeah:) .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0zY6X10zo4E

As for Silent Hunter, got a bit burnt out with SH3 cause I was still in Uni (or rather had gone back) when it came out and had more spare time for games in general. With my upgrade last year I could finally try SH4 which really got me with the improved graphics and the novelty of the new theatre. While I still play it, it's just too tiring to play those long non-stop sessions I did before. I also have started getting into Steel Fury though tank warfare is new territory for me.

Lately more of my gaming time is spent with browser flash games (some good ones) and especially gaming on my metrosexual iphone. :O:

Besides some standard titles, I got very nice ports of past faves Doom and Space Invaders. My two fave apps of the moment are the following:

http://www.f-sim.com

Amazing shuttle approach and landing sim which is more involving and difficult than you might think-you can do full or final approaches. Change weather or add system failures.


Another is not a game but for those who like space and astronomy is pretty cool.

http://vitotechnology.com/star-walk.html

Also shows you where the ISS and about 8000 satellites are besides stars and planets.

Basically as others have said, change is good, if you get bored, do something else then come back to it-if not move on to something else. :shucks:

Krauter 07-15-11 08:17 AM

I find it funny because my gaming appetite usually rotates from Subsimming to Flight Sims (combat or otherwise), to tank sims, to strategy games back to subsims and then the cycle continues :D

kiwi_2005 07-15-11 11:39 AM

Cause there are not plenty of WW2 subsims to choose from we stick with SH series that ends up boring gameplay there are days where I wont go near SH5 and days where I can't wait to load it up.

I find myself leaning more and more to role playing games, last month I brought 5 RPG games and still looking for more, it crazy as heading off on quests to kill wolves for their skins or help a dame in distress its like what the hell am I doing! But I can't get enough of it. I just picked up Avatar the game today and its actually not a bad RPG shooter, the gameworld detail creams every other game out there its the best detail i've seen in a game yet. Everything on ultra high damn jaw dropping. Avatar the game got averages score but i'm wondering if this game wasn't based on the movie it probably would be a hit with RPGers.

Now whats the next rpg to get :hmmm: :rotfl2:

Stealhead 07-15-11 11:53 AM

I agree with Platapus if you are feeling burned out with a game or anything for that matter you are spending too much of your time with it.I have always had many different hobbies/pass times I enjoy playing various PC games and I might play one particular game for about a week or so and then do something else and I might not come back to the same game for weeks or even months.Also I like to work on my cars and I have a few old Datsun Z cars that I will bust knuckles on from time to time I have been restoring this 77 280 since about 2005 I could have finished it much sooner but I like to take a long time it gives me something to do.

Feeling burned out is your brains way of saying "give me a break from this".


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.