SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   Pissed off........ctd (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=154687)

JScones 08-12-09 03:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by StarLion45 (Post 1148437)
there you ' re wrong Contact . If you die , and decide that you want to start the patrol you died in , you must never start SH3Cmdr right away , it crashing to desktop at ONCE . YOU MUST START IN THE GWX GAME , OR STOCK sh3 :yep:

:hmmm: I don't even understand what you are trying to articulate, but it sounds to me that you are doing something screwy.

I mean, if you die, SH3Cmdr will no longer let you load the dead career. Thus for you to use it, you must be interfering manually. As soon as you interfere manually, and THIS INCLUDES REVERTING TO A PREVIOUS SAVE POINT IN ANY CAREER, you potentially break SH3, which in turn breaks SH3Cmdr.

But I'm sure you would know this, having no doubt read the FAQ in the SH3Cmdr User Guide. ;)

Unfortunately SH3Cmdr usually ends up blamed for CTDs because of:
a) some interesting user belief that SH3 is perfectly coded thus couldn't be at fault
b) some interesting user belief that it couldn't possibly be anything they've done (like add conflicting mods, incorrectly edit files etc etc)
c) some interesting user belief that searching forums for possible answers before ranting is a waste of time, you know, like finding instances of similar problems occurring *before* SH3Cmdr and mods like GWX even existed (I know SH3Cmdr and GWX are mighty good, but I don't think they're good enough to create CTD's before they even existed!)
d) some interesting user belief that as SH3Cmdr is the last thing they see before SH3 loads, *anything* that goes wrong in SH3 must be attributed to it.

But as anyone who has read the SH3Cmdr User Guide will know, SH3Cmdr is very particular in what it changes, especially when you are mid patrol (hence why it recognises such careers). It limits changes to those proven not to cause CTDs under normal usage (through repeated scenario testing).

I will state categorically that outside of testing I have never had a CTD while playing SH3 + GWX (all versions), ever. Call me a smartarse or whatever you like, but the reason is simple: basic housekeeping and knowing what I am doing (ie following "manufacturer's" instructions and taking no shortcuts because "they seem right"). Much like maintaining a car. ;) It can be done.

I'm not pointing fingers at anyone in this thread (indeed, any defensiveness may be an indication of guilt), but that's simply how it is.

TarJak 08-12-09 04:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Contact (Post 1149360)
If you say Rez fix is 100% stable then could it be somewhere incompatible with OLCG2 ? Guess no one knows that.. :doh:

I can't comment on OLCG2 because I don't use it. I've installed it an tried it but prefer not to use manual targeting because I'm a lazy Kaleun.

Looking at your list of mods there are possibly 3 or 4 potential candidates for causing CTD's.

Contact 08-12-09 05:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 1149402)
I can't comment on OLCG2 because I don't use it. I've installed it an tried it but prefer not to use manual targeting because I'm a lazy Kaleun.

Looking at your list of mods there are possibly 3 or 4 potential candidates for causing CTD's.

Name them please.

TarJak 08-12-09 05:54 AM

It's probably one mod that is not compatible with something else you have running so naming them is not really for me to say. Doing so may offend the modder and the people who did the testing of that mod.

I should have said there are 3-4 candidates for causing incompatibilities which may cause CTD's. It is most likely the mix of mods you have rather than any single mod, however that may also be the case.

Usually mods are well tested against a base install without other mods in the way.

The only way to diagnose a combination of mods is to remove them all then add them back one by one then run several tests across a number of scenarios. If you still get CTD's then take that mod out and try the next one and so on until you don't get anymore CTD's.

It's a pain in the rear but then so was testing my GWX set of mods for months until I settled on a group that is stable and provides me with some enjoyment.

Hanzberger 08-12-09 05:56 AM

Well a lot has gone on in a couple of days of being away. OK maybe I am a big dummy but help me understand some things:

First off I did search the forums (not extensivly) and found some threads on CTD's. Everything I read was either old or didn't have anything to do with what happened to my CTD.

I am using a clean install with GWX3.0 and no additional mods. And yes I followed the instructions and installed all the files needed to run that and CMDer per the directions.

I made sure I was on the surface, no other ships around, not raining so it seemed like a good time to quit and save. :yep:

Yes I was angry cuz I don't have a lot of time to play this game let alone finally have a good career going and then have it lost. :wah:

Now I still have some questions:
This I did not know or missed but are we suppose to delete the folder SH3 from "my documents"?????

2)when you leave the game it doesn't allow you to just quit it always puts you back in base so when you go to restart, cmder has you starting back in base. Once in the game I go back to where I was at "in mission"
What am I missing here? What I am thinking is that cmder and the game don't jive all the time by doing this since when you start thru cmder, and I just checked, it has me at home base. The only option it gives me to change that is to start at another base. I wanna start where I left off, at sea. I hope this makes some sense I am on 5hrs sleep in 2 days. :zzz:

And this CTD happened on my 5th try. (career wise) so everything was fine up until this happened.

TarJak 08-12-09 05:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanzberger (Post 1149440)
This I did not know or missed but are we suppose to delete the folder SH3 from "my documents"?????

Before installing GWX you must remove the SH3 Folder from My Documents.

Melonfish 08-12-09 08:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 1149444)
Before installing GWX you must remove the SH3 Folder from My Documents.

Actually i didn't do this and i've only ever had one CTD and that was a duff save file.
otherwise no issues.

Jimbuna 08-12-09 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Melonfish (Post 1149494)
Actually i didn't do this and i've only ever had one CTD and that was a duff save file.
otherwise no issues.

Then you are luckier than many other people who have done similarly.

The installation instructions for GWX3.0 strongly advise against that course of action.

Hanomag 08-12-09 12:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JScones (Post 1149391)
:hmmm: I don't even understand what you are trying to articulate, but it sounds to me that you are doing something screwy.

I mean, if you die, SH3Cmdr will no longer let you load the dead career. Thus for you to use it, you must be interfering manually. As soon as you interfere manually, and THIS INCLUDES REVERTING TO A PREVIOUS SAVE POINT IN ANY CAREER, you potentially break SH3, which in turn breaks SH3Cmdr.

But I'm sure you would know this, having no doubt read the FAQ in the SH3Cmdr User Guide. ;)

Unfortunately SH3Cmdr usually ends up blamed for CTDs because of:
a) some interesting user belief that SH3 is perfectly coded thus couldn't be at fault
b) some interesting user belief that it couldn't possibly be anything they've done (like add conflicting mods, incorrectly edit files etc etc)
c) some interesting user belief that searching forums for possible answers before ranting is a waste of time, you know, like finding instances of similar problems occurring *before* SH3Cmdr and mods like GWX even existed (I know SH3Cmdr and GWX are mighty good, but I don't think they're good enough to create CTD's before they even existed!)
d) some interesting user belief that as SH3Cmdr is the last thing they see before SH3 loads, *anything* that goes wrong in SH3 must be attributed to it.

But as anyone who has read the SH3Cmdr User Guide will know, SH3Cmdr is very particular in what it changes, especially when you are mid patrol (hence why it recognises such careers). It limits changes to those proven not to cause CTDs under normal usage (through repeated scenario testing).

I will state categorically that outside of testing I have never had a CTD while playing SH3 + GWX (all versions), ever. Call me a smartarse or whatever you like, but the reason is simple: basic housekeeping and knowing what I am doing (ie following "manufacturer's" instructions and taking no shortcuts because "they seem right"). Much like maintaining a car. ;) It can be done.

I'm not pointing fingers at anyone in this thread (indeed, any defensiveness may be an indication of guilt), but that's simply how it is.

SH3 COMMANDER IS OPERATING AS INTENDED!! :salute:

Hanzberger 08-13-09 04:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 1149444)
Before installing GWX you must remove the SH3 Folder from My Documents.

So is it too late to do it now or do I have to reinstall everything again?

Contact 08-13-09 04:49 AM

Ok so CTD still happens when I scroll the map. Tried with and without rez fix, same sh** happened. In both ways gramaphone was playing, but I don't think it could be related to CTD I'm having :nope:

I'm going nuts and already having headache here trying to figure out what is wrong in my installation or mods or both.
Tired from treating the game like with jeweller hands honestly..

Peace of crap.. :damn:
Pardon my emotions.. but I'll find that bug in time hopefully.

I'm testing it now by disabling one mod after another and scrolling the map wildely across the screen. So far after a minute of scrolling BANG, CTD and goodnight.

Contact 08-13-09 06:23 AM

So mods rejection method did not gave any results, so I made a back up of my save files and I'm going to reinstall everything clean and fresh.

BTW I was using MultiSh3 for multiple SH3 installs. one for stock and one for GWX. Had some problems when uninstalling

http://img23.imageshack.us/img23/464...oardvdn.th.jpg

Then

http://img23.imageshack.us/img23/464...oardvdn.th.jpg

After these errors I had to manually delete SH3 and GWX installation folders, rebooted pc, will clean registry and reinstall everything from scratch. Will do only one install with GWX this time. Will keep this thead posted if I dig something out.

Contact 08-13-09 06:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TarJak (Post 1149444)
Before installing GWX you must remove the SH3 Folder from My Documents.

Correct, but if you never run SH3 before installing GWX you have nothing to delete there.

Contact 08-13-09 07:28 AM

Ok I have reinstalled GWX cleaner then ever. It has absolutely no mods enabled on JSGME, nor SH3Cmdr is installed either.

This video is explaining how CTD happens in GWX:

http://www.mediafire.com/?jqnzxynyoy3

At the end you will not see CTD window popup, because of application hang and Fraps stopped recording.

But the next second when the game froze in this video there was:

http://img197.imageshack.us/img197/5204/ctdf.th.jpg

Personally I see GWX not so stable as I wanted it to be.

Jimbuna 08-13-09 11:10 AM

Did you clean the registry files?

Contact 08-13-09 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbuna (Post 1150073)
Did you clean the registry files?


Yeah I did with registry clean expert.

Reinstalled stock SH3 patched it manually to 1.4 did testings, crashing in the same way :nope:

Jimbuna 08-13-09 11:50 AM

Well there is something still in there that is causing the crashes.

You stated you've used MultiSH3 in the past....have you left any files at all relating to SH3 in C\MyDocs, perhaps an installation save with a different name?

Contact 08-13-09 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbuna (Post 1150090)
Well there is something still in there that is causing the crashes.

You stated you've used MultiSH3 in the past....have you left any files at all relating to SH3 in C\MyDocs, perhaps an installation save with a different name?

No, everything was deleted that was related to any SH3 in the installation directories and in my documents. Have you tried doing the same Jim to see if it crashes too ? Try scrolling the map wildely for about a minute and see if it's not going to crash please.

Jimbuna 08-13-09 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Contact (Post 1150097)
No, everything was deleted that was related to any SH3 in the installation directories and in my documents. Have you tried doing the same Jim to see if it crashes too ? Try scrolling the map wildely for about a minute and see if it's not going to crash please.

I was unable to create a ctd I'm afraid, but the crash could be down to the specs of your machine, a high number of units rendered within your vicinity or a combination of both.

Contact 08-13-09 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbuna (Post 1150173)
I was unable to create a ctd I'm afraid, but the crash could be down to the specs of your machine, a high number of units rendered within your vicinity or a combination of both.

No way, my machine is capable more than enough tu run SH3 with GWX.

.. My last guess is possible faulty crack for SHII v.1.4 that I use. If the crack can crash the game then I have found what I'm looking for, but so far I'm not sure if it's the crack to blame. If there are ppl who are using cracks and are also experiencing CTD's as well, please PM me.

For now at least I know what NOT to do to avoid crashings directed to sh3.exe :shifty:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.