Quote:
Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
There is a reason that modern submarines do not have deck guns. They were an appallingly bad idea. Sinking a lousy tug meant a half hour lollygagging on the surface waiting for your puny posterior to be plastered by a lucky airplane.
Because the submarine was such a lousy gun platform, and dangerous to its crew, the odds of being tagged by an enemy aircraft were only slightly worse than the odds of sinking the target. The risk/benefits ratio was hideous.
If I were Admiral Lockwood, I would have used the deck gun solely as a screening device to detect and eliminate incompetent skippers from my fleet. If your log shows a deck gun use against anything but a junk, you're relieved of command. If you were stupid enough to endanger your crew shooting at an armed merchant or escort, it's the firing squad for you. Your death is a small price to pay for the lives of your crew and that valuable sub you were willing to throw away. OK, I'll throw in a get out of jail free card for use finishing off an unarmed wounded merchie if you have no torpedoes left. Ain't I merciful?
|
It is funny to read all of the "Captain's" comments on the use of deck guns, because similar comments were made by actual "Captain's" in WWII.
During Wahoo's 5th or 6th patrol, "Mush" Morton used a deck gun to sink a ship that he felt "unworthy" of a torpedo. When he filed his report, Lockwood sent a memo to all Fleet Boats, encouraging the use of deck guns and used "Mush's" report as an example of aggressive use.
The general feelings of actual Captain's varied between using the deck gun on unarmed ships being OK, to "hanging laundary" as being the best use for the gun. Some Captain's even threatened to "dump" the gun overboard once they left Pearl. Don't know if anyone did, though. It was generally felt that having a gun battle against an "armed" opponent was too risky for a sub, as 1 hit could cause catastrophic damage.
When O'Kane was outfitting the "Tang", the builder's at Mare Island were to install the deck gun on the bow side of the conning tower. O'Kane wanted the DG installed on the stern, because he felt the best use for the gun would be when running from an armed ship when he was unable to submerge. For some reason, this desire to mount the DG on the stern never materialized and he received a bow mounted gun.
Source: The Bravest Man, William Touhy, ISBN 9780891418894
|