SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 4: Wolves of the Pacific (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=202)
-   -   What do you guys use your deck gun for? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=141129)

AVGWarhawk 08-23-08 08:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WEBSTER
Quote:

Originally Posted by AVGWarhawk
Trust me when I say, a bit of pucker factor is now involved when surfacing before a armed merchant.

:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
it sounds like once again you guys outdid yourselves and did a fantastic job, keep up the good work and never doubt the community loves everything you guys do for us. :up:

I do nothing but test. Swdw, LukeFF, Observer, Peto are the main apple scrapples. Skwajer S3D editor brought to them for ease of making things work. Mix these guys up with Lurker's, Kriller's or W_Clear's work. Throw in Fred's 4 million MB of music for the gramaphone and you have one hell of a sim. I can not forget the modder who makes the smallest mod that sometimes speaks the loudest to the community....this Bud(or beer of your choice) is for you. The Modder!

Captain Vlad 08-23-08 09:08 PM

I kinda wish we had a mod that'd let you chase gun crews away from their mount with your AA guns...

...what? Turnabout is fair play!

LukeFF 08-24-08 01:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
I dont suppose I have an ice cream machine on my S-boat:cry:

No, you get old, moldy mattresses, electric motors that catch fire, and fuel tanks that leak worse than the Exxon Valdez! :smug:

LukeFF 08-24-08 01:24 AM

Since AVG and others have already said what I wanted to write, I'll just add this:

Quote:

105 MM. GUN.

The rate of fire was claimed as high as 25 rounds per minute, but a prisoner who had taken both the gunnery courses and an A/A course stated that 6 or 7 per minute was the rate of fire per minute in combat from a surface vessel, and even up to 15 rounds per minute under ideal circumstances in practice. The same gunner claimed that they had achieved 10 to 12 rounds per minute in practice. He felt that that was a good performance.

The crew of the 105 mm. consisted of six men and an extra passer: Number 1 was the pointer and fired when ready; Number 2 was the trainer; Number 3 was the sight setter; Number 4 was the plug man; Number 5 was the loader and called "ready!" when the breach had been closed. Numbers 6 and 7 were passers.
From the interrogation report of U-841.

momo55 08-24-08 07:20 AM

Every time i start a patrol i'll fire a few rounds in the direction of the first sunlight i see , for Dave .
I started doing it when he past away and still do .

Otherwise i may consider to use the deckgun to finish the suffering of a heavely crippled NON armed ship when i'm way out of costal waters .
I see the deckgun as a defensive weapon and prefer it on my afterdeck .

Sailor Steve 08-24-08 07:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LukeFF
Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
I dont suppose I have an ice cream machine on my S-boat:cry:

No, you get old, moldy mattresses, electric motors that catch fire, and fuel tanks that leak worse than the Exxon Valdez! :smug:

Oh come on! Every American unit that ever existed had a good 'scrounger' on board, somebody who could go ashore anywhere and come back with whatever was needed. Just go steal one!

Or was that just in the movies?
:rotfl:

Turbografx 08-24-08 02:04 PM

Yeah, I pretty much just use it for entertaining the crew whenever a sampan or junk pops up. Even then it takes about 25 shells to sink one of those suckers so not really worth the time/effort.

AVGWarhawk 08-25-08 08:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sailor Steve
Quote:

Originally Posted by LukeFF
Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
I dont suppose I have an ice cream machine on my S-boat:cry:

No, you get old, moldy mattresses, electric motors that catch fire, and fuel tanks that leak worse than the Exxon Valdez! :smug:

Oh come on! Every American unit that ever existed had a good 'scrounger' on board, somebody who could go ashore anywhere and come back with whatever was needed. Just go steal one!

Or was that just in the movies?
:rotfl:

Nope! Jimmy Dolittle had his man who could "find" things for Jimmy. I think everyone had the guy who could "find" things:D

Nunya 08-25-08 09:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
There is a reason that modern submarines do not have deck guns. They were an appallingly bad idea. Sinking a lousy tug meant a half hour lollygagging on the surface waiting for your puny posterior to be plastered by a lucky airplane.

Because the submarine was such a lousy gun platform, and dangerous to its crew, the odds of being tagged by an enemy aircraft were only slightly worse than the odds of sinking the target. The risk/benefits ratio was hideous.

If I were Admiral Lockwood, I would have used the deck gun solely as a screening device to detect and eliminate incompetent skippers from my fleet. If your log shows a deck gun use against anything but a junk, you're relieved of command. If you were stupid enough to endanger your crew shooting at an armed merchant or escort, it's the firing squad for you. Your death is a small price to pay for the lives of your crew and that valuable sub you were willing to throw away. OK, I'll throw in a get out of jail free card for use finishing off an unarmed wounded merchie if you have no torpedoes left. Ain't I merciful?

It is funny to read all of the "Captain's" comments on the use of deck guns, because similar comments were made by actual "Captain's" in WWII.

During Wahoo's 5th or 6th patrol, "Mush" Morton used a deck gun to sink a ship that he felt "unworthy" of a torpedo. When he filed his report, Lockwood sent a memo to all Fleet Boats, encouraging the use of deck guns and used "Mush's" report as an example of aggressive use.

The general feelings of actual Captain's varied between using the deck gun on unarmed ships being OK, to "hanging laundary" as being the best use for the gun. Some Captain's even threatened to "dump" the gun overboard once they left Pearl. Don't know if anyone did, though. It was generally felt that having a gun battle against an "armed" opponent was too risky for a sub, as 1 hit could cause catastrophic damage.

When O'Kane was outfitting the "Tang", the builder's at Mare Island were to install the deck gun on the bow side of the conning tower. O'Kane wanted the DG installed on the stern, because he felt the best use for the gun would be when running from an armed ship when he was unable to submerge. For some reason, this desire to mount the DG on the stern never materialized and he received a bow mounted gun.

Source: The Bravest Man, William Touhy, ISBN 9780891418894

Atony94 08-25-08 04:55 PM

i use it when im out of torps and i come across 1 or 2 lone merchants (cept one time one of the merchants had a gun in december of 1941!!) and if you hit it below the waterline (the round still travels underwater but slowly and not for long) you can sink em pretty fast.

cj95 08-25-08 05:24 PM

This is interesting light of the facts that some of the biggest WWI ace's used the deck gun almost exclusively for most of their kills.

I cant imagine that ships were easier to sink back then, or the subs any better gun platforms.:lol:

Webster 08-25-08 05:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
This is interesting light of the facts that some of the biggest WWI ace's used the deck gun almost exclusively for most of their kills.

I cant imagine that ships were easier to sink back then, or the subs any better gun platforms.:lol:

i would think if that were the case it was because ww1 merchant ships were generally unarmed and not as well built as during ww2 when they had better stronger steel.

i would imagine back then a few shells would split the seems open and unzip those rivets without too much effort.

Peto 08-25-08 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WEBSTER
Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
This is interesting light of the facts that some of the biggest WWI ace's used the deck gun almost exclusively for most of their kills.

I cant imagine that ships were easier to sink back then, or the subs any better gun platforms.:lol:

i would think if that were the case it was because ww1 merchant ships were generally unarmed and not as well built as during ww2 when they had better stronger steel.

i would imagine back then a few shells would split the seems open and unzip those rivets without too much effort.

And they generally weren't too concerned about planes :hmm:.

Sailor Steve 08-25-08 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WEBSTER
Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
This is interesting light of the facts that some of the biggest WWI ace's used the deck gun almost exclusively for most of their kills.

I cant imagine that ships were easier to sink back then, or the subs any better gun platforms.:lol:

i would think if that were the case it was because ww1 merchant ships were generally unarmed and not as well built as during ww2 when they had better stronger steel.

i would imagine back then a few shells would split the seems open and unzip those rivets without too much effort.

It's also only partly true. They would stop the ship, allow the crew to depart in lifeboats, and then sink the ship by opening the sea cocks, laying scuttling charges and then using a few rounds from the deck gun. The British development of the Q-ship made that much more dangerous, and by the end of the war most of them were using torpedoes.

So it's a lot easier to sink a ship with the gun when it's already open to the sea, and when there is no crew on board to make repairs and fight fires.

I'm also delighted to report that www.uboat.net 's article on Lothar von Arauld de la Perriere has been updated to reflect the fact that his use of only four torpedoes was not throughout his entire career, but only during one patrol. Still an amazing accomplishment, but not quite the myth it seems to have become.

Sailor Steve 08-26-08 01:50 AM

Just found another one for you all. It's a liberty ship and was registered at 7176 tons, sure, but after a torpedo destroyed her stern it still took 99 rounds from the deck gun to finish her off.
http://uboat.net/allies/merchants/3001.html

Sailor Steve 08-26-08 07:01 AM

More on rates of fire:
http://uboat.net/allies/merchants/739.html

Twenty-eight rounds in sixteen minutes is an average of 1.75 rounds per minute, or one every 34 seconds.

I also have to wonder who the mystery ship was who evaded four torpedoes and got away.

buddha95 08-26-08 11:13 AM

AARRRGGGGG !!!!!!!!
BILGEWATER I SAY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

my 2 highest paid and most decorated men are my deck gun crew.
last night in a 4/2 porpoise boat we took out an entire convoy over a 2 day long battle.
4 DDs
2 lg tanker
2 lg freighters
3 med freighters
med tanker
sm tanker

I #@$* swear and rely on my deckgun. Keep in mind I carry few torps on this ond but faithful friend.

So when you talk about my deck gun,,,,,, your messing with me !!!!!!:arrgh!:

SteamWake 08-26-08 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by buddha95
AARRRGGGGG !!!!!!!!
BILGEWATER I SAY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

my 2 highest paid and most decorated men are my deck gun crew.
last night in a 4/2 porpoise boat we took out an entire convoy over a 2 day long battle.
4 DDs
2 lg tanker
2 lg freighters
3 med freighters
med tanker
sm tanker

I #@$* swear and rely on my deckgun. Keep in mind I carry few torps on this ond but faithful friend.

So when you talk about my deck gun,,,,,, your messing with me !!!!!!:arrgh!:

Install RFB and you will be singing a different tune I assure you. :|\\

Quote:

Originally Posted by Captin Vlad
I kinda wish we had a mod that'd let you chase gun crews away from their mount with your AA guns...

Hell they dont even abandon their guns as the ship is sinking and listing at 45 degrees.

Sailor Steve 08-26-08 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by buddha95
I #@$* swear and rely on my deckgun. Keep in mind I carry few torps on this ond but faithful friend.

So when you talk about my deck gun,,,,,, your messing with me !!!!!!:arrgh!:

I swear I would never dream of criticizing your deck gun. Neither its size nor its performance. What you do with your deck gun is your business and nobody else's. I may disagree with your deck gun, but I'll defend to the death your right to shoot it.

Wilcke 08-26-08 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cj95
I dont suppose I have an ice cream machine on my S-boat:cry:

No you don't get in a Fleet Boat! Why wait do it now!

Happy Hunting!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:31 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.