SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)
-   -   When are we going to see the end of US bashing? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=124623)

PapaG39 11-05-07 04:33 PM

Nope! people just love to bitch about something.

And I couldn't care less... Let them bitch.
I still live in a free country and it suits me just fine... I support President Bush also. I think he is doing just fine...To bad he couldn't go another term.

11-05-07 04:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fatty
Bizarrerly worded flamebait thread with a public poll... good things will come of this.

I'd have thought you were serious save your vote in favor of each poll subject.

Winston 11-05-07 04:43 PM

It depends on how one would define 'bashing'. If you mean expressing an opinion on current United States policy then as long as it worded in a thoughtful and non-insulting way then it should be fine. However, anyone who verbally attacks any country using foolish generalisations obliviously steps way out of line.
I live in Wales myself and enjoy quite a good western lifestyle. I get to do a lot of things thus I can say I'm not jealous of the United States. I think most people living in the western world would honestly tell you they are not jealous either. Most Europeans will probably have quite different views on a lot of topics then people in the United States and thus will often find themselves erupting in debate.


If I may Waste Gate I'd like to ask why you used the word jealousy? Personally if I were to look more closely at the term I might be slightly insulted myself that you'd think I'd be jealous. I'd ask myself, “Dose he think that I'd be jealous because he believes I'm worse off then the average United States citizen as I happen to live in Wales?”


Might I venture the question. Why dose it seem that there is so much 'resentment' to the United States? Might I then suggest that you review each releasable response you receive and think about these different point of view. Put yourself in there shoes and perhaps you might understand how and why there is resentment out there.


p.s. I did not vote by the way as I have no resentment toward the American people.

11-05-07 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeepIron
Quote:

I'm not trying to bait anyone...
You've asked an 'open ended' rhetorical question to which there is no singular answer. The law of averages will probably raise its ugly head and someone will get emotionally charged, say something fairly inappropriate, and the thread will be closed.

But until then...:smug:

Quote:

I have yet to see a reason for the US bashing, other than they don't like GWB and his policies.
What? That isn't enough? Almost 8 years of this nitwit thumbing his nose at Congress, lying to the American people, foisting his "world view" upon the rest of us...

Geez, I'm an American and I can't stand the guy ("we all chipped in for a bag of cement" to quote Paul McCartney)... I can understand why others in the global community might seize upon him as an icon of Americanism and maybe not like the rest of us too much..

Open ended questions are no more than exercising my right to free speach. If you see it as a problem it says more about you than me. You dont really believe in free speach do you?

Basic US policy hasn't changed in thirty-plus years. Bashing GWB isn't helping your effort. Like I stated earlier congress has either endorsed or allowed everything GWB has done. If anything congress and the people of the US are at fault as much as GWB.

U49 11-05-07 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by waste gate
How long do you think the US has been doing things w/o understanding what they(more GWB slamming) it is/are doing and why?

I don't want to drift into your internal politics wether it was this guy, his predecessor or whoever. It's your election, not mine.

But I still can remember the days, when someone in the US made smart moves.

OT (sorry, but I feel it fits) : Not an example of "smart" but afterwards one of my all-time favorites:
"My fellow Americans, I am pleased to tell you today that I`ve signed legislation that will outlaw Russia forever. We begin bombing in five minutes." :rotfl:
Guess who was that ? :D

11-05-07 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Winston
It depends on how one would define 'bashing'. If you mean expressing an opinion on current United States policy then as long as it worded in a thoughtful and non-insulting way then it should be fine. However, anyone who verbally attacks any country using foolish generalisations obliviously steps way out of line.
I live in Wales myself and enjoy quite a good western lifestyle. I get to do a lot of things thus I can say I'm not jealous of the United States. I think most people living in the western world would honestly tell you they are not jealous either. Most Europeans will probably have quite different views on a lot of topics then people in the United States and thus will often find themselves erupting in debate.


If I may Waste Gate I'd like to ask why you used the word jealousy? Personally if I were to look more closely at the term I might be slightly insulted myself that you'd think I'd be jealous. I'd ask myself, “Dose he think that I'd be jealous because he believes I'm worse off then the average United States citizen as I happen to live in Wales?”


Might I venture the question. Why dose it seem that there is so much 'resentment' to the United States? Might I then suggest that you review each releasable response you receive and think about these different point of view. Put yourself in there shoes and perhaps you might understand how and why there is resentment out there.


p.s. I did not vote by the way as I have no resentment toward the American people.

Perhaps a better word was envy. Britain, Germany, France, et al, were powers in the past and are not now. Perhaps their populations are less than happy with their political place in the world. I didn't mean to cast aspersions on anyone's socio-economic position, nor how the see themselves.

11-05-07 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by U49

OT (sorry, but I feel it fits) : Not an example of "smart" but afterwards one of my all-time favorites:
"My fellow Americans, I am pleased to tell you today that I`ve signed legislation that will outlaw Russia forever. We begin bombing in five minutes." :rotfl:
Guess who was that ? :D

Ron Regan.

XabbaRus 11-05-07 05:11 PM

US bashing? where I haven't seen that for a long time here.

U49 11-05-07 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by waste gate
Ron Regan.

Score! :yep:

Takeda Shingen 11-05-07 05:14 PM

Anyone who has been reading this forum regularly over the past few days knows what this thread is really about. I suggest that we move on.

11-05-07 05:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Takeda Shingen
Anyone who has been reading this forum regularly over the past few days knows what this thread is really about. I suggest that we move on.

It's about US bashing and I made every attempt to make it fair by opening the poll to multiple answers and allowing for the free flow of opinion by inviting other opinions to be aired in the respondents posts.

If you think something else is involved I give you this :

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neal Stevens
Anyway, don't get too wrapped up in it, I think the world bashes the US more than Germany these days.

http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/show...226#post684226

Takeda Shingen 11-05-07 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by waste gate
Quote:

Originally Posted by Takeda Shingen
Anyone who has been reading this forum regularly over the past few days knows what this thread is really about. I suggest that we move on.

It's about US bashing and I made every attempt to make it fair by opening the poll to multiple answers and allowing for the free flow of opinion by inviting other opinions to be aired in the respondents posts.

You think that I am very, very stupid, no? This is about you and Skybird. It started two days ago. You're mad about how it turned out and you are going about things in a very unproductive way.

For the second time, let's just cut the semantics and move on.

Ducimus 11-05-07 05:24 PM

Everything we do will cause complaints. Even if we don't do anything at all, people will still complain. Ever see that spoof joke of "If patton were president"? I really, really, like the notion.

Oberon 11-05-07 05:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by U49
Quote:

Originally Posted by waste gate
Ron Regan.

Score! :yep:

I love that quote! And others too. Reagan did come out with some good ones... :D

11-05-07 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Takeda Shingen
Quote:

Originally Posted by waste gate
Quote:

Originally Posted by Takeda Shingen
Anyone who has been reading this forum regularly over the past few days knows what this thread is really about. I suggest that we move on.

It's about US bashing and I made every attempt to make it fair by opening the poll to multiple answers and allowing for the free flow of opinion by inviting other opinions to be aired in the respondents posts.

You think that I am very, very stupid, no? This is about you and Skybird. It started two days ago. You're mad about how it turned out and you are going about things in a very unproductive way.

For the second time, let's just cut the semantics and move on.

You are so wrong TAK. I don't even read most of what SB writes. It is mostly contradictory. This was started because its time to start a conversation about how and why the SS members are anti-US. I think its a worth while topic.

EDIT: If you are correct TAK, perhaps it is time to express that sentiment to the appropriate party.

Penelope_Grey 11-05-07 05:38 PM

Im not jealous of the USA... As with all countries, they have strengths and weaknesses.

I think the "America bashing" on the forum probably comes from the fact there are too many people on the GT forum who wrap the Stars and stripes round themselves and chant USA USA USA and puff out their chests a little too much...

Pride in your country is one thing, but, rubbing peoples faces in it... thats another... though as with all things, I dare say it can be 6 of one, half dozen of the other.

11-05-07 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Penelope_Grey
Im not jealous of the USA... As with all countries, they have strengths and weaknesses.

I think the "America bashing" on the forum probably comes from the fact there are too many people on the GT forum who wrap the Stars and stripes round themselves and chant USA USA USA and puff out their chests a little too much...

Pride in your country is one thing, but, rubbing peoples faces in it... thats another... though as with all things, I dare say it can be 6 of one, half dozen of the other.

The last time I heard anyone chant USA, USA, USA, death was in front of it.

How would you feel if entire nations wanted you and your countrymen dead?

Oberon 11-05-07 05:42 PM

Why would a site run by an American, frequented by many Americans and featuring many American things (US submarines, planes, etc) be anti-American?

I think what it primarily may boil down to (and I'm no expert) is more US president-bashing than actual US bashing. After all, while I think that Bush is a bit of an idiot at times, I don't think that this means that every American person is a bit of an idiot...even if they did break away from the Empire ( ;) j/k ;) ), and on the subject of Bush, I happened to be very touched (and my opinion of him bumped up by a notch) by his speech after the 7/7 bombings when he was up at Gleneagles. So, the guy has a bit of hope, it's just that some absolutely disasterous decisions overshadow his entire career. Much as Blair won't be remembered for helping to solve the Irish issue but more for all the problems that happened while Labour was in power (Particularly British involvement in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the whole Hutton fiasco that followed it).
Politics is a risky game, sometimes the game plays you right, sometimes it totally screws you up and throws you out in shreds, it's how you're able to play that game determines how you are remembered by future generations (and when you consider that a sizable portion of that 'game' these days is the media, then you're screwed before you even start).
Besides, as it stands at the moment, the US is the big power of the world, like Britain and Rome before it, and I bet Britain and Rome were Real popular amongest other nations of the time. (Although I don't think there was a subsim radio room back in the 1800s...)

Penelope_Grey 11-05-07 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by waste gate
The last time I heard anyone chant USA, USA, USA, death was in front of it.

How would you feel if entire nations wanted you and your countrymen dead?

Considering Britain is far older than the USA, I'd say as far as nations wanting us dead... been there done that and got the T-shirt.

Recent example, London was attacked and I was on a holiday and very near Liverpool station at the time. I have said this before... I'd say the American position is far fron unique or exclusive.

3Jane 11-05-07 05:53 PM

A rather disingenuous selection, especially in the 'No'. Ah well :rotfl:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:09 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.