nattydread |
07-27-07 01:37 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by -Pv-
Silent Running does not mean you are "silent" or undetectible. The button is not a starship cloaking shield. Neither is the layer. Even with both you can be tracked and attacked. If you have a visual contact through the scope or a sound contact, they cannot be "over the horizon" in this game though you can hear contacts beyond visual range. Just as you can hear them, there is a chance they can also hear you.
-Pv-
|
They were identified as being at long range, thats atleast 10km i believe as mentioned in the manual. They were heading in at high and then medium speeds from long range. I seriously doubt they'd be able to detect me deep under the layer, silent running at 2kts from over 10km using passive sonar in 41. Even if they keyed in on my last bearing, or assuming they did better and they solved for my track and speed to intercept, they still would have been miles away on a differnet course and speed by the time they got there.
I tend to believe the ships I ran into were ships sitting and sleeping at the location I surfaced. The standard speed ascent and surface may have certainly gotten the attention of an alerted crew, but Ive read of subs doing much more amoungst a convoy at night...granted the escorts were underway.
I can accept the idea of a sitting hunter-killer grouping getting the jump on me, but Im not sure i accept the idea that a hunter-killer group would be sitting stationary, engines off in a combat zone. I cant accept the hunter-killer group was from a distant location that magically homed in on me under the conditions. British passive sonar wasnt even that good at that point in the war.
|