Which do you think is better: a game that came out years ago and has been worked on for almost as long by a very talented group of modders or a game that was released weeks ago?

Come on, these posts are getting tiresome. Anybody that has more than a passing interest in simulations knows that mods make the game a simulation, it's the developers job to provide a solid base for these modders (who don't work under publisher restrictions).

PD

You seem to miss the point. The question is what is best right NOW, not in three months when patching is done and mods are pouring out. SH4 will be better, the added flexibility of the dynamic campaign, and the stunning graphics will ensure that (when FSAA is possible), but I actually think SH3+GWX is better at the moment.

Thanks to all.

Stabiz is on the mark...

Right now, and maybe say for the next 6 months until patches and modders catch up, I want to invest my time on a sim that most say SH3 with GWs is a deep, rewarding, bug free, challenging experience.

As I am sailing in the Atlantic, I'll keep checking with what's going on in the Pacific Theater. I imagine, a lot of what I learn with a U Boot will be transferable some day to Uncle Sam's service.

Best of both worlds! Great sim now, another great sim to look forward say at about Xmas.:up:

REAL men have great big honkin' hard drives that can handle both!

I'm just sayin'...

JCC

:cry: :cry: :oops:

Don't fret.

As a female friend of mine used to say,

"Size really doesn't matter.








Unless, of course, we are talking about sex!".


JCC

SH3 plus Grey Wolfs super Mod/expansion does great big smelly dog poo's all over SH4, no hesitation. :up:

Be warned SH3-GWX is not for the weak willed or the faint of heart, only the biggest hardest of he-men should enlist.

Play both - specialisation is for insects :p