SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter III (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=182)
-   -   Could someone kindly recommend a good U-Boat novel? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=92793)

jaxa 05-05-06 11:03 AM

"Das Boot" - Bible of subsimers, "must read"
"Iron coffins" - probably the best

Myszkin - duże brawa za hasło pod Twoimi postami, chociaż podejrzewam, że wielu z uzytkowników forum będzie miało co do tego wątpliwości

Myszkin 05-05-06 11:29 AM

"Hirschfeld. The story of a U-Boat NCO 1940-1946" by Geoffrey Brooks - This is a unique book based on a highly secret diary kept by Wolfgang Hirshfeld during the war.

Jaxa - wątpliwości można mieć, ale faktom nie da się zaprzeczyć :)
Pozdrawiam!

retired1212 05-05-06 12:48 PM

U-571 :rock:

Ducimus 05-05-06 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oombongo
U-571 :rock:

Someone get a rope! We's gonna have us a hangin'! :-j

Quote:

Could someone kindly recommend a good U-Boat novel?
My order at Borders has come in:
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/steelboat.gif

I just havent had a chance to pick it up yet.

To wet your whistle, heres a 10 page excerpt from it.
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/books.cgi?a=4


Theres another one out there, i dunno where it is, theres like two excerpts from the book you can read on the net,

Ping Jockey 05-05-06 05:04 PM

Operation Drumbeat :up: :up: :up:

Seminole 05-05-06 05:38 PM

For a novel Big Sharks and Little Fish would be hard to beat. It is a fictional account of a group of young roughneck German sailors and follows their lives from able seamen on mine sweepers in the early war North Sea through their training as cadets to become U-Boat officers.

If I remember correctly it was written by a real life U-Boat submariner and I suspect the things he writes about actually happened to him. I took it to be a fair glimpse into how the war affected these men.

JScones 05-05-06 10:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus
My order at Borders has come in:
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/steelboat.gif

I just havent had a chance to pick it up yet.

To wet your whistle, heres a 10 page excerpt from it.
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/books.cgi?a=4

Thanks for the link...I might just have to buy this one.

CCIP 05-05-06 10:59 PM

Grey Wolf, Grey Sea by E.B. Gasaway

Wonderful book about a Type IX boat's entire career, relatively concise but detailed - and really just awesome read, very well-written. Still my favorite :up:

Tigrone 05-06-06 01:48 AM

Real Books about real war
 
"The Key", aka "Stella," by Jan deHartog
"The Enemy Below" by D.A. Raynor

Both became major motion pictures.

My all time favorite is "The Good Shepherd" by C.S. Forester.

perisher 05-08-06 08:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hairydynamicist
Any of you guys read 'The Real Cruel Sea'? Non-fiction based around the allied merchant navy during the battle of the Atlantic. Not read it myself, but sounds very interesting.

Not to be confused with Monserrat's "The Cruel Sea", 'The Real Cruel Sea' by Richard Woodman, a professional mariner and an excellent writer, gives the merchant seaman's view of the Battle of the Atlantic. There's no glory here, just the war through the eyes of the targets.

tiger_tim_34 05-09-06 05:33 AM

re: your recommendations
 
Just started reading 'Iron Coffins'. :up:

perisher 05-09-06 06:40 AM

John Biggins' "A Sailor of Austria" is an excellent novel about First World War submarine combat. Seen from the prespective of the Austro-Hungarian Navy it is informative, accurate and, at times, very funny. It's the best submarine novel that I have ever read. :up:

Swede 05-09-06 08:13 AM

Mein Kampf

It can be interpeted in a way so that you think its about subs. Especially if you dont understand german

ParaB 05-09-06 04:44 PM

Buchheim's "The Fortress" is also IMO a very interesting novel. Lots of Uboat stuff of course but also a look at the situation in France before and after the invasion in Normandy.

And if you're interested in what happened to the Kaleun of U-96 after WW2, read the last part of the trilogy, "The Goodbye".

Ducimus 05-09-06 05:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JScones
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ducimus
My order at Borders has come in:
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/steelboat.gif

I just havent had a chance to pick it up yet.

To wet your whistle, heres a 10 page excerpt from it.
http://www.uboatwaffe.net/books/books.cgi?a=4

Thanks for the link...I might just have to buy this one.

Well so far im into chapter 2. He gives a real good account of life on a uboat as so far. Some of the details he gives really sticks in your mind. His first war patrol was to the south atlantic in the waters off of freetown. His descriptions of the eniroment were really vivid.

I particuarly enjoyed this part about eggs. Yess, eggs. He says in the chilly north atlantic, they'd last anywhere from 2 to 3 months before going rotton. On U505's outsdet they had 3000 of them onboard, and theyd rott in 2 or 3 weeks in the humid south atlantic , espcially inside a sweltering uboat pressure hull. So they had to scarf down 3000 eggs in two weeks. blech. The heat inside a uboat was intense. WHen they dived the water would cool down the hull, but it would create condensation. he said he had "rain water" dripping into his books while reading or what not.

Lots of other small details, really good reading as so far. He even went into talking uboat school at the time. Pretty intense training, with a high washout rate.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:31 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.