DarkFish |
06-07-10 04:37 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by jimbuna
(Post 1413696)
Oh I agree....moving further along the coast to Holland, exactly the same could be said....they also had an active resistance that hardly ever get a mention by historians.
|
While definitely heroic, I doubt that the resistance played a large role in the military operations of WW2 (and thus deserves a place on maps).
Because of the German retaliations that often followed resistance operations, many of these operations may even had a negative effect. I'm not saying this is to blame on the resistance fighters, but the effect's there nonetheless.
Somewhere in the end of 1944/beginning of 1945 my grandfather was, like all young men of his town (Zelhem), called up to dig trenches, to be used in the German defence of the Netherlands. Not wanting to help the German occupiers, he hid in a nearby barn, just as many other called up community members did. In response, the Germans arrested and executed the mayor and a few other people, and threatened to keep on executing people until everyone had turned themselves in. My Grandfather did so, and was put to work digging trenches around the town.
While certainly admirable that he (and the many other young men involved) didn't want to help the occupiers, the collective hiding in this case only had negative effects. Had they turned themselves in, nobody would have been shot. For the war it wouldn't have mattered a thing as the trenches probably weren't even used in the German defence of the Netherlands.
Same goes for most "real" resistance.
I think saving jews by providing hiding places, ration stamps and ID cards may be called the "worthiest" achievement of the Dutch resistance. Most of the other actions may have harassed the Germans, may have disrupted communications and operations of the German army, and may even have saved one or two lives. But as a whole, I see these "other", non live-saving actions as maybe even having caused more harm than they prevented.
It doesn't make the resistance fighters less heroic though:salute:
|