I don't think it is as easy as saying "Good or Bad"

Its getting better, thanks to the Mods and makers. As a off the shelve game its "interesting"

Its not good

Everything takes time, but Ubi could help us, at least if you are not already quit working.
Finally, a couple million dollars / euros have gone into the treasury.
They make the copy save and what we have for protection?
I'm optimistic!:hmmm:
-----------------------
Alles braucht seine Zeit , aber Ubi könnte uns wenigstens unterstützen wenn Sie die Arbeit schon nicht Beenden.
Schließlich sind ein Paar Millionen $ / Euros in die Kasse gegangen.
Sie machen den Kopierschutz und was haben wir für einen Schutz??
Ich bin Optimistisch !!!

More good than bad.

less bad than good.

:rotfl2:

Pessimist. :O:

at 11 a.m., 60 % of "the community" think SH5 is good...:rock:

I don't have it so I'm not voting. But from all that I've read here at Subsim, at the official site's forum, at other sim forums, and at Amazon...I would say the title is unfinished. I know this is not what you would want to hear but really, imagine asking an art critic to judge a painting or sculpture that is only 75% complete.

I am also wondering how many more times a submarine simulation will be released that only becomes satisfactory after it has been modded considerably? In other words, the stock product is a failure to anyone who bought the title specifically for the submarine simulation experience. It's one thing to mod a game (just as many people like to put aftermarket parts on their car) but with these simulations the mods are there to fix things as often if not more than to enhance. This is really deplorable in my opinion.

It's happened enough times now that I think it's reasonable to say the company (Ubisoft) is counting on the modders to make the simulation right at their own expense. It's no longer by accident. If you believe that you are kidding yourselves.

Good 4 what cannot connect to the servers:rotfl2:

Bugs:rotfl2:

Let the free unpaid modders sort it out :down:Whats good about this release from ubisoft,:cry::cry:

How can people support them.

So you're judging a game that you don't own and that you think is unfinished?

And whe're the ones that are kidding ourselfs? :lol:

At least wait 'till it's in a more polished state (from patches, not modders) and you've experienced it yourself, then you can rip it apart as much as you want. ;)

:rotfl2:s you

If you relied on just patches from ubi soft:rotfl2:there is not much of a game.
ITS THE MODDERS THAT MAKE THE GAME. Just look in the mod section.

Our get some GLASSES:har:

62.5% !!!

thanks Ubi for such a popular sim...:rock:

u need dictionary so u can spell

:har::har::har::har:

Silent Hunter 5 is the best sub sim ive ever played and i love it, thanks UBI :up:

NoLine

If you relied on just patches from ubi soft:rotfl2:there is not much of a game.
ITS THE MODDERS THAT MAKE THE GAME. Just look in the mod section.

Please correct me on this spelling.:hmmm: Bilge_Rat

very good...much like the game...:arrgh!: