SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 5 (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=244)
-   -   Was there ever a need for online save games? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=161371)

Letum 02-06-10 06:33 AM

There are programs about that will upload saves from any game to a server. Sh3, Sh3, any game.

If you haven't heard about such things; thats because no one needs/uses them.

Schroeder 02-06-10 06:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trenken (Post 1259562)
But ive had game saves for games that were offline become corrupt.

Just out of curiosity, how is storing the save game on a server preventing it from being corrupted? I guess it doesn't get corrupted by the hard drive (otherwise all of your data would be corrupted, not just saves) but by bugs in the game's save function and/or OS. The server can only store what was sent to it and working as an external hard drive (or at least that's what I think). So my guess is, if the save is getting corrupted by your machine then the save on the server will be just as corrupted as the one on your system.
Or do I have a wrong understanding of all of this?:06:

Letum 02-06-10 06:54 AM

And even if HDDs did corrupt files* then having it on a server won't help.
It's still stored on a HDD, just the server's HDD, not yours.



*if this did happen you would never be able to boot up, let alone load saves.

JU_88 02-06-10 07:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by aaronblood (Post 1259493)
I'm just curious if this adds any value at all to anyone.?

Yes if you just reinstalled your OS or upgraded to a different machine and forgot to back up your save files.

-Other than that, none what so ever.

Mud 02-06-10 07:07 AM

It's like parking my motorcycle in the garage and give the key to a total stranger.
The stranger tells me he keep it save so I won't lose my key and I can get it back anytime, do I trust him ... No Sir.

Mud

HundertzehnGustav 02-06-10 07:29 AM

but he isnt a stranger! you already bought your Motorcicle from him!
it cost 50 bucks and came with a DVD case!:D

you can trust him, no problem.:hmmm:


:haha::haha:

Mud 02-06-10 07:50 AM

Nice point you've made there :up:
But every time I give the key doesn't feel I completely own the motorcycle.

Mud

SubSim Skipper 02-06-10 07:51 AM

I think I can say with a fair amount of reason that, UBI is not doing me any favors by allowing me to save my games online....as a matter of fact I could care less and would just as soon keep them on my PC. I imagine that the files can corrupt just as easily on their drives as they can mine.

HundertzehnGustav 02-06-10 08:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mud (Post 1259797)
Nice point you've made there :up:
But every time I give the key doesn't feel I completely own the motorcycle.

Mud

ah that, my friend, is a feeling i can relate to. i mean, he could just change the lock, or NOT BE THERE when you need to access the garage...

but on the other hand, he would not do that. he would lose you as a customer. And his customers, he cares about!

Right? i mean... he cares, does he not?

:hmmm:
:dead:

utops 02-06-10 09:02 AM

This kind of "service" is real pain in the eye when is related to sh5
So what i can install game on many computers i like, when probaly my copy of sh5 will be submerged in mod soup... because picture from what i see on screens and clips don`t satysfying me.
Besides i`ve got only one computer and i bet more ppl like me has one gaming unit to use.(Not mention retro freaks here :) )
Ubicorp maybe make games for Richie Riches? If so, then sorry im not target for theirs marketing.

psykopatsak 02-06-10 09:18 AM

my parents are divorced. so before i bought my own laptop, this could have been VERY handy...

Brag 02-06-10 09:33 AM

If Ubi offered a choice where you could play offline, then save online if you wanted to, this would be a great benefit! :salute:

After losing the first manuscript of Kingmaker, I save my work online in case of fire, theft or other disaster. But this is voluntary. I don't need to log in or stay online to work.

The Enigma 02-06-10 12:58 PM

I've never asked for such service and I would never use such service.

I wonna play off line. No more no less.

tater 02-06-10 01:39 PM

Strikes me this doubles the chance of a save game failure. Maybe triples.

Local save can be corrupted by a bad sector on a HDD, and same can happen on a remote drive. DOuble chance of failure. The game coupld check the 2 saves vs each other, but is the files are different, which does it chose?

Then there are lost packets on the net. A 3d way to corrupt the data.

Since offline is not possible (DL savew to laptop, play on plane), where is the added value, exactly? I'm not seeing it.

Brag 02-06-10 03:14 PM

So far, they have not shown one single benefit for the user--bound to fail.

:D even if you have one hundred computers


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:23 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.