SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   Silent Hunter 4: Wolves of the Pacific (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=202)
-   -   Hey UbiSoft! How about a SecuROM-less executable? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=132746)

Digital_Trucker 03-10-08 01:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TDK1044
Personal opinion....Starforce was useless and intrusive. SecuRom is just useless. At least it's a move in the right direction. :D

I like the way you think, sir:up:

The copy protection issue has been with us since I can remember. It basically is as useless now as it was in the BBS days. Where there is a will to crack it, it will be cracked. The only ones who are inconvenienced by copy protection are the people who legitimately purchase the software.

I won't start with the whole Sony rant because, frankly, my balance is too bad to be climbing up on a soap box.

Taking an "oh you can remove it later" attitude is not the sensible approach. Voicing concern over the invasion of our computers by the likes of Sony's (oops, I said that four letter word) viruses and rootkits is the only way to effect any changes. It may be a bit of "tilting at windmills" but so many "revolutionary" ideas started as just that.

If we say we are POed about this crap and nothing happens, then so be it, but if we never complain about the crap to begin with, then we deserve it.

<climbs down from soap box to the tune of the Who's "We're Not Gonna Take It">

Rockin Robbins 03-10-08 01:35 PM

Nope!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Major Johnson
Ok, so I have a question. Seeing how I am the owner of a legal copy of SH4, and if I wanted to make a backup for protection sake, like in case my original gets damaged, would this Securom prohibit me from making a backup of something I legally purchased?? Back in the day, when the compac disk first came out, they were referred to as "practically" indestructable. This we all know, came to be proven false. I like to have a backup of my software.

No foul there. The downloaded installation file is easily and without restrictions able to be burned to a CD. You could conceivably save it to Filefront too, if you just wanted off-site backup. Finally, Direct2Drive lets you redownload previously purchased software that you have bought from them.

So that part is fine.

Edit: oops I thought you were talking about the add-on. The original CD does have copy protection and a normal copy will not work at all. There are ways to make a copy, which is allowed under law, but I understand the tools themselves to produce these allowed copies cannot be specifically discussed here. As a website owner you can't afford the consequences of someone stealing software based on instructions they received on your website. We don't encourage or condone piracy here. Piracy is why we've got our panties in a wad as it is.:rotfl:

DeepIron 03-10-08 01:37 PM

Quote:

FYI, I too know my way around an OS, which is how I know the process required to remove SecuRom. Wanna Dance?:p
Sure.. let's rhumba... ;)

Ok, just to verify something... I completely stripped all SH related files from my system, cleaned the registry, etc. and re-installed Sh4 1.3 from the DVD.

There are no SecuROM files or processes installed or running on my PC...

Installed the 1.4 patch. No SecuROM...
Installed the 1.5 downloadable add-on. NOW I've got SecuROM.:down:

So, if SecuROM should have been installed at 1.3 and was not (at least in my case), then there is something fishy about either SecuROM or my OS... either and/or both would not be beyond suspicion...

[EDIT] A quick disassembly of the original 1.3 sh4.exe file shows a .securom code section. Hmm, wonder why it didn't execute before?

danlisa 03-10-08 01:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeepIron
and re-installed Sh4 1.3 from the DVD.

Um, you won't have SecuRom if you installed directly to v1.3, cos it was dropped with that patch. However, the DVD v1.0 did have SR on it, which is what I said in my post.

These versions have SecuRom:
v1.0
v1.1
v1.2
v1.5

These do not:
v1.3
v1.4

Now, that said, I entirely agree with you. Why have SR reinstated in the v1.5 patch?

While I take acception to it's inclusion, I can understand the reasons why, but I have taken it upon myself to remove it, and why not?:D

Rockin Robbins 03-10-08 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeepIron
Quote:

FYI, I too know my way around an OS, which is how I know the process required to remove SecuRom. Wanna Dance?:p
Sure.. let's rhumba... ;)

Ok, just to verify something... I completely stripped all SH related files from my system, cleaned the registry, etc. and re-installed Sh4 1.3 from the DVD.

STOP!!!!!! Danlisa is assuming you install from an original SH4 1.0 DVD. They included SecuROM. Round awarded to DeepIron. Sorry danlisa, it was close.

Now in addition to our original ammunition, DeepIron reveals that UBI sold DVDs without protection. That really strengthens our position. What changed? The nice sales weasel with the scary stories, that's what!

I'm getting off the thread. The SecuROM situation is important to protest once in awhile, but there is a point of propriety. We're there.

DavyJonesFootlocker 03-10-08 01:58 PM

I wanna take Ubi to court!:hmm::yep::rotfl:

danlisa 03-10-08 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
STOP!!!!!! Danlisa is assuming you install from an original SH4 1.0 DVD. They included SecuROM. Round awarded to DeepIron. Sorry danlisa, it was close.

Balls!:rotfl: Why wouldn't one assume a fresh installation was from v1.0? It should have been stated in DeepIrons arguement.

Oh and FYI, anyone who did install from v1.0 and then patch up will still have SecuRom dormant on their system. Why have we not heard from them? Answer, because it doesn't cause them any problems.

Round to me or (at the very least) a Draw.:D

Damn, my feet hurt. I should have worn comfortable shoes for this dance.

Dowly 03-10-08 02:01 PM

I only know of one CP that actually works. Theatre of War's. You get a license number when you buy it or if you dont have an internet, you have to call them and get it. AFAIK, still remains un-cracked and I'd like to see other games use this method too. Bin the SF & SR crap, does more to hurt than help.

DeepIron 03-10-08 02:05 PM

Quote:

These versions have SecuRom:
v1.0
v1.1
v1.2
v1.5

These do not:
v1.3
v1.4

Now, that said, I entirely agree with you. Why have SR reinstated in the v1.5 patch?
Man, this is weird. Right off hand, I'd have to say that perhaps Ubi has some versioning control problems... So, let me read this correctly, v1.0 - v1.3 inclusive were DVD issued. v.1.4 was a downloadable patch and v1.5 seems to be in both media...

So, I got a v1.3 DVD with an sh4 executable that contains SecuROM code that shouldn't be there... and doesn't work anyway... hmmm....

danlisa 03-10-08 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeepIron
So, let me read this correctly, v1.0 - v1.3 inclusive were DVD issued. v.1.4 was a downloadable patch and v1.5 seems to be in both media...

Not quite.

V1.0 was DVD as was v1.3 (also downloadable), the rest (excluding v1.5, which is both) were downloadable.

It makes sense that v1.3 would be re-issued on DVD without SecuRom as it was the first patch that removed the requirement for the DVD.

Quote:

So, I got a v1.3 DVD with an sh4 executable that contains SecuROM code that isn't activated...
As my copy is v1.0 I couldn't comment on whether v1.3 even contains SecuRom.

AVGWarhawk 03-10-08 02:56 PM

The secuROM does absolutely nothing other than let you download the game when you purchase it. I have it on my computer. It has sat dormant since last year. It became active when I downloaded the add-on. It went back to sleep when done. No ill affects on my computer. Would it have been nice to know secuROM was being loaded? Sure. It was not told to me and I will get over it. Let it go and play the game:up:

DeepIron 03-10-08 03:05 PM

Quote:

As my copy is v1.0 I couldn't comment on whether v1.3 even contains SecuRom.
Fair enough, and you can trust me on this one. The v1.3 sh4.exe file has SecuROM code in it... I've disassembled enough of it to find the VERSION section:

Code:

Structure for 1
Signature:        0xFEEF04BD
StrucVersion:    0x00010000
FileVersionMS:    0x00010003
FileVersionLS:    0x00000000
ProductVersionMS: 0x00010003
ProductVersionLS: 0x00000000
FileFlagsMask:    0x00000017
FileFlags:        0x00000000
FileOS:          0x00000004
FileType:        0x00000001
FileSubtype:      0x00000000
FileDateMS:      0x00000000
FileDateLS:      0x00000000
 
VS_VERSION_INFO VERSIONINFO
    FILEVERSION 1,3,0,0
    PRODUCTVERSION 1,3,0,0
    FILEFLAGSMASK 0x17L
    FILEFLAGS 0x0L
    FILEOS 0x4L
    FILETYPE 0x1L
    FILESUBTYPE 0x0L


flag4 03-10-08 03:18 PM

wow it's gettn' hotter

while y'all hack it out

how does this affect the novice like me who's about to insatll SH4 + u boat missions
from afresh..... or am i missing the point, in that, there isnt one - just install, click 'yes' to everything, patch up to 1.5 and off i go ?

AVGWarhawk 03-10-08 03:23 PM

SecruROM is out there to get the Developers their compensation for the thousands of man hours put into this game. Read below. How do you think the modders feel? Their hard work now on someone elses computer. It is being distributed and looks like for a fee. So really fellas , what is the big issue here? Other games have this as well.



http://www.subsim.com/radioroom/show...814#post802814

tater 03-10-08 03:28 PM

If you installed but didn't run SH 1.5, could someone with the DVD send you thei exe file, and you'd be golden?

tater


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:14 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.