SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   General Topics (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=175)
-   -   Turkey Recalls US Ambassador (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=123347)

August 10-11-07 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird
america has strategic and military interests in Turkey, and that is the only reason the WH tries to fight against that justified classification of the Armenian killings as genocide.

I agree Skybird, but on the other hand the only reason the Democrat controlled US Congress is doing this now is to further hamstring Bush.

bookworm_020 10-11-07 06:04 PM

Most turks admit that it did happen. It's just politicians trying to score brownie points. I believe when the term genocide was created, the Armenians were giving as an example.

The fact is that 40 states of America already recognize it as the Armenian genocide.

geetrue 10-12-07 12:41 PM

Turkey May Invade Northern Iraq

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?p...FCQ&refer=home

Now oil has risen to it's highest ever to $84 a barrel ...

Just because they think this may result in war for Northern Iraq's Kurd area ...

Doesn't look good for our side to be coming home any time soon if war breaks out up north does it?

Tchocky 10-12-07 01:01 PM

Turkey Recalls US Ambassador
 
Ah yes, his name was Johnson, hmm?

Big burly fellow, liked hunting.

DeepIron 10-12-07 03:37 PM

<RANT MODE ON>
Just once, JUST ONCE for cryin' out loud...:damn:
Can't the US government keep it's meddling and opinions to itself? :damn::damn::damn:

Stupid, stupid, stupid! Why in the world should we even be involved in this? This is not an American affair. :damn:

All this does is further the image that American's are meddling bullies who just have to stick our noses in someone's else business... :down:

We have enough problems of our own without alienating yet another ally... :down:

<RANT MODE OFF>

bradclark1 10-12-07 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by August
Quote:

Originally Posted by Skybird
america has strategic and military interests in Turkey, and that is the only reason the WH tries to fight against that justified classification of the Armenian killings as genocide.

I agree Skybird, but on the other hand the only reason the Democrat controlled US Congress is doing this now is to further hamstring Bush.

Yes it would seem so. Pretty damn stupid thing to do right now.:nope:

Sea Demon 10-12-07 08:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by August
I agree Skybird, but on the other hand the only reason the Democrat controlled US Congress is doing this now is to further hamstring Bush.

Actually it's alot deeper than that August. The Democrats are purposely trying to cause harm to one of America's allies in the War, to cause a split between us and them. The enemies in the region are being aided and abetted by these Democrats in OUR own Congress. The Democrats are simply trying to harm a U.S. ally in the Iraq war, and cause problems for America in keeping stable allies in the region. This is simply a gutless, and treasonous way of getting America to lose the war. These Democrats will not be happy unless we lose. They are totally seeking for us to lose. The only thing that's new is that this is the first blatant direct support we've seen by the Democrats to support the terrorist insurgency in Iraq. They've done much indirectly to help them out in the past. This sickens me.

AntEater 10-13-07 07:50 AM

A nice ally who:

- just elected a muslim fundamentalist as president, to compliment a muslim fundamentalist prime minister. The fact that Erdogan and Gül are not rabble-rousers like Ahmadinejad does not mean they're any more tolerant of non muslims than he is.

- who's "western" component is largely based on the model of Mussolini's Italy

- whose majority of population regards the US as hostile and likes to reads books in which heroic turkish secret agents nuke Washington D.C. with a suitcase bomb. Not to mention "Valley of the Wolves"

- where Christians are actively persecuted, antique sites of non muslim origin are deliberately demolished or neglected

- Actively tried and still tries to pursue the goal of a "greater Turkey" in Asia, as well as reestablishing ottoman holds on the Balkans. Western Europe and the US may have forgotten what the Ottoman empire was, but Serbs, Bulgarians, Greeks and Rumanians haven't.

Not to mention the Kurds, who are basically the world's largest people without a nation. Actually a kurdish state in northern Iraq (and southern Turkey) would be a far better ally than Turkey.


Of course there is a pro western Turkey, people who in way of life are more similar to Italy or Greece or Israel than to the islamic world. Those people are pro western (meaning they hate the US only about as much as the average western european :D), but they are raplidly outbred by the islamic part of turkey. Until recently, this small minority dominated politics, the military and the economy. By enforcing democratization and privatization of the economy (Turkey was pretty much a state run economy until recently), the west took away their hold on power. The "Apes" (as one westernized Turk I know calls them) are simply more than the "normal people", so they win elections.
Ironically, a democratic turkey can't be a friend of the US, that is a simply question of math.
If you've got 80% of people who are islamists, want the Ottoman empire back (which basically means subjugating the whole balkans and much of Asia) and hate the US and you have a democracy, you have really a great ally.
The only way Turkey stays pro US is with a military coup, Congress or not.

bradclark1 10-13-07 08:26 AM

Yes, but for now they are letting us use their space and facilities. That is what this is all about. We are using them plain and simple but they are getting paid for it in various ways. If Turkey pulls away or should I say if we push them away the logistcs for our forces in Iraq are going to be a lot harder. Not impossible, but harder. I'm all for getting them out of Iraq but not provide undue hardship on them.

Happy Times 10-13-07 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bradclark1
Yes, but for now they are letting us use their space and facilities. That is what this is all about. We are using them plain and simple but they are getting paid for it in various ways. If Turkey pulls away or should I say if we push them away the logistcs for our forces in Iraq are going to be a lot harder. Not impossible, but harder. I'm all for getting them out of Iraq but not provide undue hardship on them.

Is it good to make foreign policy on a short term perpective? The average Turk hates Americans and Europeans.. Some Europeans may dislike somethings in America but they still feel you as relatives. Blood is thicker than water.

geetrue 10-13-07 10:23 AM

Turkey has been planning this aggression against the Kurds and what they call the PKK, some kind of rebel group, for a long time now.

It wasn't just the US Congress vote about murdering over one million people in 1915 that caused this huge border problem between Turkey and Iraq.

True the timing is suspected politics by the democratic wing of the US Congress, but the Armenians have been trying to pass this resoulution for years.

Take a look at the headlines for just the last few days for an eye opener on tanks, planes, helicopters and men ready to attack.

One article gives us a clue that Turkey wants a buffer zone. This could be their aim to attack and pull back to cause a buffer zone to stop the rebels from setting up a country within their country.

When you look at it like that it's hard not to be on Turkey's side.

Turkey Ponders Iraq Campaign
The Associated Press - Oct 12, 2007
ANKARA, Turkey (AP) — Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said Friday that Turkey would not be deterred by the possible consequences of invading Iraq if it ...

Turkey ready to face world criticism over Iraq
Reuters Canada, Canada - Oct 12, 2007
ISTANBUL (Reuters) - Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan said on Friday Ankara was prepared to face up to international criticism if it launched an attack ...



Petraeus Concerned Over Turkish Tension
The Associated Press - Oct 11, 2007
BAGHDAD (AP) — The top US commander in Iraq warned Thursday that Turkey's threatened incursion into Kurdish regions in the north of the country could harm ...

Turkey moves closer to a military campaign in Iraq, but still ...
International Herald Tribune, France - Oct 11, 2007
AP ISTANBUL, Turkey: Turkey's parliament could approve a cross-border offensive against Kurdish rebels in Iraq as soon as next week, but that doesn't mean a ...

Turkish govt to seek go-ahead for Iraq incursion next week
Africasia, UK - Oct 11, 2007
The Turkish government will formally ask parliament next week to approve an incursion into northern Iraq to crack down on Kurdish rebels taking refuge there ...

Turkey condemns US over Armenian genocide resolution
Guardian Unlimited, UK - Oct 11, 2007
Turkey today condemned a US congressional committee for approving a resolution that recognises the 1915 massacres of Armenians by Ottoman Turks as genocide. ...

Turkish tanks ready to roll into Iraq in
Times Online, UK - Oct 10, 2007
Turkey was preparing to send troops and tanks into northern Iraq yesterday as the Government came under intense pressure to avenge the deaths of Turkish ...

Turkey readying military operation against Iraqi Kurds
USA Today - Oct 10, 2007
ISTANBUL (AP) — A motion calling for a Turkish military incursion against Kurdish rebels in northern Iraq will soon be presented to Parliament, ...

Anti-PKK Campaign
Arab News, Saudi Arabia - Oct 10, 2007
TURKEY is rightly furious at Sunday’s killing of 12 soldiers, the highest military death toll in a dozen years. According to reports, Turkish troops ...

Turkey Escalates Offensive Near Border
The Associated Press - Oct 10, 2007
SIRNAK, Turkey (AP) — Turkish warplanes and helicopter gunships attacked suspected positions of Kurdish rebels near Iraq on Wednesday, a possible prelude to ...



W.House cautions Turkey against Iraq incursion
Reuters - Oct 10, 2007
WASHINGTON, Oct 10 (Reuters) - The White House on Wednesday cautioned Turkey against making a military incursion into northern Iraq after Kurdish rebels ...

Turkey confirms army operation plans for Iraq
Swissinfo, Switzerland - Oct 10, 2007
By Hidir Goktas ANKARA (Reuters) - Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan confirmed on Wednesday his government was drawing up plans to authorise a military ...

US sends top envoys as Turkey gears up plans for Iraq incursion
DigitalJournal.com, Canada - 1 hour ago
The United States dispatched two top officials to Ankara on Saturday amid a breakdown in relations between the two NATO allies and growing concern that ...

Turkey resolute to crush PKK
PRESS TV, Iran - 20 hours ago
Turkish PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan has warned he will not wait for US permission to order Turkish armed forces to fight Kurdish rebels. ...

Tension arises between Turkey, US
Contra Costa Times, CA - Oct 12, 2007
By Molly Moore ISTANBUL, Turkey -- The Turkish government warned Thursday that a congressional committee vote labeling the mass killings of Armenians during ...

Trouble's brewing in Turkey
Ottawa Citizen, Canada - Oct 12, 2007
Turkey's threat to invade northern Iraq to crush Kurdish guerrillas has serious implications not just for Iraq's stability but also for Turkey's relations ...

Turkey Prepares for Incursions into Iraq
Independent Media Review Analysis (IMRA), Israel - Oct 11, 2007
rebels. The US is warning against such a move and Iraq has said it would Thursday. It would then be voted upon as early as next week and would give the ...

The United States wants Turkey to stay out of Iraq
OverTheLimit.info, Canada - Oct 11, 2007
The United States has come out and stated that they oppose Turkey’s attempt to become involved in Iraq by launching a unilateral incursion into Iraq to go ...

Government to seek authorization from parliament for a cross ...
Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey - Oct 11, 2007
The government will send a motion to Parliament next week requesting authorization for a cross-border operation into northern Iraq to deal with a terrorist ...

Turkey steps up measures to fight against PKK
China Internet Information Center|, China - Oct 10, 2007
In the face of mounting terrorist activities of the outlawed Kurdish Workers' Party (PKK) and growing tension with the US and Iraq, Turkish government and ...

Turkish PM Erdogan confirms Iraq plan
People's Daily Online, China - Oct 10, 2007
Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan confirmed yesterday his government was drawing up plans to authorize a military incursion into northern Iraq to crush ...

Turkish military pounds Kurdish rebel camps
Gulf News, United Arab Emirates - Oct 10, 2007
AP Sirnak, Turkey: Turkish troops pounded suspected Kurdish rebel camps in northern Iraq with artillery fire, a newspaper reported yesterday, ...

Turkish warplanes attack Kurd rebel posts in Iraq
Kuwait Times, Kuwait - Oct 10, 2007
SIRNAK, Turkey: Turkish warplanes and helicopter gunships attacked the suspected positions of Kurdish rebels near Iraq yesterday and police detained 20 ...

Turkey: Looking to Formalize a Buffer Zone?
Stratfor (subscription) - Oct 10, 2007
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said before heading into parliament Oct. 10 that his government is busily preparing for a military incursion ...

EU stresses need for Iraq’s unity, as Turkey threatens incursion
Khaleej Times, United Arab Emirates - Oct 10, 2007
BRUSSELS - The European Commission Wednesday underscored the need to maintain Iraq’s sovereignty and integrity following Turkish threats of a border ...

bradclark1 10-13-07 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Happy Times
Is it good to make foreign policy on a short term perpective? The average Turk hates Americans and Europeans.. Some Europeans may dislike somethings in America but they still feel you as relatives. Blood is thicker than water.

It's not good but it serves the purpose. The Turks wouldn't let us use their facilities until they were sure Saddam was finished, then they let us bribe them. They aren't doing this for nothing. Iraq calls for strange bedfellows as does Afghanistan with Pakistan. We've caused a real cluster ******* in the region and the U.S. does not need to make it worse for ourselves by playing silly political games at the moment. To me this is a serious Democratic (and a few Republicans) political blunder. This is going to bite them back and hopefully take some leadership casualties because we don't need spiteful people in those positions.

AntEater 10-13-07 11:00 AM

Strange bedfellows indeed.
The Kurds in northern Iraq are pretty much the only group in Iraq not trying to murder americans on a daily basis.
They want independence, granted, but killing americans or waging jihad is not on their political agenda.
Now the US is supposed to help Turkey invade the only "safe haven" the US has in Iraq, thereby destroying (among other things) the only safe oil production facilities in the country, the only R&R area in theater and other things.
We're not talking commando raids here (these happen all the time), but a large scale military invasion with all the boy's toys like tanks and such.

Given the US presence there it wouldnt suprise me if some americans would actually get killed in this operation, as the turkish military isnt exactly renowned for neither surgical precision or subtleness of approach.
And what will US forces do if faced with the attrocities which are bound to happen, given the racial hatred and the conscript nature of the turkish army.
Will US forces stand by and watch when Turks cause a massacre?
If Saddam massacres Kurds = bad, if Turkey does = good?
Score another big PR point for Bush if that happens.
Ok, the other option, engaging a NATO ally in combat isnt really a great one either.

bradclark1 10-13-07 12:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AntEater
Strange bedfellows indeed.

Yes. This is about the genocide that has been on the table since whenever and hasn't passed a vote until right now when it would have the worst impact. It's about using Turkey who we have never gotten along with politically as a key logistics point. Until the Turks actually invade in force they are sabre rattling because I'd guess that the U.S. is trying to give them incentives not to cross the border. It's about using and being used. It's about the trade offs. If they weren't being used as a logistics center we'd probably have a force on the border already sabre rattling right back.
So yes 'strange bedfellows'.

TteFAboB 10-13-07 10:16 PM

The genocide is rubbed in their face, an ******* leaves the country and everybody can tell Pelosi is being an opportunist.

I can't see anything wrong in any of this.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:16 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.