Sailor Steve |
05-01-11 06:09 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zedi
(Post 1654559)
Yeah guys, please take your time and work this out in every detail. Would be nice if you guys can work out all the ships, including those from Uekel. Im very busy now by adding every major historical convoy to the campaign and that will take a while, so there is no rush.
|
Though this is a noble idea, I see a couple of potential problems. Are you leaving the convoys randomized, or will they be scripted with the actual ships? Will you even have the specific individual convoys or will all the 'HX' convoys be represented by a route with the actual convoys randomized? The reason I ask is that if every specific convoy is placed on the map, players will be able to look them up and track them from start to finish, which ends up being less realistic rather than more.
Ducimus faced a similar problem in his work on SH4. Which is more realistic - having things exactly as they were, which gives the player information he wouldn't have had in real life, or making things worse than they really were, which makes the player realistically cautious?
Quote:
Btw, if is possible, please split these ships for every nation. I wanna make the convoys very historically accurate, so I need ships from every nation. At least 1 cargo and tanker for every nation. Ah.. and before I place them into the campaign, I need to divert them into my paint shop first :P
|
Not every nation had every kind of ship. Estonia, for example, had only twenty-three ships in her merchant fleet, and the very newest of them was built back in 1918. I can help provide a lot of the information on individual ships based on the research I've done for my SH3 Ship Names mod, but as I said I believe there's a possibility that the more detailed you make it the less realistic it becomes, since hindsight gives us information no one could possibly have had at the time.
|