SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   SH4 Mods Workshop (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=219)
-   -   All members read this (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=138774)

Dowly 07-05-08 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MONOLITH
RR's post is spot on.

And this...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
That is the coopetition (Darrell Waltrip word there:up:) that has made the SH4 modding community the great place it is. It is the ingredient that has been missing so far from the SH3 modders' world, which has unfortunately been a theater of oneupsmanship. Maybe that will change, but there are plenty of examples, the attempted supression of OLC GUI, the reverse engineering of NYGM to take the ship damage model without asking the NYGM modding crew. Sorry, but I'm on record as saying you should support your conclusions with facts and that cuts both ways.

I believe is really the heart of the matter.

This has never, imo, been about who like u-boats vs who likes PTO. It has been about the SH4 modding community not wanting what is described above, to move from SH3 to SH4.

And the closer that came, the more hostile the environment in SH4 became.

I'm not sure I understand the need to seperate communities, when it's the behaviors, not the geographies, that is the problem.

Then that'll be the SHIV guys' problem. If they dont want the SH3 community to mix with SHIV commmunity, go somewhere else. The last time I checked, Neal owns the site and calls the shots. You dont have the right to say who can come to the SHIV and who cant.

lurker_hlb3 07-05-08 10:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
It is a public forum. Some Subsim members post the link as part of their signature with every post they make. We invite every Subsim member to drop by for a visit and talk to the vast array of talented modders who congregate there.

Actually, both of my email addresses I use have been banned from kickinbak. This' the open and helpfull SHIV community you all are talking of? :roll:

I have moderator privileges at “kickinbak” so I can manage me campaign work.
Base on you “pubic profile” here at SS, you use hotmail.com for your emails. “ANY” email from hotmail.com is banned because of “spammers”; if you wish to join us then don’t us a “general” email account like hotmail.com.

As you can see we are not out to “BAN” you

Dowly 07-05-08 10:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lurker_hlb3
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
It is a public forum. Some Subsim members post the link as part of their signature with every post they make. We invite every Subsim member to drop by for a visit and talk to the vast array of talented modders who congregate there.

Actually, both of my email addresses I use have been banned from kickinbak. This' the open and helpfull SHIV community you all are talking of? :roll:

I have moderator privileges at “kickinbak” so I can manage me campaign work.
Base on you “pubic profile” here at SS you use hotmail.com for your emails. “ANY” email from hotmail.com is banned because of “spammers”; if you wish to join us then don’t us a “general” email account like hotmail.com.

As you can see we are not out to “BAN” you personnel

Is Gmail.com on the ban list aswell? That's the other account which is banned. But like I already said, worry not, I have no need to register atm. :up:

TDK1044 07-05-08 10:34 AM

As much as this Forum might try to be all things to all people, it can't be. This is Neals's house. He sets the rules and selects the Moderators...not some small group of Drama Queens from the modding community who can't get along.

The vast majority of people here enjoy and respect subsim. If you don't, please feel free to leave.

MONOLITH 07-05-08 10:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Then that'll be the SHIV guys' problem. If they dont want the SH3 community to mix with SHIV commmunity, go somewhere else. The last time I checked, Neal owns the site and calls the shots. You dont have the right to say who can come to the SHIV and who cant.


That's exactly right Dowly.

But they do have the right to protest unproductive behaviors. Including yours.

Dowly 07-05-08 10:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MONOLITH
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Then that'll be the SHIV guys' problem. If they dont want the SH3 community to mix with SHIV commmunity, go somewhere else. The last time I checked, Neal owns the site and calls the shots. You dont have the right to say who can come to the SHIV and who cant.

That's exactly right Dowly.

But they do have the right to protest unproductive behaviors. Including yours.

Yes they have. Everyone also have the right to be unproductive if they so choose. :p

lurker_hlb3 07-05-08 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by lurker_hlb3
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
It is a public forum. Some Subsim members post the link as part of their signature with every post they make. We invite every Subsim member to drop by for a visit and talk to the vast array of talented modders who congregate there.

Actually, both of my email addresses I use have been banned from kickinbak. This' the open and helpfull SHIV community you all are talking of? :roll:

I have moderator privileges at “kickinbak” so I can manage me campaign work.
Base on you “pubic profile” here at SS you use hotmail.com for your emails. “ANY” email from hotmail.com is banned because of “spammers”; if you wish to join us then don’t us a “general” email account like hotmail.com.

As you can see we are not out to “BAN” you personnel

Is Gmail.com on the ban list aswell? That's the other account which is banned. But like I already said, worry not, I have no need to register atm. :up:

Yes "ALL" general email accounts are banned.

Takeda Shingen 07-05-08 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by MONOLITH
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Then that'll be the SHIV guys' problem. If they dont want the SH3 community to mix with SHIV commmunity, go somewhere else. The last time I checked, Neal owns the site and calls the shots. You dont have the right to say who can come to the SHIV and who cant.

That's exactly right Dowly.

But they do have the right to protest unproductive behaviors. Including yours.

Yes they have. Everyone also have the right to be unproductive if they so choose. :p

Take it to PM, guys.

_Seth_ 07-05-08 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rockin Robbins
Quote:

Originally Posted by _Seth_
:nope: And this is really the way you folks think it should be...?

Can you elaborate so we can all benefit? Love your signature. Who says SH3 is yesterday's sim? That's awesome!

Thanks, mate, i love it too! :yep::up:
I'm thinking about the arguing,ranting and all the other negative things that have lead to the situation beeing like it is. People going mad at each other for things like "who did what" and "who said what". I wont go as far as naming names; that wont solve anything, but i believe everyone sees that this aint doing subsim any good. Subsim has been one of the most dedicated and professional forums on the web for a long time, and this is because of the members attitude and interest for the games they love to play. Developers and modders have done their best to make the games even better, and they have all contributed in making the games survive in the changing world of computer games. They are all credited for that job, no doubt, a job they have done on their spare time, maybe missing time to be with their friends and family. We as part of this community have shared ups and downs here, from the arrival of new members and mods, to the sad loss of fellow skippers and good friends. And i don''t want to see this forum loosing it's best quality because some folks have decided to make other people's life a misery. And deep inside me, i dont think any of you will either.

The truth is just as Takeda says; The problem is that party X cannot get along with party Y and vice versa. To me, thats fine. I have no problems understanding that noone has to like the other faction. But; Respect for the other opinion should always be present. And thats the core value; Respect for your fellow mateys. You can't ask for more than that.

Dowly 07-05-08 10:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Takeda Shingen
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Quote:

Originally Posted by MONOLITH
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Then that'll be the SHIV guys' problem. If they dont want the SH3 community to mix with SHIV commmunity, go somewhere else. The last time I checked, Neal owns the site and calls the shots. You dont have the right to say who can come to the SHIV and who cant.

That's exactly right Dowly.

But they do have the right to protest unproductive behaviors. Including yours.

Yes they have. Everyone also have the right to be unproductive if they so choose. :p

Take it to PM, guys.

Why? What? When? :o

All I am saying is that if one doesnt want to share, for example, a tool he has made, for the community he doesnt have to. That what I meant by unproductive in my post. And the reasons why one wouldnt want to share his tool has already been mentioned, it might be so hard to understand/get to work by an outsider that it wouldnt be beneficial to release it.

Same goes for explaining something new, just think how much time it would take for [pick your supermod] to document and then explain everything that has been changed.

And at times the modder doesnt even necessarely know 100% what he did to get the end result. A good example being my IL2 mod that changes the fire particles of a burning aircraft to the ones IL2 uses as rocket's backfire. It was a classic case of trial and error and the process took so much time that I have no idea anymore what I exactly did to achieve the end result. :rotfl:

Digital_Trucker 07-05-08 10:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Is Gmail.com on the ban list aswell? That's the other account which is banned. But like I already said, worry not, I have no need to register atm. :up:

As a matter of fact it is. When I tried to register, I was "banned" also, until I spoke to someone who made an exception for my address (which you evidently didn't attempt to do).

Dowly 07-05-08 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Digital_Trucker
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Is Gmail.com on the ban list aswell? That's the other account which is banned. But like I already said, worry not, I have no need to register atm. :up:

As a matter of fact it is. When I tried to register, I was "banned" also, until I spoke to someone who made an exception for my address (which you evidently didn't attempt to do).

Actually I did PM AVG about it here at SubSim, who in return told me to contact Sam. But like I already said twice, I dont have an urge to register there atm. ;)

CDR Resser 07-05-08 11:01 AM

I, personally, agree with the spirit of the petiton. We should all treat each other with the respect that we would require. It is too easy to forget that maxim in such an impersonal and anonymous format, such as this. I also know that we cannot change what has happened in the past, whatever that might be. All we can do now is resolve that the mistakes of the past will not be repeated in the future. If the petition helps people to take a second thought before they do, maybe it can be of some use.

/signed

Regret that it is necessary


Respectfully Submitted;
CDR Resser

Takeda Shingen 07-05-08 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Why? What? When? :o

All I am saying is that if one doesnt want to share, for example, a tool he has made, for the community he doesnt have to. That what I meant by unproductive in my post. And the reasons why one wouldnt want to share his tool has already been mentioned, it might be so hard to understand/get to work by an outsider that it wouldnt be beneficial to release it.

Same goes for explaining something new, just think how much time it would take for [pick your supermod] to document and then explain everything that has been changed.

And at times the modder doesnt even necessarely know 100% what he did to get the end result. A good example being my IL2 mod that changes the fire particles of a burning aircraft to the ones IL2 uses as rocket's backfire. It was a classic case of trial and error and the process took so much time that I have no idea anymore what I exactly did to achieve the end result. :rotfl:

All good and well. Just remember, we're discussing what happens on SubSim.com, not kickinback.com, Politico.com, Somethingawful.com or theonion.com. Keep it on topic and put everything else in PM.

That should go for everyone, not just Dowly. Now let's go back to topic.

Dowly 07-05-08 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Takeda Shingen
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dowly
Why? What? When? :o

All I am saying is that if one doesnt want to share, for example, a tool he has made, for the community he doesnt have to. That what I meant by unproductive in my post. And the reasons why one wouldnt want to share his tool has already been mentioned, it might be so hard to understand/get to work by an outsider that it wouldnt be beneficial to release it.

Same goes for explaining something new, just think how much time it would take for [pick your supermod] to document and then explain everything that has been changed.

And at times the modder doesnt even necessarely know 100% what he did to get the end result. A good example being my IL2 mod that changes the fire particles of a burning aircraft to the ones IL2 uses as rocket's backfire. It was a classic case of trial and error and the process took so much time that I have no idea anymore what I exactly did to achieve the end result. :rotfl:

All good and well. Just remember, we're discussing what happens on SubSim.com, not kickinback.com, Politico.com, Somethingawful.com or theonion.com. Keep it on topic and put everything else in PM.

That should go for everyone, not just Dowly. Now let's go back to topic.

We were talking about what happens in SubSim.com. ;) But sorry, if I made it look like something else. That wasnt my intention. Alles Klar. :up:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2025 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.