Originally Posted by Hans Witteman (Post 1744220)

...
The bad news is that if we go the SH4 way then i will not mod it for both platform too much work involve...
...

Originally Posted by Old_Jakub (Post 1743995)

OK, I understand now ;). I agree with you: in the game we won't see the difference, it looks like real wind. But if we could see this fake-real wind in U-BOOT_HAHD it would be nicely. :up: It is looks much better than in stock SH3.

Regards

Originally Posted by Gedis (Post 1744250)

can we see that magnificent GUI screenshots?

back in the days when sh4 was released i didn't like the GUI, specialy crew managment screen and pacific was soo boring, switched back to sh3 + gwx.
then Uboat missions expansion was released for sh4, i was jumping in joy, but as much as i wanted uboats, GUI with crew managment didn't change, so switched back to sh3 + gwx.
and i still think crew managment screen and ability to drag sailors in slots individually is best in SH3 and GUI is not that strange as in SH4.

but if you can keep similar crew managment screen and GUI as in SH3, then go for SH4 and i think i'll switch to SH4 too :)



P.S. atlantic, it must be atlantic!

Originally Posted by Old_Jakub (Post 1744251)

Hans, I think that you will start the real storm on forum ;).

I played SH4 little because I don't like Pacific theatre. SH4 has a nice graphics but very "candy". It fits the tropics, hot beaches and palms, but will it work with the cold, north Atlantic? SH3 has a dirty, faded and dark graphic. Will you be able to change SH4 colors that they will match to the U-boot war? Color scheme creates the atmosphere. If you decide to change the platform, your current work will be wasted and you will have to start from the beginning?

Regards :salute:

Originally Posted by urfisch (Post 1744259)

@hans

i already applied for the membership, by sending reaper an email. although he hasnt answered yet, i really appreciate your decision, if we talk about modding sh4 with atlantic theater. i love sh3 as it is, but modding in sh4 gives much better results, so the time is much more better invested. and sh4 has the much better gameplay, than sh5. so it definitely is the best platform. steve is right: sh4 is the diamond, that has never been polished.

but its a lot of work, to port over all the nice mods from sh3 to sh4. so we need more human power, i guess. and maybe we also need the creators of some sh3-mods in the team. e.g. the wolfpack addition from h.sie should definitely be part of our supermod. and we need people like privateer or diving duck, who know much about hexediting.

and the creator of the monsun mod should also join the crew, as we want the atlantic theater, right?! finally one can say: its a huge amount of work, but its worth it!

:salute:

Originally Posted by BUKER (Post 1744264)

Very accurately noticed!:up:


What?
Diamond?
I find it funny....:haha::har:



Hans personally I am upset..........

Originally Posted by ***1074;***1086;***1083;***1082; (Post 1744266)

With h.sie and stiebler working on sh3, sh3 will still be the choice for "reality" followers and for me. But it is really sad that there is no GWX for sh4, it may be a better engine, with better possibilities.

Originally Posted by Myxale (Post 1744275)

Well, I too have my opinion, bus since this isn't a poll I'll refrain from voicing it.
The HAHD team worked hard and if they consider SH4 the better platform for their Mod, so be it.

I own SH4+AddOn, got it to support UBIRO, but never found it appealing beyond the first few hours of 'wow nifty graphics'.

Originally Posted by Hans Witteman (Post 1744636)

And you probably forgot to read one of my recent post because nothing we did for SH3 will be wasted because we will release each part as individuals mod.

Originally Posted by Hans Witteman (Post 1744636)

For the color scheme of the Atlantic i can do whatever i want and with SH4 shaders i can even write my own shader so this is minor to do for me.

Originally Posted by Old_Jakub (Post 1744666)

Hi Hans,

I had in mind that your current work could be moved painlessly to SH4, or will you have to do everything for SH4 from the beginning?



Nice :up:


Regards :salute:

Originally Posted by Schwieger (Post 1744855)

Still prefer SH3 to SH4 here.. by this I'm not referring to gameplay but just the overall feel... if you can get the SH3 feel in SH4... I will be one happy U-boat Kaleun. :Kaleun_Periskop::Kaleun_Salivating: