PDA

View Full Version : War-gaming an extremely unlikely conflict


Wxman
01-01-14, 08:51 PM
War-gaming an extremely unlikely conflict (http://theweek.com/article/index/254400/what-would-a-us-china-war-look-like)
By Eugene K. Chow | 9:15am ET

Imagine this: In the early morning, a barrage of more than 1,000 Chinese ballistic and cruise missiles bombard Taiwanese civilian and military targets.

As the U.S. Air Force stationed in Okinawa prepares to rush to the aid of its sworn ally, Chinese cyber attacks wreak havoc on America's air defense and targeting systems. A second volley of ballistic missiles detonates in space, destroying critical military satellites, while a third rains down on the base, damaging jets and leaving runways unusable.

Meanwhile, a U.S. carrier strike group led by the USS George Washington has launched from Japan and is steaming towards the Taiwan Strait. Without the advanced warning and additional data supplied by satellites, the group's missile defense systems are at a disadvantage against the Chinese "carrier killer" missiles that are streaking towards them. Defense systems do their best, but a few missiles still hit their mark, leaving the USS George Washington's flight deck unusable. America's awesome air and sea power has [become rendered to be a moot point].

Article is excerpted: read more at http://theweek.com/article/index/254400/what-would-a-us-china-war-look-like (http://theweek.com/article/index/254400/what-would-a-us-china-war-look-like)

Wxman
01-01-14, 09:03 PM
I've talked to guys whose Dad's served in Korea.

Their Dad's - and their card-game buddies - always seemed to talk about how the Chinese soldiers would just keep coming.

"we just bayonet'd - gutted - 'em to death with utmost vehmence.

The Chinese didn't seem to flinch (regardless of their losses), they just kept coming over in waves", like the Redcoats did in formation, eh?

Gen. Sherman stated "its a good thing war is fairly unpleasant and mostly uncomfortable to a large number of people, e.g., TV / cable outages could be somewhat inconveniant for a little while to several number of individual groups; otherwise it'd become something we could become much too fond of (lest things become really nasty)."

As long as the Duck Dynasty imbroglio keeps up: who would know? Or who would care?

Wxman
01-01-14, 09:35 PM
There's no doubt the American miltary would win such conflict. After the inevitable riots, life w/ out iPhones, iPads, TVs, computers would go on, would it not?

Life would go on despite somebody trying to translate 150 cases of Reaabok's / 160" flat-panel HD TV into a single pack of feminine hygeine product.

How is it that the author left out the fact that the Russians and ChiComs have been staging joint war-excercises since 2005, in preparation for this very scenario?

They're been conducting these excercises every year since about 2010; before that every other year.

Russia, China hold Peace Mission 2009 joint exercise

The exercise involves about 3,000 Russian and Chinese servicemen, nearly 300 units of army military equipment and over 40 fixed-wing aircraft and helicopters.

Excerpt: read more at http://en.ria.ru/photolents/20090724/155604547.html (http://en.ria.ru/photolents/20090724/155604547.html)

Is it in the Chicom / Russian battle-plan to have sufficient stock of feminine hygene napkins / deodarent on hand? For how many hours as such plan is executed is such stock kept on hand? Is such in the Western military command's plans? Which side would suffer the most from lack of such war materiel? W/ out doubt that's all produced domestically; shouldn't be a problem.

Dread Knot
01-02-14, 08:21 AM
Is it in the Chicom / Russian battle-plan to have sufficient stock of feminine hygene napkins / deodarent on hand? For how many hours as such plan is executed is such stock kept on hand? Is such in the Western military command's plans? Which side would suffer the most from lack of such war materiel? W/ out doubt that's all produced domestically; shouldn't be a problem.

I think the alluring premise that one side or another in a conflict will simply collapse on the battlefield or at home because they are soft, luxury-loving, incapable of adapting, or alienated from their government has often proven to be a dangerous case of wishful thinking in historical terms.

To put it another way. If seriously planning for a war I wouldn't really pay much heed to what effect a tampon shortage or a regular TV broadcast interruption will have on the enemy. There are too many far more important things. (like the decision to go to war in the first place)