Log in

View Full Version : 1943 and the growing sense of doom


GoldenRivet
04-09-13, 11:38 AM
the ongoing saga of U-93 continues as control of the boat is relinquished to a new commander on his first war patrol.

It seems there are few things out in the Atlantic except erratic radar signals and thousands of allied patrol planes.

During the Biscay crossing we must have submerged a dozen times to evade incoming aircraft.

On the 17th radar signals forced us to dive approximately 150 nautical miles west of Casablanca, upon reaching 40 meters depth numerous sound contacts were tracked for about an hour and a rough Easterly direction of travel was determined. We surfaced and moved to intercept what was believed to be a task force but was later observed to be a convoy of merchants - mostly large tankers and troop ships under heavy escort of at least 5 destroyers of varying types under American banners.

The intercept which took place just before sunrise did not place me in the best position, but with allied radar being a consideration, the longer range shot was probably a more tactically sound decision anyway.

3 observations were made for speed calculation, and finally a spread of 2 torpedoes was sent toward the large tanker steaming in the center column, immediately astern of him was another large tanker which also received a spread of 2.

The periscope was immediately lowered, a heading of 270 and a depth of 140 meters was ordered.

All four torpedoes were heard to impact and explode, within minutes these sounds were followed by numerous secondary explosions and sinking sounds. The escorts promptly responded.

The sea state was moderate and this may have contributed to poor listening conditions for their ASDIC gear because several pings were heard, but the escorts focused on an area of sea well astern of our position.

The westerly course was continued toward the Canary Islands and i chose not to continue harassment of the convoy as the next point of intercept would have been dangerously close to the Straight of Gibraltar. Allied air cover, and surface patrol craft would have easily persecuted the u-boat in this area if the attack was poorly executed or the boat discovered by radar or aircraft etc.

On March 21st just north of the Canary islands radar signals again forced us to dive as a precautionary measure, the weather which had been very poor for the past several days had started to improve and the sea state was now calm. Sound contact as made with 1 warship and 3 merchant vessels.

Again an approximate course was determined and an intercept made.

We attacked around 0300 from point blank range sinking a small merchant and a liberty ship.

Over the next 4 hours, the lone escort depth charged U-93 with a high degree of accuracy. Our initial depth of 140 meters had to be pushed to 160, then 180, then 220 and finally 230 meters. I dared not dive deeper.

The boat was obviously under heavy strain, several bold decoys were used at each depth however the escort never seemed to respond to these. accurate persecution of ASW attacks against U-93 continued until (it is assumed) that the escort exhausted its supply of depth charges and made a rush back toward the last remaining merchant of the small convoy.

The overwhelming sense was that if this particular destroyer had any help, it would have been over for U-93. The destroyer pressing the attack seemed to be clearly aware of the approximate position and depth of the boat almost constantly with a very small margin of error.

U93 employed the tactic of course changes of approximately 40 degrees during the depth charge run at flank speed. Once the escort was acquired from our baffles we would turn the boat so as to present the smallest profile possible and quickly drop to 50 rpm, generally pointing our stern directly at the attacker. Usually there was anywhere of up to a minute of silence following a depth charge barrage. The silence in any case was always broken by ASDIC pings and the tracking of the destroyer closing on our position at high speed.

Eventually however as is stated above, the escort broke off her attack and headed north at high speed.

be careful out there folks :03:

By March - May of 1943, the allies have made a science of killing u-boats. make sure and strike from long range whenever possible, i have found that it is best to disable your target ships near the maximum range of your torpedoes, then dive deep and away. later you can then pick off the wounded stragglers as the convoy (and obviously the escorts) sail on without them.

I am bound and determined to see that U-93 survives this mess!

RustySubmarine
04-09-13, 12:08 PM
Still at the end of 1940 on my fifth patrol out of Lorient. almost got sunk in the Irish Sea on my way back from my last patrol, after sinking three large Merchants in a convoy. I returned to Lorient with 10% Hull vunrability, six of my crew dead and my attack periscope and deck gun destroyed after heavy depth charging. It was a miracle I survived at all. So I aint looking forward to 1943, if I make it that far.

bertieck476
04-09-13, 12:46 PM
I have not got that far yet with gwx, but even in stock sh3 when you get to your stage of the war it gets so hard to stay alive, I fully understand your "growing sense of doom"

Bert.

Vince82
04-09-13, 01:46 PM
Nice report, must have been a 30.000 GRT patrol.

With a calm sea state I sometimes experience exactly the same, they are good at finding you and once they do you can't loose them. Ofcourse it all depends on how you have your SHIII files tweaked, but it is probably pretty realistic. Bold decoy does work for me, tho. But than after 5 minutes they find me again.

I use GWX and I've the Hsie patch if you're using that aswell you should be able to destract them. Could be that some DE's are just too good and cant be fooled.

flag4
04-09-13, 03:17 PM
solid report - good luck, keep up the good work:up:

HW3
04-09-13, 04:20 PM
I actually made it to the end of the war once while in the WAW group. That is once out of five tries with that group. It can be done but, it is very hard to do, and you must be very lucky too. My last attempt had me dying in the Caribbean in late 44.

:subsim:

flag4
04-10-13, 05:22 AM
...never made it past '42. But I think this was due to impatience and risk taking.

RustySubmarine
04-10-13, 06:29 AM
...never made it past '42. But I think this was due to impatience and risk taking.

Taking risks can play a big part on survival. I am a bit of a stickler for taking risks. :smug: If my patrol has not brought much luck in sinking a few ships, I tend to venture into an area where I am likely to find something worth risking. The Humber estuary is one of these, but there is always warships on the lookout for any unsuspected activity. Night time encounters are best used to enter harbours, either on surface or submerged if there are chances of being spotted. I usually stay on the surface as long as possible and only submerge if I need to do so. You need to watch out for nets, especially if the channel you are entering is narrow, or you may even encounter mines. Oh yes I have been caught in nets up the Clyde, and getting out of them can be a bit tricky, but you will get damaged. But it's all part of risk taking I suppose, otherwise play it cool and don't take chances, if you want to survive longer, but you wont get any medals, if you don't get your tonnage score up. :salute:

flag4
04-10-13, 09:46 AM
Taking risks can play a big part on survival. I am a bit of a stickler for taking risks. :smug: If my patrol has not brought much luck in sinking a few ships, I tend to venture into an area where I am likely to find something worth risking. The Humber estuary is one of these, but there is always warships on the lookout for any unsuspected activity. Night time encounters are best used to enter harbours, either on surface or submerged if there are chances of being spotted. I usually stay on the surface as long as possible and only submerge if I need to do so. You need to watch out for nets, especially if the channel you are entering is narrow, or you may even encounter mines. Oh yes I have been caught in nets up the Clyde, and getting out of them can be a bit tricky, but you will get damaged. But it's all part of risk taking I suppose, otherwise play it cool and don't take chances, if you want to survive longer, but you wont get any medals, if you don't get your tonnage score up. :salute:

I agree with you RustySubmarine...but I think my problem sometimes surfaces when impatience and risk taking combine; this I think is a deadly combination. it has caught me out on so many occasions and every time I tell myself, next time I wont let it happen - so, im learning not to rush in in panic mode just to get some tonnage. I keep saying to myself 'crew first - tonnage next time.'
the problem is that its so tempting to take a risk...:hmmm:


by the way, that's a great photo of 534. ive been to see it on a few occasions and think they should never have cut it up the way they did. maybe have been better to cut some large side panels out - coz inside is all rusted to hell anyway. its such a gorgeous shape and we lose all sense of that as it lies there in 3-4 slabs like a sliced up whale.

RustySubmarine
04-10-13, 07:06 PM
Yes it's a bloody shame they had to cut up U534. I watched it being lifted off the barge, when it first arrived at Birkenhead and lowered onto the jetty. I've been aboard her quite a few times whilst she was at the H S Museum, as a mate of mine was one of the volunteers who worked there. It was a sad day when the museum had to close and the fate of U534 was left in the balance, as to what would happen to it. The rest of the ships, found new homes, but U534 was too big to move and fears that it might have to be scrapped was on the cards. Luckily she was eventually saved, but had to be cut into sections, so that it could be moved to its new resting place at the new Nautical Museum near the Ferry. But at least it has been saved and although maybe not a complete one piece boat, you can still visit it today.

Wulfmann
04-12-13, 03:26 PM
I have only once completed a GWX start to finish career.

I almost finished another but was sunk in early 45 taking a risk i should not have.

The one I completed I simply left the NA in the Spring of 43 buying a IXC and moving to the SA. After mid 44 I bought a VIIC and moved to Norway. I never went into the NA after 43 at all.

In late 44 and 45 I attacked Russian convoys and from long range turning and diving deep long before any possible torpedo impacts.

To be honest I eventually succumbed to shell shot and now have trouble attacking in 1940.
I used to sit for hours glued to the sonar maneuvering to avoid depth charges but now feel like I can no longer handle the stress
It is funny to admit you have post traumatic Stress from a sub sim but that is what happen to me.

I have completed one 1943 start and one 1944 start which helped and have two careers going but again, do not have the nerve I used to have.

When i completed an entire war career in GWX I kind of was expecting general O'Neil to stop by and beam me up to his ship and send my to the Destiny but alas, nothing

Wulfmann