PDA

View Full Version : Can someone lend us a sub???


bookworm_020
01-25-10, 04:38 PM
Out of six subs that the Australian Navy has, only one is fit for sea!:damn:

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/nation/navys-collins-class-fleet-reduced-to-one-working-submarine/story-e6frg6nf-1225823451926

ETR3(SS)
01-25-10, 05:38 PM
Wow that sucks. That really is another blow to your guys sub service. Maybe we could sell you a couple S-Boats or even a Gato for the time being. :haha:

Bethune
01-25-10, 05:43 PM
be glad youre country even has a sub that works :D

but yeah, that blows 1 out of 6 working, money problems?

bookworm_020
01-26-10, 01:37 AM
be glad youre country even has a sub that works :D

but yeah, that blows 1 out of 6 working, money problems?

No, more engineering and crew problems, than money. Even if they all worked, there isn't enough crew for all of them.

krashkart
01-26-10, 01:55 AM
Hrm.... :hmmm:

It seems to me that submarines are a very expensive defense asset. Wonder how the US will fare, given our current financial obligations to China.... :yeah:

*my thanks in advance to all [poorly trained] business people working for America's greatest financial institutions* :nope:

JSLTIGER
01-26-10, 09:30 AM
What's the matter? Run out of chewing gum to keep the water out? Sorry, I kid...

Weiss Pinguin
01-26-10, 09:45 AM
No, more engineering and crew problems, than money. Even if they all worked, there isn't enough crew for all of them.
Huh, I was under the impression that Australia's navy was decently well off in the submarine department. :hmmm: Guess I was a bit off the mark... 1 out of 6 is pretty appalling. :o

Thunder
01-26-10, 09:45 AM
You can have two of our , we're only using one...

We got the same $%$%^&:dead:

http://www.da.org.za/newsroom.htm?action=view-news-item&id=5849

Highlights:
The Navy has denied the allegations that they are unable to properly operate the submarines purchased as part of the R49bn arms procurement package. They insist that the submarines are not duds, that the SA Manthatisi is in dry dock as part of "normal naval procedure" and that it was normal naval procedure to rotate submarines.

the use of the four frigates we already have in our possession has been compromised by continuous skills and personnel shortages and they still need to undergo a substantial technical upgrade before they have the required land-attack and anti-submarine capabilities.

problem is not just limited to the Navy. For example, in the Air Force, there are only two Gripen aircraft in South Africa and none are yet operational, leaving South Africa without fighter capacity to defend our airspaces as the older Cheetahs have been decommissioned.

In addition, we do not have the pilots and navigators to man the aircraft.

kiwi_2005
01-26-10, 01:37 PM
I wouldn't feel too bad bookworm, NZ has none! :har: :nope:

Jimbuna
01-26-10, 05:12 PM
We have a one going spare in Merseyside but you'll need a few skilled welders :DL

krashkart
01-27-10, 12:53 AM
You can have two of our , we're only using one...

We got the same $%$%^&:dead:

http://www.da.org.za/newsroom.htm?action=view-news-item&id=5849

Highlights:
The Navy has denied the allegations that they are unable to properly operate the submarines purchased as part of the R49bn arms procurement package. They insist that the submarines are not duds, that the SA Manthatisi is in dry dock as part of "normal naval procedure" and that it was normal naval procedure to rotate submarines.

the use of the four frigates we already have in our possession has been compromised by continuous skills and personnel shortages and they still need to undergo a substantial technical upgrade before they have the required land-attack and anti-submarine capabilities.

problem is not just limited to the Navy. For example, in the Air Force, there are only two Gripen aircraft in South Africa and none are yet operational, leaving South Africa without fighter capacity to defend our airspaces as the older Cheetahs have been decommissioned.

In addition, we do not have the pilots and navigators to man the aircraft.

Ow, brings a tear to my eye to hear of that. :-? On the other hand, you do have Gripen fighters. Stateside we just have all the usual boring stuff. lol

bookworm_020
01-28-10, 02:58 AM
I wouldn't feel too bad bookworm, NZ has none! :har: :nope:

Submarines, Fighters or a defense force?:O:

Jimbuna
01-29-10, 05:21 PM
Submarines, Fighters or a defense force?:O:

Oh that was mean :DL

IIRC NZ were the first of the Commonwealth countries to offer us help (a loan of weaponry/platforms for home defence) during the Falklands campaign :hmmm:

bookworm_020
01-31-10, 03:01 AM
Oh that was mean :DL

I couldn't resist knocking a sitting kiwi of his perch!:DL

Jimbuna
01-31-10, 09:01 AM
I couldn't resist knocking a sitting kiwi of his perch!:DL

Like a clay pigeon I suppose :DL

bookworm_020
01-31-10, 10:56 PM
Like a clay pigeon I suppose :DL

And as any aussie will tell you, it's always open season!:D

Highbury
02-01-10, 01:45 AM
Although I make my home in the US most of the year I am from Canada.. we only have 4 as well. 70's/80's vintage ex-Upholder Class subs, now called Victoria Class.

One is operational, two were expected to be in service by late '09 but I haven't heard anything and the fourth is still undergoing a major overhaul after a fire happened onboard on the way back to Canada after receiving the ship in the UK. One sailor died (Lt(N) Chris Saunders) and the boat had to be sealifted back to Canada on a Norwegian ship. It is expected to re-enter service in 2012.

Jimbuna
02-01-10, 05:06 PM
Although I make my home in the US most of the year I am from Canada.. we only have 4 as well. 70's/80's vintage ex-Upholder Class subs, now called Victoria Class.

One is operational, two were expected to be in service by late '09 but I haven't heard anything and the fourth is still undergoing a major overhaul after a fire happened onboard on the way back to Canada after receiving the ship in the UK. One sailor died (Lt(N) Chris Saunders) and the boat had to be sealifted back to Canada on a Norwegian ship. It is expected to re-enter service in 2012.

Yes I remember that...a terrible tragedy :nope:

TLAM Strike
02-04-10, 02:41 PM
Maybe you folks down under should have bought a couple of Kilos! I mean even Iran is able to keep atleast one of those operational!

bookworm_020
02-05-10, 08:49 PM
Although I make my home in the US most of the year I am from Canada.. we only have 4 as well. 70's/80's vintage ex-Upholder Class subs, now called Victoria Class.

One is operational, two were expected to be in service by late '09 but I haven't heard anything and the fourth is still undergoing a major overhaul after a fire happened onboard on the way back to Canada after receiving the ship in the UK. One sailor died (Lt(N) Chris Saunders) and the boat had to be sealifted back to Canada on a Norwegian ship. It is expected to re-enter service in 2012.

Australia did look at buying the Upholder subs, as well as a modified version. The RAN went with the collins class instead