Log in

View Full Version : Pesky Frigate Meets His End


Commander Gizmo
09-12-09, 08:17 PM
I was chasing a convoy earlier and ended up having to take on most of the escorts, sinking each one as the need occurred. That's not as easy as it used to be in GWX3.0 it seems. Anyway, I was down to a flower class tailing the convoy to one side and a black swan class leading at the front.

I decided to have a little fun since I am a pretty good shot with the deck gun, even in GWX. So I slipped in behind the convoy and surfaced about 6500 meters behind the flower and sighted him in. After firing for a while and getting plenty in return huge plumes of smoke were coming up. I continued my barrage laughing at their captain's vain attempts to hit something with his green crew. A few shells later and it exploded quite nicely and my crew and I started to celebrate.

At just that moment the frigate decided to show up all guns blazing. Having an apparently more seasoned crew, they actually landed a shell in the forward compartment. After ordering a crash dive, I spend some time evading and hiding before slinking back towards the convoy. You see, I had a plan. While the frigate searched in circles I moved back the direction he would have to travel to return the convoy. I was figuring that if I could catch him heading in a straight line back I would have the whole convoy to myself.

For once it worked and I managed to line up the shot. The torpedo slid under the keel quite nicely and exploded just as I had planned. However, that's where things turned for the worst. Although I had manged to destroy the engine compartment and bring it to a stop, the crew apparently had no intention of abandoning ship. There they sat on the deck manning the guns while their crew mates were undoubtedly pumping all that water back out of the hull. It simply wouldn't sink.

I really needed him gone because a convoy moving at 4 knots will take forever to get out of gun range. However, I discovered another problem. By this time, I was out of my main stock of torpedoes in my IXB and didn't have time to get the ones off the deck for the job. So after sighing and figuring I would just have to move my torpedoes while I wait for the convoy to get out of gun range a thought suddenly occurred to me. Something so dastardly it just might work.

I carefully maneuvered my uboat in next to the frigate so that I could only see his hull in my scope. After coasting to a complete stop, I have the order to surface. No, I wasn't going to board her -- though I could have used some fresh food at that point in my patrol. I ordered the men to the deck and flak guns. "I want their deck guns taken out first!" I ordered. A few shots rang out and the frigate's main guns were flying through the air with some very satisfying explosions beneath them.

It was only then that I suddenly gave thought to the amount of ammunition that would shortly be exploding a few yards from my boat. "CRASH DIVE!!!" As the frigate started to rip itself to shreds, we were just starting to dip under the waves. We took some heavy damage on the conning tower and flak guns, but we made it down and survived to devastate the rest of the convoy.

Thank goodness there wasn't an s-class there. I sank a South Hampton, three Black Swan, a Town, two KF, and a flower in that one convoy; but I've never sank an S-Class. Can it even be done? I blew their deck and flak guns off the boat once and then pulled up along side and put all my shells into their hull and they didn't even flinch. I couldn't even see damage marks on their hull. I think I need one of those!

SteveW1
09-12-09, 08:27 PM
S Class's can be sunk, I put 2 Fish into one last night took a while for it to go down but it eventually slipped under.

Steve

Damo
09-12-09, 08:41 PM
Aiming for the hull and the guns will lead to a very slow demise of any ship. You want to be aiming below the water line so you get a splash first then an explosion as the shell hits to ensure that she starts flooding. Aiming at one spot will cause more damage to one section too, reducing the chances of the flooding to be brought under control.

Personally I don't like deckgunning navy ships, especially in GWX but if I have to, I try and get myself head on so I present the smallest target for them. Normally when you get a couple of hits they start to zig zag leaving their sides vulnerable but this should only be done from long range. If they get within 2500m I crash dive and set myself up for another go at range. This is a pure desperation 'gotta kill em' strategy though and not one I'd adopt in a D.I.D. career. There it's all about saving my men and my boat with the opportunity to go back out and get em next time.

I still prefer the stern shot under the keel on chasing destroyers at 350m, gets me grinning every time. I'll not be a happy bunny when those hedgehogs appear.

:arrgh!:

Commander Gizmo
09-12-09, 10:26 PM
I kinda figured that almost any hit on a sub is below the water line, but yea I aleays aim to flood if I'm not trying to remove some of their equipment. The S class I mentioned was foaming bubbles from their hull for 5 hours and never sank. Shouldn't their hulls be as weak as ours?

They tried to hit me but couldn't aim their guns low enough. I know GWX is suppost to be anti-deck gun, but I can take a frigate that is dead in the water at 7000-8000km with minimal casualties. This one hit me at 6km though, so I didn't want to take them on at range.

Mopy
09-12-09, 11:05 PM
:doh: How do you do that? I've seen several convoys in mid '40 with a single escort and calm weather, itching to sink it and take down the rest of the convoy with the deck gun. I have never once managed. It just changes direction and speed way too often to get into a good firing position.

Grats on taking out the 1.. 2.. 3... 8! Escorts though.

/jealous :sunny:

Commander Gizmo
09-13-09, 12:26 AM
Shadowing a convoy is a lot of work. This one was running at 4 knots, which is why it worked out so well. You have to do quite a bit of calculating to end up at the right intersection point to begin with after you get the report of a convoy or otherwise spot them. They slow down quite a bit when zig zagging after you first strike.

I often try to bait patrols that are too agressive to ignoe so that they end up in the right firing posistion. I also have lots of close calls with depth charges. I've learned a few tricks with the IXB that I couldn't do in the VII. That extra little bit of power comes in handy.

If you run just out of visual range (before radar) and dip under every so often and take a manual listen on the hydrophones you can stalk them until your fuel runs out. Be sure to watch for the lateral patrols as they often swing out quickly to see if anyone is there. They're really sneaky sometimes. Early in the war most navy crews are in experienced and lousy gunners.

Damo
09-13-09, 01:26 AM
Early war I like to get ahead of the convoy and then turn head on, going as deep as I can on silent running until the lead escort passes overhead. Then I go to ahead one third and come up to peri depth making a 90 degree turn. I normally come up mid convoy where the juicier targets are and with the forward tubes I fire on the furthest ship making note of the approx time to impact then I line up both fore and aft closer targets and time my second forward salvo and my aft salvo so they hit roughly the same time as the first shot. I don't wait around to watch the fireworks but turn back to the convoys course and go deep and 2 knots while I reload. I find that the escorts have a hard time finding me and if they do they have to negotiate a path through the columns of ships. Then it's a case of popping up and getting off a few more torps when I can before going deep and silent and head back towards the rear of the convoy.

Most of the time the escorts lose me quick (if they indeed find me in the first place), and go back to their buddies. Normally I can be sure that a damaged straggler will be left behind for me to take some deck gun potshots at and then I can follow the convoy out of sight while I load the external torps for a few 180degree AOB magnetic shots if it's calm enough or just cruise ahead and repeat the first steps. If there's only one escort though I'll focus on taking that out first so I can pick my targets at leisure and empty the ammo store.

I once stumbled across a large convoy in the channel with one escort and a Revenge BB in the middle. I actually lined up out to the side and stuck 2 torps into the BB killing it's engines which got left behind and then took out the escort. After a major turkey shoot which left me with just my external torps and no deckgun rounds I went back to the BB which was listing heavily and stuck another torp under the forward guns. She went up like the 4th of July, it was awesome.

Total patrol tonnage was 108000t. Loads of Auxilary cruisers and Large Merchants ended up as channel shipping hazards that day. Didn't even get a third of the way to my patrol grid either. Happy days.

:yeah:

Iranon
09-13-09, 07:03 AM
Shame that enemy warships have no qualms about sinking the vessels they are supposed to protect. Otherwise picking off the merchants after the lone remaining warship is dead int he water would be easier... simply surface on the far side of a merchant and tear it to shreds at close range.

Brag
09-13-09, 08:16 AM
From BDU to Gizmo.

Next time be more agressive :sunny:

Patkins1983
09-13-09, 04:38 PM
Came across a convoy on my last patrol which had HMS Rodney sitting at the back. (my 5th patrol in my VII)
I put two eels into her but she just slowed down and fell back.
I wouldnt normally take a suicidal risk but decided to try down her with my 88mm.

I decided that a range of 8500m would be enough so I surfaced in the dark and got ready for some fun. After a good 10 rounds on to Rodney she fired back.

Im decided to dive to get out of the way, sadly I took a few shells. I had no flak gun, periscopes or radio and some flooding.

A quick peek on the external view showed Rodney with only 1 working gun so I popped back up and started to put a few more shells into her.
Luckily I got the down in time for Rodneys next attack and got the shes going down message.

Sadly at the time I had no eels left , I might not have taken the risk otherwise.

I had the fortune of sinking my first S type on my 4th patrol, she had sat on the surface after repeated attacks on the convoy she was in. Easiest kill ever:) I love GWX

Damo
09-13-09, 06:53 PM
I got my first Type S when I sneaked (or is it 'snuck') into Lerwick in early 1940. It was real bad weather with vis down to 400m and pouring down. She was sitting there beside an Auxiliary cruiser so the two overlapped from my viewpoint. Set 2 TII's on salvo with a 4 degree spread an let em go. By the time they hit I couldn't see as I was already making my way out but I saw a lot of flame accompanied by two she's going down messages pretty much instantly. I was quite happy to have sunk a sub.

My second encounter was leaving Lorient early 1941 and cruising on the surface as I left land behind. Got a submarine spotted and didn't think much of it this close to German territory so kept TC up and then I heard shells whizzing past the boat, got on deck to see a rather audacious Type S weaving towards me, guns blazing. I fired off a contact report and dived and swung in to get her perpendicular to fire a torp. I got one off but she was going at around 9/10 knots and zig zagging hard. I got a hit but right at the rearmost section so I waited and watched her weave away hoping for a slow sink but she didn't even slow down. I was about to give chase when the Luftwaffe turn up in HE-111's and start pounding it so I let it be and resumed my mission. I don't know if she ever went down, I guess I failed my responsibilities there, but as the Luftwaffe had her sighted I doubt she got far.