PDA

View Full Version : Food- will it run out?


Siara
10-29-08, 11:40 AM
Its february 1942 around straights of Gibraltar, and the contacts have run dry.
There have been few cons, but all neutral. I managed to sink Granville freighter, and medium cargo, but other than that- its just quiet.
I still have more than half a tank o juice, but its been more than 3 months since i left the cosy port of St Nazaire, and i have doubts about the food.
I know it is not scripted ingame, but shouldnt i be on the way back by now?
:hmm: It would be nice to have that option in SH3 perhaps?

Is it possible to make such mod?

Jimbuna
10-29-08, 11:44 AM
Nope....just bear in mind what a realistic patrol length was and use your judgement to decide when your going to return.

I'm suprised you've still got eels left after 3 months ingame.

Your not hiding outside the pier in your home port are you? :lol:

Siara
10-29-08, 11:53 AM
Ive only wasted 4 torps so far- 2 on each ship. Honestly, the waether was so bad for most part of my mission, and now its improved sufficiently to get the decent shot- theres nothing to shoot at. Few neutral, lightly escorted convoys went past, but no English ships at all. I had aircraft attack few weeks back / i lost the man on the gun- stupidly thinking i can take him on :-? /, maybe the ships have been allerted to my presence in the area.:hmm:

meduza
10-29-08, 12:10 PM
THat's strange. I always had a good catch around Gibraltar, single ships and convoys. I patroled the area throughout 1941, on east and west of Gibraltar. :arrgh!: Maybe you should go through the Strait and see what's on the other side...

Regarding the patrol length, I've never been out there more than two months, maybe two and a half. Not because I wanted to keep realistic patrol length, but because I was either out of eels or low on fuel.

Jimbuna
10-29-08, 01:25 PM
Go 250km west of Gib 30km south of the mid channel point.....and fill yer boots http://www.psionguild.org/forums/images/smilies/wolfsmilies/pirate.gif

Siara
10-29-08, 02:00 PM
Go 250km west of Gib 30km south of the mid channel point.....and fill yer boots http://www.psionguild.org/forums/images/smilies/wolfsmilies/pirate.gif

Jimbuna- i know where to find them.:up:
I have been hunting them here for the last 10 patrols. Nearly 400 000t sunk so far.
Question was- is it possible to have food mod- something similar to diesel gauge- the longer you at sea, the shorter the food bar.
I dont know- thats why im asking. If not possible- shame, thats something i like to see in the game, and i think it would add more realism to it. Im not one of the tonnage freaks, and i plan my attacks carefully- survivability being the priority. I dont mind hunting for suitable targets for months.:yep:

Commander Gizmo
10-29-08, 02:02 PM
Perhaps that could be added as part of the health mod? When the food runs out, the crew's health and moral could start to drop rapidly.

B.N.R.T.
10-29-08, 02:29 PM
How much food was there on a U-boat? How long could they stretch it?

badwolf
10-29-08, 03:48 PM
Perhaps that could be added as part of the health mod? When the food runs out, the crew's health and moral could start to drop rapidly.

Already been done.

Jimbuna
10-29-08, 05:08 PM
Go 250km west of Gib 30km south of the mid channel point.....and fill yer boots http://www.psionguild.org/forums/images/smilies/wolfsmilies/pirate.gif

Jimbuna- i know where to find them.:up:
I have been hunting them here for the last 10 patrols. Nearly 400 000t sunk so far.
Question was- is it possible to have food mod- something similar to diesel gauge- the longer you at sea, the shorter the food bar.
I dont know- thats why im asking. If not possible- shame, thats something i like to see in the game, and i think it would add more realism to it. Im not one of the tonnage freaks, and i plan my attacks carefully- survivability being the priority. I dont mind hunting for suitable targets for months.:yep:

No prob matey...I refer you to my answer @ #2 'nope'....not as far as I am aware.

But a workaround may be done by linking it to the fatigue option you are using.

Siara
10-29-08, 05:12 PM
Im using GWX + 8 hour fatigue option, but even with it enabled one can stay on patrol for as long as one likes.

Schöneboom
10-29-08, 08:06 PM
Ciao Siara,

I don't know about making a mod, but you as Kaleun have other options besides watering down the gruel. If you're within range of a supply ship (Versorgungsschiff), they'll give you food as well as fuel.

Six weeks was a typical patrol length. With a resupply at sea, you could stay out for three months without austerity measures. In the case of the Monsun U-boats, they resupplied twice at sea to get to Penang (that was the plan at least, until the Allies started sinking supply ships).

Alternatively (& this probably did not happen in RL), you could visit a friendly port, or a neutral one if you're careful, and go shopping!

"Kriegsmarinekarte -- don't leave port without it."

BasilY
10-29-08, 10:55 PM
I think in real life the longest patrol is 100 days +. So you are pushing the envelop. I had one myself (almost 4 months) But I think in a real patrol, the sanity of your crew will probably be out lasted by your food.

Graf Paper
10-29-08, 11:23 PM
After two months at sea with no bathing and only one toilet, I'd probably end up shooting a few of my own men. :doh:

Siara
10-30-08, 03:11 AM
How about this:

"Kplt. Lüth managed to sink ten ships (amassing 45,331 tons) during this long and difficult patrol. This patrol lasted an amazing 205 days at sea! This was the second longest patrol of the war, second only to Korvettenkapitän Eitel-Friedrich Kentrat (http://www.everything2.org/title/Eitel-Friedrich%2520Kentrat)s patrol of 225 days with the crew of U-196 (http://www.everything2.org/title/U-196)."

:hmm:

Sailor Steve
10-30-08, 12:01 PM
On the other hand, those accounts don't mention any details. Like the accounts of Lothar von Arnauld de la Periere's famous First World War patrol, in which he sank 54 ships for 91,150 tons using only four torpedoes, they almost never mention that he used more than 900 shells from his deck gun, or about eight times as many as the boat could carry. Since he had to go into a port to reload the shells, does that really count as one patrol?

Likewise Lüth and Kentrats: did they spend that many days at sea, without ever restocking their food supplies? I don't claim they didn't, only that the accounts leave something to be desired.

Most patrols lasted less than 100 days, and since food never seems to be mentioned in the accounts I think it's safe to assume that it wasn't a problem.

Jimbuna
10-31-08, 07:33 AM
Purely out of curiosity........Wasn't there documentation (in the early days of the conflict) of merchants being boarded prior to sinking and foodstuffs being taken off :hmm:

Hanomag
10-31-08, 08:20 AM
I'm suprised you've still got eels left after 3 months ingame.

Your not hiding outside the pier in your home port are you? :lol:

LMAO :rotfl:

Or maybe the merhcants are so small that they steam right passed at 500 m with no notice. Their teeny weeny props barely registering on the hydrophones.

By god... I demand the electron microscopic periscope option mod for GWX 3.0!!! :ping:

Havokflight
10-31-08, 09:38 AM
The worlds submariner community has always been on the cutting edge of technology, looking at ways to get more out of less.

The german service made powdered milk better, found better ways of drying foods, and the german navy perfected a concoction that later with more development became the hugely popular hand sanitizer.

However sailors carried and used large volumes of very potent cologne and perfumes. Foods typically "turned", fruits and vegitabes had to be used within a week or two or they spoiled. The boats became known as "Pig Boats" for good reason.

Kapt Z
11-01-08, 11:23 AM
Purely out of curiosity........Wasn't there documentation (in the early days of the conflict) of merchants being boarded prior to sinking and foodstuffs being taken off :hmm:

Yes!

I remember a book about numerous u-boat mens' adventures. Each chapter was from a different man's experience. From plain seamen to ace kaleuns.

One chapter was about a u-boat early in the war who had stopped a cargo ship and sent over a boat for fresh bread and other foodstuffs. They thought they were safe from aircraft attack, but a aircraft did show up and started bombing them. Several u-boat men were still on the ship and the u-boat dived to evade with the ship's lifeboat still tied to her wintergarden! Then the attacking bomber tried too hard to score a hit on the submerged sub and he crashed into the sea. The u-boat surfaced, picked up her missing crew, a gravely wounded British pilot and then sunk the merchant ship.

Quite a tale.

Jimbuna
11-01-08, 05:28 PM
Purely out of curiosity........Wasn't there documentation (in the early days of the conflict) of merchants being boarded prior to sinking and foodstuffs being taken off :hmm:

Yes!

I remember a book about numerous u-boat mens' adventures. Each chapter was from a different man's experience. From plain seamen to ace kaleuns.

One chapter was about a u-boat early in the war who had stopped a cargo ship and sent over a boat for fresh bread and other foodstuffs. They thought they were safe from aircraft attack, but a aircraft did show up and started bombing them. Several u-boat men were still on the ship and the u-boat dived to evade with the ship's lifeboat still tied to her wintergarden! Then the attacking bomber tried too hard to score a hit on the submerged sub and he crashed into the sea. The u-boat surfaced, picked up her missing crew, a gravely wounded British pilot and then sunk the merchant ship.

Quite a tale.

Rgr that http://www.psionguild.org/forums/images/smilies/wolfsmilies/thumbsup.gif