gramaphone - Silent Running

[dean_acheson]

If you leave the gramaphone on while silent running, do the British hear it?

[_Seth_]

Hi mate! I dont think so.....

[Jimbuna]

Not as far as I'm aware :nope:

[Corsair]

If some of you have seen "Duel in the Atlantic" with Robert Mitchum and Kurt Jürgens, you should know they do...;)

[Hakahura]

I find that Marlien Dietrict lulls the brits into a dream like state allowing me to escape! :rotfl:

[Jimbuna]

If some of you have seen "Duel in the Atlantic" with Robert Mitchum and Kurt Jürgens, you should know they do...;)

Also known as 'The Enemy Below'...Yeah I saw that too...but I think the original question was asking if it could be heard in SH3 not real life...and the answer as far as I am aware is 'No' :hmm:

[Corsair]

If some of you have seen "Duel in the Atlantic" with Robert Mitchum and Kurt Jürgens, you should know they do...;)
Also known as 'The Enemy Below'...Yeah I saw that too...but I think the original question was asking if it could be heard in SH3 not real life...and the answer as far as I am aware is 'No' :hmm:

Thks I figured that out.;) Was just trying to make a little joke:oops:

[Sailor Steve]

Your joke was fine, Corsair, if misunderstood. I'm also pretty sure that it doesn't affect the enemy's ability to hear you. I turn it off anyway, anytime I'm preparing to attack, just because it's what they would really do.

Call me a realism nazi, but there it is.:roll:

[dean_acheson]

I have always turned it off too, but last night, I was listening to some vavaldi on mine, and really didn't want to, on the long silent run in to a convoy, which usually i do on 1x, and therefore it takes for-freaking-ever. ;)

Wondered if anyone else had any ideas.

Thanks guys!

[CptGrayWolf]

If the devs modeled something as detailed as the gramophone bieng detected but din't bother modeling woflpacks...I think would scream :damn:

[_Seth_]

If the devs modeled something as detailed as the gramophone bieng detected but din't bother modeling woflpacks...I think would scream :damn:

:yep: I cant wait to see what they have done with SHIV.....Maybe they made the ice-cream machine work in 3D (with virtual icecream and sound:lol:), so that the japanese destroyers could pin-point the machine's noise and come running.... And since the devs did all that work, there would be no time to make japanese AI subs... (I have to learn some 3D modelling, and start to make the imperial japanese Submarine-fleet before SHIII is released...:nope:)

[CptGrayWolf]

:yep: I cant wait to see what they have done with SHIV.....Maybe they made the ice-cream machine work in 3D (with virtual icecream and sound:lol:), so that the japanese destroyers could pin-point the machine's noise and come running.... And since the devs did all that work, there would be no time to make japanese AI subs... (I have to learn some 3D modelling, and start to make the imperial japanese Submarine-fleet before SHIII is released...:nope:)

:lol: :lol:

[Corsair]

Your joke was fine, Corsair, if misunderstood. I'm also pretty sure that it doesn't affect the enemy's ability to hear you. I turn it off anyway, anytime I'm preparing to attack, just because it's what they would really do.

Call me a realism nazi, but there it is.:roll:
Same here... add me to the club:up: Would sound weird to me to order silent running on a dead stick approach while the Blue Angel is singing out loud "Lili Marlene"...
Although I can understand listening to Vivaldi on a bright nice night on the open sea - have done it often IRL - as well as other musics - but it was on sailing boats and I didn't worry about being detected at the time...;)

[Jimbuna]

If some of you have seen "Duel in the Atlantic" with Robert Mitchum and Kurt Jürgens, you should know they do...;)
Also known as 'The Enemy Below'...Yeah I saw that too...but I think the original question was asking if it could be heard in SH3 not real life...and the answer as far as I am aware is 'No' :hmm:

Thks I figured that out.;) Was just trying to make a little joke:oops:

:up: :up: :up: :up: :up:

[IceGrog]

If you leave the gramaphone on while silent running, do the British hear it?
'The Enemy Below'...Yeah I saw that too.……….me too……….great movie
I remember a long time ago I was reading a book about a submarine, I think maybe the Wahoo not too sure, but in it the sub had just sunk a Japanese warship and as it was sinking the sub’s men could hear the yells of the Japanese’s sailors inside the ship very clear until the ship gave into the pressure of the sea.

[Corsair]

I translated in english the title I knew as I only saw the french and german versions... glad to learn the original title was "The Enemy Below"...