PDA

View Full Version : Sophie Scholl - die Letze Tage review [spoiler warning]


Safe-Keeper
11-15-06, 05:31 PM
I bought and watched this movie yesterday, and it made an even bigger impression on me than Der Untergang (The Downfall), which takes a good deal.

The Final Days details the arrest and subsequent trial and execution of Sophie Scholl, a German activist who turned from devoted Nazism to resistance, spreading anti-Nazi propaganda leaflets for a year with her and her brother's organization, Weisse Rose (White Rose), before her capture by the Gestapo.

The movie starts with Sophie Scholl listening to music with a female friend (girlfriend?), and moves on to the planning of a leaflet drop at the city's university. It goes on to show us the capture of Sophie and her brother, and from there on it's interrogation, despair, trial, and - finally - the execution by guillotine. The movie follows Sophie from beginning to end, meaning that the questions she asks herself - what'll happen to my comrades, my family, what do the Nazis know, have they searched our appartment, have they found anything to use against us - remain unanswered to us for as long as they remain unanswered to them.

The things I remember is how Sophie and her brother so strongly defended their beliefs verbally until the very end; how she said she'd do the same thing again, given the chance; and how the Allies got ahold of one of the leaflets, printed millions of copies, and dropped them by plane over the city of Münich. A brilliant and moving tribute to Sophie Scholl (regardless of whether or not the British intended it to be;)).

The movie had such an impact on me that it's scary, especially the way you know from the beginning that this incredibly brave, friendly young girl is going to be executed in the end. I repeatedly found myself wanting to reach through the monitor screen and hug her. There were scenes where I so loathed the people in the movie that I wanted to go back in time and punch them. This isn't the friendly, Hitler-hating crew of U-96, who spent their time speaking ill of Göring and tormenting the Nazi correspondent - the German officials in The Final Days belong to the evil portion of the German politics-and-war machinery.

I fail to see any wrongs with this movie. It's simply such a splendid master-piece of a film that it'll haunt you for all eternity, along with the memory of a brave, idealistic, and, tragically, reckless young German girl who managed to see the error in her Nazi beliefs and choose the right ideal to pursue. My heart sunk when I saw them make their escape from the university for then to hear Sophie say, "I've still got some leaflets left in my briefcase". If only she hadn't turned back...


In Admiring Memory
of the White Rose Resistance Movement

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/88/Scholl-Denkmal%2C_M%C3%BCnchen.jpg
Photo courtesy of Wikipedia

Skybird
04-12-07, 06:03 PM
I today happened to have seen the movie on DVD, and Safe-Keeper is right - it impressed me much more than "Der Untergang" (which was to be forgotten again by me surprisingly fast). It is very moving, involving, especially in the second half, but never cheap sentimental. What keeps in my memory is the psycho-duel between Sophie and interrogator Mohr - who wants to build her a golden bridge to escape death if only she would admit her belief is wrong - so that his own Nazi view of the world can remain intact and unchallenged by her superior morals.

Also the moment when Sophie gave up lying to passively defend herself when being confronted with overwhelming evidence - and calm, but determined went on some kind of attack and never again gave any ground to Mohr's arguments. Impressive.

And the silent moment at the window of the cell, watching the sun and clouds in the sky.

The scene when the three (brother, sister, a friend) embrace each other in the end short before their executions - I found to be absolutely heart-breaking, without any great gestures or hysteric movie-magic needed to touch the audience.

I do not wish to trigger a debate here, and will stubbornly refuse to participate in such a thing, but I must say that when taking away the Nazi background of the story i consider the meaning of this movie to be very relevant for our present - more than ever before since WW2.

A very humane film, and an agreeable sober production with some very competent actors. The main actress won several film awards for this role.

See it, see it, see it.

http://www.amazon.com/Sophie-Scholl-Final-Julia-Jentsch/dp/B000H5V8H2/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/103-4729363-1543863?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1176418893&sr=8-1

(note that almost all of the 33 reviewers gave it 5 stars)


P.S.
What I was surprised to learn is that von Moltke carried the last leaflet of the Scholls to Norway, where the British mass-duplicated it and unloaded it over German cities. It's new title then was "Ein deutsches Flugblatt".

What the Scholls did - was foolish, but not futile.

Camaero
04-12-07, 06:34 PM
I thought it was a very very good movie. The Germans have been making some damn good WWII movies lately.

jumpy
04-13-07, 03:37 AM
Are we talking subtitles? If so it'll be one I end up watching alone as she doesn't like that kind of thing.
I saw an advertisement for this film not all that long ago. It it out on DVD release in the UK yet? Will have to look for this one at my local hire shop.
Der Untergang was quite compelling, Bruno Gantz (sp?) revealed a fighteningly disturbing side to Hitler; his humanity, which seemed to make (for me) him all the more sinister and not just some demonised figure from history. Seeing him brought back to life, as it were, was very thought provoking.

Possibly the most ugly film I have seen recently was 'Come And See'. It just gets worse and worse as the film progresses, until there's nothing of the original central character left; as he was from the beginning of the film.

Skybird
04-13-07, 04:20 AM
Above amazone link was amazon.com (US) (region code 1, NTSC), this one is in the UK:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Sophie-Scholl-Julia-Jentsch/dp/B000EHPOPU/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/026-3560527-3548442?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&qid=1176454766&sr=8-1

Disk is in German, with subtitles, region code 2, PAL. Again, almost all customers gave it 5 stars.

I had not slept a minute this night. Scenes from the movie on my mind all night long, along with the question of "what if I...". Very uncomfortable, and gruelling. Some movies just cut deeper than others.

Links to the six leaflets at the bottom:
http://www.google.de/imgres?imgurl=http://www.ob.shuttle.de/ob/ssg/sophie.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.ob.shuttle.de/ob/ssg/Biografi.htm&h=392&w=309&sz=18&tbnid=wkVrOdME876KxM:&tbnh=123&tbnw=97&hl=de&start=2&prev=/images%3Fq%3DSophie%2BScholl%26gbv%3D1%26svnum%3D1 0%26hl%3Dde%26safe%3Doff%26sa%3DG

BTW, the actress, Julia Jentsch, has comparable visual resemblance with Sophie Scholl like Bruno Gantz had with Hitler.

Awards and recognition:

Berlin Film Festival, 2005
"Silver Bear: Best Director" - Marc Rothemund
"Silver Bear: Best Actress" - Julia Jentsch

European Film Awards, 2005
"Best European Actress" - Julia Jentsch

German Film Awards ("Lolas")
"Best Actress" - Julia Jentsch
"Audience Award"

German Film Prize, 2005"
Best Film," Silver Prize
"Best acting performance (female main role)" - Julia Jentsch

78th Academy Awards
Nominated for "Best Foreign Language Film"

25th Fajr International Film Festival, 2007
"The Special Jury Award"