KSDCommander

[Warham]

Originally Posted by vdr1981

I'm also going to upload Cpt.Kurtz's save game folder so you can examin it in more details...Is that OK?

Yes upload it please.

Its really not good about salvo.

[vdr1981]

Originally Posted by Warham

Yes upload it please.

Its really not good about salvo.

Yes, on my last patrol for example I shoot 4+1 torpedoes into the convoy but there was only one "Torpedo in the water" event in that particular attack, probably because of fast shooting or something, but...

There were also 4 Torpedo missed and 1 Torpedo Impact! events which is exactly what happen...

I think that if you count all Torpedo Impact! and Torpedo missed you will get pretty much accurate info about spent torpedoes per patrol...
Even with this system some mistakes are possible but much less than with "torpedo in the water" events...
You can then compare this number with actual tonnage and draw some conclusions...KSDCommander can use this dependencies for penalties/awards determination or you can just display it as a additional info for other players, it's up to you...


Also note that Torpedo missed is not always a miss. If target is far away and torpedo eventually hit something after the game declares it as "missed" , you will get credits for kill but appropriate "torpedo impact" message will never be displayed...

I hope that my findings can help you a bit...


O yes, here's Kurtz's gamesave...Feel free to ask something if you have doubts about some files/entries...

http://www.mediafire.com/download/gb.../Cpt.Kurtz.rar

[Cybermat47]

Warham, excellent news! I installed the new version mid-patrol, expecting the new features to start working when I got back to base, but they're working already! 1 torpedo fired, 84% realism - all present and correct!

[Warham]

Just look at it. So, sometimes in the water > impact + missed, but sometimes in the water < impact + missed

The best solution I can see to select the larger of these two values as torpedoes launched counter for statistics:
1) in the water
2) impact + missed

And show this info only for information. No penalties cause this info is not 100% accurate.

Cpt.Kurtz. All Information. 12/3/1941

 

-------------------------------------------------------
Rank - Korwettenkapitan
Awards - Eisernes Kreuz 2. Klasse, U-Boot-Kriegsabzeichen, Eisernes Kreuz 1. Klasse, U-Boot-Kriegsabzeichen mit Brillanten, Ritterkreuz des Eisernen Kreuzes mit Eichenlaub und Schwerter
Commanded - U-33(VIIA), U-47(VIIB), U-69(VIIC)
Current Location - 2ndFlotilla, 6thFlotilla
Home Base - Memel, Kiel, Wilhelmshaven, Lorient, Kiel, StNazaire
Merit - 12670
Torpedoes launched - 101
Torpedoes impact - 53
Torpedoes missed - 47
Sinking tonnage - 381118
Sunk merchant ships - 54
Sunk warships - 5
Aircraft Shot Down - 1
Number of patrols - 20
Total time at sea - 335 days
Died 12/3/1941
-------------------------------------------------------
Difficulty level - 100 %
-------------------------------------------------------
id - 217
-------------------------------------------------------
Mods:
-------------------------------------------------------
1. The Wolves of Steel 1.05
2. The Wolves of Steel 1.05 - Update No. 08
3. The Wolves of Steel 1.05 - Real Navigation_by TheDarkWraith
4. The Wolves of Steel 1.05 - 8x5 Resolution Patch
-------------------------------------------------------
8/31/1939 - The new rank is Oberleutnant zur see.
8/31/1939 - Appointment 2ndFlotilla.
8/31/1939 - Appointment to the base Memel.
8/31/1939 - Appointment commander U-33 type VIIA.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #1.
-------------------------------------------------------
8/31/1939 1:00:00 PM - Out on patrol from the base Memel.
9/2/1939 - Appointment to the base Kiel.
9/1/1939 - Objective achieved Intercept/report the Polish taskforce.
9/1/1939 - Objective achieved Destroy the Polish Taskforce and any other shipping.
9/1/1939 5:58:00 AM - Destroyed V&W Class Destroyer, 1188 tons, Long 19° 05' E, Lat 54° 41' N.
9/1/1939 8:05:00 AM - Destroyed Small Modern Composite Merchant, 1855 tons, Long 18° 58' E, Lat 54° 33' N.
9/5/1939 7:36:57 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Kiel.
Merit - 200.
Torpedoes launched - 3.
Torpedoes impact - 2.
Torpedoes missed - 1.
Sinking tonnage - 3043.
Patrol time - 5 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #2.
-------------------------------------------------------
9/29/1939 5:36:57 PM - Out on patrol from the base Kiel.
10/1/1939 - Appointment to the base Wilhelmshaven.
9/29/1939 9:37:00 PM - Destroyed Hog Island Type A Freighter, 4054 tons, Long 10° 41' E, Lat 54° 37' N.
10/5/1939 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach AN7932 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
10/7/1939 1:28:00 AM - Destroyed Small Modern Composite Merchant, 1998 tons, Long 0° 31' E, Lat 54° 04' N.
10/7/1939 1:34:00 AM - Destroyed Small Passenger Type Merchant, 1742 tons, Long 0° 31' E, Lat 54° 02' N.
10/8/1939 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations at AN5899.
10/11/1939 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations at AN5466.
10/12/1939 6:53:00 AM - Destroyed Cimmaron Class Tanker, 7604 tons, Long 1° 16' W, Lat 56° 33' N.
10/17/1939 7:08:00 PM - Destroyed Hog Island Type A Freighter, 4116 tons, Long 1° 45' W, Lat 58° 12' N.
10/18/1939 5:16:00 AM - Destroyed Rawalpindi Armed Merchant Cruiser, 16965 tons, Long 1° 50' W, Lat 58° 15' N.
10/20/1939 8:17:25 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 950.
Torpedoes launched - 11.
Torpedoes impact - 5.
Torpedoes missed - 3.
Sinking tonnage - 36479.
Patrol time - 21 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
10/20/1939 - The new award is Eisernes Kreuz 2. Klasse.
10/20/1939 - The new award is U-Boot-Kriegsabzeichen.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #3.
-------------------------------------------------------
11/13/1939 3:17:25 AM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
11/15/1939 6:30:00 PM - Destroyed Small SV Tanker, 2821 tons, Long 0° 22' E, Lat 54° 27' N.
11/20/1939 5:07:00 AM - Destroyed Hog Island Type A Freighter, 4091 tons, Long 6° 33' W, Lat 59° 41' N.
11/20/1939 10:44:00 PM - Destroyed Cimmaron Class Tanker, 7603 tons, Long 7° 37' W, Lat 60° 16' N.
11/20/1939 10:57:00 PM - Destroyed Small Old Split Merchant, 2429 tons, Long 7° 38' W, Lat 60° 14' N.
11/21/1939 - Objective achieved Engage any encountered enemy task force in your patrol area.
11/22/1939 4:58:00 PM - Destroyed Small Old Split Merchant, 2428 tons, Long 10° 15' W, Lat 60° 27' N.
11/24/1939 12:15:00 PM - Destroyed Hog Island Type A Freighter, 4188 tons, Long 13° 26' W, Lat 60° 47' N.
12/7/1939 8:53:00 AM - Destroyed Rawalpindi Armed Merchant Cruiser, 16965 tons, Long 5° 59' W, Lat 59° 07' N.
12/11/1939 6:17:49 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 1030.
Torpedoes launched - 7.
Torpedoes impact - 7.
Torpedoes missed - 0.
Sinking tonnage - 40525.
Patrol time - 29 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #4.
-------------------------------------------------------
1/4/1940 12:17:49 PM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
1/7/1940 200 PM - Destroyed Liberty Cargo, 7170 tons, Long 0° 07' W, Lat 58° 30' N.
1/7/1940 200 PM - Destroyed Large Merchant Ship, 7716 tons, Long 0° 07' W, Lat 58° 31' N.
1/7/1940 2:11:00 PM - Destroyed North Sands Type Large Freighter, 7171 tons, Long 0° 07' W, Lat 58° 30' N.
1/7/1940 2:21:00 PM - Destroyed Large Steamer, 7003 tons, Long 0° 07' W, Lat 58° 29' N.
1/9/1940 10:23:36 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 860.
Torpedoes launched - 5.
Torpedoes impact - 4.
Torpedoes missed - 1.
Sinking tonnage - 29060.
Patrol time - 5 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
1/9/1940 - The new award is Eisernes Kreuz 1. Klasse.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #5.
-------------------------------------------------------
2/2/1940 3:23:36 AM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
2/9/1940 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach the area AM3468 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
2/9/1940 8:05:00 AM - Destroyed Rawalpindi Armed Merchant Cruiser, 16965 tons, Long 7° 25' W, Lat 59° 45' N.
2/13/1940 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations at AM5322.
2/16/1940 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations at AM2955.
2/22/1940 2:38:02 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 220.
Torpedoes launched - 4.
Torpedoes impact - 0.
Torpedoes missed - 1.
Sinking tonnage - 16965.
Patrol time - 20 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #6.
-------------------------------------------------------
3/17/1940 5:38:02 PM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
3/19/1940 7:55:00 AM - Destroyed Small Modern Composite Merchant, 1935 tons, Long 1° 31' E, Lat 53° 53' N.
3/19/1940 1100 PM - Destroyed North Sands Type Large Freighter, 7175 tons, Long 0° 53' E, Lat 53° 55' N.
3/20/1940 10:11:00 AM - Destroyed Medium Composite Freighter, 4016 tons, Long 0° 52' E, Lat 55° 02' N.
3/22/1940 7:59:31 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 450.
Torpedoes launched - 7.
Torpedoes impact - 4.
Torpedoes missed - 3.
Sinking tonnage - 13126.
Patrol time - 5 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #7.
-------------------------------------------------------
3/27/1940 5:59:31 PM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
3/30/1940 - Objective achieved Recon Bergen naval base.
4/5/1940 10:26:00 AM - Destroyed Queen Elizabeth Battleship, 31000 tons, Long 13° 32' E, Lat 67° 39' N.
4/9/1940 12:38:00 AM - Destroyed Cimmaron Class Tanker, 7602 tons, Long 13° 33' E, Lat 67° 38' N.
4/9/1940 1:02:00 AM - Destroyed Liberty Cargo, 7172 tons, Long 13° 33' E, Lat 67° 37' N.
4/13/1940 323 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 1550.
Torpedoes launched - 11.
Torpedoes impact - 6.
Torpedoes missed - 5.
Sinking tonnage - 45774.
Patrol time - 17 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
4/13/1940 - The new rank is Kapitanleutnant.
4/13/1940 - The new award is Ritterkreuz des Eisernen Kreuzes.
4/13/1940 - Nominated to the command boat type VIIA.
4/13/1940 - Appointment commander U-47 type VIIB.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #8.
-------------------------------------------------------
5/31/1940 723 AM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
5/31/1940 11:58:47 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base Wilhelmshaven.
Merit - 0.
Torpedoes launched - 0.
Torpedoes impact - 0.
Torpedoes missed - 0.
Sinking tonnage - 0.
Patrol time - 1 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #9.
-------------------------------------------------------
6/15/1940 1:00:00 PM - Out on patrol from the base Wilhelmshaven.
7/1/1940 - Appointment to the base Lorient.
7/11/1940 2:21:00 PM - Destroyed Medium European Composite Freighter, 5404 tons, Long 10° 23' W, Lat 47° 45' N.
7/11/1940 2:38:00 PM - Destroyed North Sands Type Large Freighter, 7178 tons, Long 10° 22' W, Lat 47° 44' N.
7/11/1940 3:11:00 PM - Destroyed Large Steamer, 7026 tons, Long 10° 21' W, Lat 47° 42' N.
7/12/1940 9:26:54 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base Lorient.
Merit - 600.
Torpedoes launched - 12.
Torpedoes impact - 1.
Torpedoes missed - 8.
Sinking tonnage - 19608.
Patrol time - 28 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #10.
-------------------------------------------------------
8/5/1940 5:26:54 PM - Out on patrol from the base Lorient.
8/12/1940 3:53:00 AM - Destroyed Small SV Tanker, 2787 tons, Long 26° 30' W, Lat 49° 29' N.
8/12/1940 3:56:00 AM - Destroyed Large Ore Transport Freighter, 8022 tons, Long 26° 29' W, Lat 49° 28' N.
8/16/1940 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach the area AL5742 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
8/20/1940 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations AK6857.
8/23/1940 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations AL7423.
8/24/1940 11:33:00 PM - Destroyed Landing Ship Tank, 2101 tons, Long 21° 32' W, Lat 47° 48' N.
8/24/1940 11:43:00 PM - Destroyed Ranger Medium Tanker, 3430 tons, Long 21° 32' W, Lat 47° 48' N.
8/24/1940 11:51:00 PM - Destroyed Granville-Type Medium Freighter, 4185 tons, Long 21° 32' W, Lat 47° 47' N.
8/29/1940 1:16:16 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Lorient.
Merit - 1020.
Torpedoes launched - 5.
Torpedoes impact - 2.
Torpedoes missed - 5.
Sinking tonnage - 20525.
Patrol time - 24 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #11.
-------------------------------------------------------
9/28/1940 5:16:16 PM - Out on patrol from the base Lorient.
10/1/1940 11:08:00 PM - Destroyed Landing Ship Tank, 2104 tons, Long 17° 10' W, Lat 46° 46' N.
10/17/1940 400 PM - Destroyed Small Old Split Merchant, 2429 tons, Long 11° 56' W, Lat 36° 11' N.
10/19/1940 10:33:00 AM - Destroyed Medium Composite Freighter, 3982 tons, Long 11° 11' W, Lat 43° 27' N.
10/21/1940 1:44:50 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Lorient.
Merit - 440.
Torpedoes launched - 6.
Torpedoes impact - 1.
Torpedoes missed - 6.
Sinking tonnage - 8515.
Patrol time - 23 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #12.
-------------------------------------------------------
11/20/1940 5:44:50 PM - Out on patrol from the base Lorient.
11/27/1940 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach the area AL5589 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
11/30/1940 2:44:00 PM - Destroyed Large Steamer (War Supplies), 7026 tons, Long 16° 20' W, Lat 54° 55' N.
11/30/1940 2:50:00 PM - Destroyed Large Steamer, 7026 tons, Long 16° 21' W, Lat 54° 57' N.
11/30/1940 2:52:00 PM - Destroyed Cimmaron Class Tanker, 7604 tons, Long 16° 20' W, Lat 54° 56' N.
12/1/1940 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations AL6668.
12/4/1940 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations AL9838.
12/9/1940 12:43:42 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base Lorient.
Merit - 950.
Torpedoes launched - 5.
Torpedoes impact - 3.
Torpedoes missed - 1.
Sinking tonnage - 21656.
Patrol time - 20 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #13.
-------------------------------------------------------
1/8/1941 5:43:42 PM - Out on patrol from the base Lorient.
1/16/1941 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach the area AL8715 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
1/24/1941 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations AK9557.
1/28/1941 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations AL4112.
1/30/1941 3:33:00 PM - Destroyed Swordfish Torpedo Bomber, Long 21° 25' W, Lat 52° 54' N.
1/31/1941 2:18:00 AM - Destroyed Troop Transport, 16965 tons, Long 22° 11' W, Lat 51° 59' N.
2/4/1941 3:35:36 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base Lorient.
Merit - 240.
Torpedoes launched - 4.
Torpedoes impact - 2.
Torpedoes missed - 2.
Sinking tonnage - 16965.
Patrol time - 27 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #14.
-------------------------------------------------------
2/28/1941 5:35:36 PM - Out on patrol from the base Lorient.
2/28/1941 11:58:37 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base Lorient.
Merit - 0.
Torpedoes launched - 0.
Torpedoes impact - 0.
Torpedoes missed - 0.
Sinking tonnage - 0.
Patrol time - 1 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
2/28/1941 - Nominated to the command boat type VIIB.
2/28/1941 - Appointment commander U-69 type VIIC.
3/20/1941 - Appointment 6thFlotilla.
3/20/1941 - Appointment to the base Kiel.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #15.
-------------------------------------------------------
3/20/1941 1:00:00 PM - Out on patrol from the base Kiel.
3/20/1941 - Objective achieved Training Drills.
3/20/1941 3:36:00 PM - Destroyed Coastal Boat, 90 tons, Long 10° 07' E, Lat 54° 57' N.
3/20/1941 - Objective achieved Return To Kiel.
3/20/1941 6:22:49 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base Kiel.
Merit - 20.
Torpedoes launched - 0.
Torpedoes impact - 0.
Torpedoes missed - 0.
Sinking tonnage - 90.
Patrol time - 1 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #16.
-------------------------------------------------------
4/13/1941 5:22:49 PM - Out on patrol from the base Kiel.
4/15/1941 - Appointment to the base StNazaire.
4/23/1941 2:58:00 PM - Destroyed Large Steamer (War Supplies), 7014 tons, Long 24° 29' W, Lat 56° 14' N.
4/23/1941 7:46:00 PM - Destroyed Medium Old Tanker, 4947 tons, Long 24° 30' W, Lat 56° 13' N.
4/24/1941 - Objective achieved Intercept convoy and sink at least 1 ship.
4/24/1941 1:25:00 PM - Destroyed Large Ore Transport Freighter, 8030 tons, Long 21° 32' W, Lat 55° 48' N.
5/1/1941 2:20:00 PM - Destroyed Medium Old Tanker, 4906 tons, Long 16° 49' W, Lat 46° 12' N.
5/4/1941 7:59:34 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base StNazaire.
Merit - 1300.
Torpedoes launched - 5.
Torpedoes impact - 4.
Torpedoes missed - 7.
Sinking tonnage - 24897.
Patrol time - 21 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
5/4/1941 - The new award is Ritterkreuz des Eisernen Kreuzes mit Eichenlaub.
5/4/1941 - The new award is U-Boot-Kriegsabzeichen mit Brillanten.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #17.
-------------------------------------------------------
6/3/1941 5:59:34 PM - Out on patrol from the base StNazaire.
6/13/1941 9:20:00 PM - Destroyed Medium Passanger Ship, 9026 tons, Long 29° 53' W, Lat 19° 13' N.
6/23/1941 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach the area FD1155 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
6/27/1941 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations at FD3255.
7/1/1941 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations at FD5455.
7/15/1941 11:58:41 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base StNazaire.
Merit - 400.
Torpedoes launched - 2.
Torpedoes impact - 2.
Torpedoes missed - 0.
Sinking tonnage - 9026.
Patrol time - 42 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
7/15/1941 - The new rank is Korwettenkapitan.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #18.
-------------------------------------------------------
8/14/1941 5:58:41 PM - Out on patrol from the base StNazaire.
8/24/1941 - Objective achieved Patrol area assigned. Reach the area AK9655 and start operations. Attack any enemy contact.
8/28/1941 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue patrol operations at AK8955.
8/29/1941 3:23:00 PM - Destroyed Troop Transport, 10965 tons, Long 32° 02' W, Lat 53° 49' N.
8/30/1941 9:53:00 AM - Destroyed Granville Type Medium Freighter, 4275 tons, Long 34° 29' W, Lat 52° 54' N.
8/30/1941 1000 AM - Destroyed Small Old Split Freighter (War Supplies), 2719 tons, Long 34° 28' W, Lat 52° 54' N.
9/8/1941 11:05:00 PM - Destroyed Large Ore Transport Freighter, 7890 tons, Long 39° 03' W, Lat 52° 54' N.
9/8/1941 1100 PM - Destroyed Troop Transport, 10865 tons, Long 39° 03' W, Lat 52° 54' N.
9/9/1941 - Objective achieved Reposition and continue operations at AK7255.
9/17/1941 7:36:07 AM - Completion of a patrol in the base StNazaire.
Merit - 1060.
Torpedoes launched - 7.
Torpedoes impact - 5.
Torpedoes missed - 3.
Sinking tonnage - 36714.
Patrol time - 34 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #19.
-------------------------------------------------------
10/17/1941 5:36:07 PM - Out on patrol from the base StNazaire.
10/21/1941 9:41:00 PM - Destroyed Large Merchant Ship, 7744 tons, Long 7° 53' W, Lat 35° 46' N.
10/21/1941 9:52:00 PM - Destroyed Liberty Cargo, 7173 tons, Long 7° 53' W, Lat 35° 46' N.
10/21/1941 11:16:00 PM - Destroyed Granville Type Medium Freighter, 4165 tons, Long 7° 53' W, Lat 35° 46' N.
10/21/1941 11:18:00 PM - Destroyed Large Ore Transport Freighter, 8001 tons, Long 7° 54' W, Lat 35° 46' N.
10/21/1941 11:38:00 PM - Destroyed Hog Island Medium Freighter (War supplies), 4235 tons, Long 7° 54' W, Lat 35° 46' N.
10/22/1941 6:48:00 AM - Destroyed Medium Composite Freighter, 3994 tons, Long 9° 07' W, Lat 35° 47' N.
10/22/1941 7:01:00 AM - Destroyed Small SV Tanker, 2838 tons, Long 9° 06' W, Lat 35° 48' N.
10/25/1941 8:33:16 PM - Completion of a patrol in the base StNazaire.
Merit - 1380.
Torpedoes launched - 7.
Torpedoes impact - 5.
Torpedoes missed - 1.
Sinking tonnage - 38150.
Patrol time - 9 days..
-------------------------------------------------------
10/25/1941 - The new award is Ritterkreuz des Eisernen Kreuzes mit Eichenlaub und Schwerter.
-------------------------------------------------------
Patrol #20.
-------------------------------------------------------
Mission Debriefing:
-------------------------------------------------------
Last message:
Attacked by airplane...heavy flooding...Sink...
-------------------------------------------------------
11/29/1941 5:33:16 PM - Out on patrol from the base StNazaire.
-------------------------------------------------------
12/3/1941 - Died.

[vdr1981]

Just look at it. So, sometimes in the water > impact + missed, but sometimes in the water < impact + missed

Heh, exactly...Although "water < impact + missed" is more frequent from what I saw...

The best solution I can see to select the larger of these two values as torpedoes launched counter for statistics:
1) in the water
2) impact + missed
And show this info only for information. No penalties cause this info is not 100% accurate.

I absolutely agree on both, nice thinking.

Looking forward to new update...

[Warham]

Originally Posted by vdr1981

Looking forward to new update...

New update with fixed torpedoes info available on the same link. This is not necessarily update. But of course this fix will aslo include in future updates.

[vdr1981]

Looking at those messed up modlists visible trough your awesome app, made me to add this warning to all main TWoS related posts...

*DO NOT add any additional mods if you are not 100% sure what you are doing! Most of the standalone mods are incompatible with this expansion without certain manual tweaks.

However, I'm pretty much sure that this wont do much good either...It's amassing how people like to cram up more mods even if they dont have any idea what a hell they're doing...

[Warham]

We have new best ace - Serviola

It was good news.

Bad news. Everyone needs to update cause i had some problems with spain version of sh5. And we wait for gamers with french, italian, russian, etc. versions of the game In fact probably (or maybe ) will be no problems with them, except counting torpedoes. But counting torpedoes is not reason to required update.

And question to everyone how do you feel about "Sunk tonnage - 1256571"? I am not so happy, cause its fantastic in cube. Maybe add filters on the level of realism and sunk tonnage

[vdr1981]

Warham?

Originally Posted by Warham

And question to everyone how do you feel about "Sunk tonnage - 1256571"? I am not so happy, cause its fantastic in cube. Maybe add filters on the level of realism and sunk tonnage

I have to agree on this...Crazy tonnage like these are commonly indication of a BUG called stock SH5 or at least lightly modded... Doesnt look "normal" , that's for sure...

[Warham]

Originally Posted by vdr1981

Warham?
:

too much date formats in this world.

Originally Posted by vdr1981

I have to agree on this...Crazy tonnage like these are commonly indication of a BUG called stock SH5 or at least lightly modded... Doesnt look "normal" , that's for sure...

He plays with TWoS But with 67% difficulty level and with Wind&Smoke. But i also can do this tonnage with save load every time i miss any torpedo. So only tonnage filter can fix this problem. For me more than 266629 is get out of my vision. But maybe anyone have better solution?

[palmic]

I would filter difficulty relevant options only for max hardcore settings.

Tonnage filter is overengineering for me.

If you want, you could ban cheaters by name manually, but it's nothing very important until they will not overspam chart

[vdr1981]

Yes...some kind of 100% realism filter would be really nice addition because every SH game (even GWX) with auto TDC, map contacts, sub with GPS or external views can be "shooting party" if player is skilled enough, exploiting unrealistic harbor raids ect......

Now, I'm not sure how would you do that because realism percentage can be changed in bunker so some Captain could have have one patrol with 100% and the next one with 87%, 70% ect.

Maybe "Players with all 100% patrols" filter or something...

[Warham]

Originally Posted by palmic

I would filter difficulty relevant options only for max hardcore settings.

Tonnage filter is overengineering for me.

If you want, you could ban cheaters by name manually, but it's nothing very important until they will not overspam chart

Its not cheat to play stock sh5 with save load. Everyone plays as he wants. My task is to divide players playing in the full real settings if they want to divide.

[palmic]

I believe, without it, chart is useless, i want most punishing category available

[vdr1981]

Originally Posted by Warham

Its not cheat to play stock sh5 with save load. Everyone plays as he wants. My task is to divide players playing in the full real settings if they want to divide.

Agree...Any idea how would you acomplish that having in mind facts from my previous post?