I'm rating it in the top category
, even though at the same time there are imo imperfections. The second category just sounded on the low side for me.
There are things that are different and that I'm still getting used to. There are things I want to see changed, and things that need fixing. But my rating is overall and I am seeing a very well-worked game, with nice gameplay and immersive features.
Just my own opinion of course, and others will disagree which is their right also.