SUBSIM Radio Room Forums - View Single Post - Exactly how does one do an extensive air attack?

nodlew · 02-20-10, 04:26 PM

Code:

The date of 7 should have nothing to do with it, you may have something   wrong that is preventing them from working.

Might be FOTRS again somehow. With the mod enabled, I had to copy and paste a couple of files from the Data folder to the mod to get the Editor to open up and run.

Been tweaking the mission. At first I had Dive Bombers and Attack planes together in a group, but since I can only give one waypoint to the group, that was restricting my fighters' speed and making them more vulnerable. Now I have one initial wave of Dauntless DBs, then for the rest of the hour successive waves of Fighters with bombs and rockets. The fighters are dive bombers too, after all. They drop bombs, then strafe and rocket, then the survivors break off. Works very well.
I neet to tone everything back to try to make things last longer. There is a constant fighter presence to keep the action going and four waves of TBs at 10 min. intervals which results, after 30 mins. or so, in the Yamato dead in the water with most of its escorts sunk, maybe one or two remaining, but heavily damaged. There is a brief lull, then the final wave arrives. More fighters and a devastating TB attack and it's sayonara Task Force Ten-Go.
It's impossible to make it true-to-life of course. In order for the game to be "fun" it diverges from reality in countless ways. The Yamato is both more vulnerable and far tougher than its real world counterpart, depending on what is attacking it. Battleships can pound it until the cows come home with little effect. Planes are somewhat more potent against it. Fighters, Dive Bombers, and Torpedo Bombers are far more accurate than they were in reality. In an interview, a Yamato survivor said the Americans attacked in groups of about 30. So 30 Curtiss Dive Bombers in the first wave. Out of those 30, according to Wikipedia, two bombs hit. In-game, 30 DBs are liable to very nearly sink Yamato in 15 seconds. In the first attack, one torpedo hit Yamato. In game, a wave of 8 TBs, if they all attack Yamato, will probably hit Yamato 8 times. At least 6 torpedoes will hit. Yamato can survive 6, or even 8, torpedo hits, but she is left dead in the water, hanging by a thread. To have Yamato survive for 2 hrs, I will have to dribble in my planes in groups of 4 (2?) which is hardly realistic, and with all the AA concentrated on a small group, the planes will all be shot down.
So...there's only so much one can do.
But it's fun.

02-20-10, 04:26 PM	#8
nodlew Engineer Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: Virginia Posts: 202 Downloads: 572 Uploads: 0	Code: The date of 7 should have nothing to do with it, you may have something wrong that is preventing them from working. Might be FOTRS again somehow. With the mod enabled, I had to copy and paste a couple of files from the Data folder to the mod to get the Editor to open up and run. Been tweaking the mission. At first I had Dive Bombers and Attack planes together in a group, but since I can only give one waypoint to the group, that was restricting my fighters' speed and making them more vulnerable. Now I have one initial wave of Dauntless DBs, then for the rest of the hour successive waves of Fighters with bombs and rockets. The fighters are dive bombers too, after all. They drop bombs, then strafe and rocket, then the survivors break off. Works very well. I neet to tone everything back to try to make things last longer. There is a constant fighter presence to keep the action going and four waves of TBs at 10 min. intervals which results, after 30 mins. or so, in the Yamato dead in the water with most of its escorts sunk, maybe one or two remaining, but heavily damaged. There is a brief lull, then the final wave arrives. More fighters and a devastating TB attack and it's sayonara Task Force Ten-Go. It's impossible to make it true-to-life of course. In order for the game to be "fun" it diverges from reality in countless ways. The Yamato is both more vulnerable and far tougher than its real world counterpart, depending on what is attacking it. Battleships can pound it until the cows come home with little effect. Planes are somewhat more potent against it. Fighters, Dive Bombers, and Torpedo Bombers are far more accurate than they were in reality. In an interview, a Yamato survivor said the Americans attacked in groups of about 30. So 30 Curtiss Dive Bombers in the first wave. Out of those 30, according to Wikipedia, two bombs hit. In-game, 30 DBs are liable to very nearly sink Yamato in 15 seconds. In the first attack, one torpedo hit Yamato. In game, a wave of 8 TBs, if they all attack Yamato, will probably hit Yamato 8 times. At least 6 torpedoes will hit. Yamato can survive 6, or even 8, torpedo hits, but she is left dead in the water, hanging by a thread. To have Yamato survive for 2 hrs, I will have to dribble in my planes in groups of 4 (2?) which is hardly realistic, and with all the AA concentrated on a small group, the planes will all be shot down. So...there's only so much one can do. But it's fun.