SUBSIM Radio Room Forums - View Single Post

S09 · 07-17-17, 07:27 PM

I'm well aware that you've probably done a lot of work on these, but the Oberon Class fin is all wrong. There were no windows in the fin and certainly no appendage at the back of the fin either. Looks more like a Foxtrot. There are no fwd foreplanes showing either. Similarly the Upholder class looks like a Kilo, again there were no windows in the fin.

Dreadnought, Valiant and Churchill class, the bows are way too pointed. The real thing had much rounder bows. The fin is also way too tall and too long horizontally. You are close with the S & T boats, except that the T boats had a much larger rudder.

The Astute class is totally wrong. It look like an Alfa.

If you want to know how I know this - its because I served on Warspite, Splendid, Sovereign and 'O' Boats. I also went onboard all the Trafalgar class boats too.

07-17-17, 07:27 PM	#8
S09 Bilge Rat Join Date: Jun 2017 Posts: 1 Downloads: 5 Uploads: 0	Boat shapes I'm well aware that you've probably done a lot of work on these, but the Oberon Class fin is all wrong. There were no windows in the fin and certainly no appendage at the back of the fin either. Looks more like a Foxtrot. There are no fwd foreplanes showing either. Similarly the Upholder class looks like a Kilo, again there were no windows in the fin. Dreadnought, Valiant and Churchill class, the bows are way too pointed. The real thing had much rounder bows. The fin is also way too tall and too long horizontally. You are close with the S & T boats, except that the T boats had a much larger rudder. The Astute class is totally wrong. It look like an Alfa. If you want to know how I know this - its because I served on Warspite, Splendid, Sovereign and 'O' Boats. I also went onboard all the Trafalgar class boats too.