SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   SHIII Mods Workshop (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=195)
-   -   [REL] Le Fantasque class (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=218227)

gap 06-11-17 08:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2490322)
Jimbuna's steady posting of pictures showing ugly stock SH3 models has always been a great motivation for doing better models :D
I probably shall give credit to his contribution :hmmm:

:rotfl2:

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2490322)
I would like to complete another project before. The major obstactle is that the guns are not available:

http://www.navweaps.com/Weapons/WNUS_5-51_mk7.php

http://www.navweaps.com/Weapons/WNUS_3-50_mk10-22.php

Gap, if you feel for you may consider to re-create them :O:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kendras (Post 2490333)
And what about 4,7inch guns with and without shield (for Nelson battleship I converted from SH5) ? :D

if someone can provide me with good quality pictures of the guns seen from different angles or, at best, with construction schemes, why not? :03:

Kendras 06-11-17 08:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gap (Post 2490369)
if someone can provide me with good quality pictures of the guns seen from different angles or, at best, with construction schemes, why not? :03:

Let's finish all our projects first. :shucks:

the_frog 06-11-17 01:31 PM

Gap, how many projects you "run" by now?
Here you go :D

http://www.mediafire.com/file/99b3n1...50_Mk_10-22.7z

http://www.mediafire.com/file/nk7bub...hb/5inch-51.7z


Mind the polygon count, we need AI items not player models :03:

A largely correct model of a 3inch-50 submarine wet mount is in SH4 but has in total >30 000 polygons :)

gap 06-11-17 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2490437)
Gap, how many projects you "run" by now?
Here you go :D

You mean how many projects carried me away? :03:
I don't know exactly, but obviously more than I can handle :doh::O:

I couldn't ask for more
:rotfl2:

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2490437)
Mind the polygon count, we need AI items not player models :03:

Roger that :salute:
How many polygons more or less would you like each gun to be?

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2490437)
A largely correct model of a 3inch-50 submarine wet mount is in SH4 but has in total >30 000 polygons :)

I will have a look into it. Maype I can downsample it. If not, it will be a good template to start from :up:

the_frog 06-11-17 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gap (Post 2490452)
How many polygons more or less would you like each gun to be?

Check the 6 inch model I once sent :03:

Most of the guns I did had 4 to 5 000 triangles. This seems to be good comprise between the level of detail and what SH3 can handle.

gap 06-11-17 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2490488)
Check the 6 inch model I once sent :03:

Most of the guns I did had 4 to 5 000 triangles. This seems to be good comprise between the level of detail and what SH3 can handle.

Those amazing guns... I almost forgot about them! :doh:

Time to download your files, hoping that the link is still working, and to return the favor :salute:

the_frog 06-11-17 04:16 PM

I remember seeing a model of the USS Texas having the two guns. It could be this model but I do not use Sketchup anaymore and so I cannot check.

https://3dwarehouse.sketchup.com/model/545ff652d009382f7bb109af440648c0/USS-Texas-BB-35?

gap 07-16-17 01:56 PM

Hi The_Frog :salute:

In the past few days I have been reading information on the guns that you need for equipping your upcoming model and, seeing how many US ships had those guns fitted aboard (some of them even featured in stock SHIII, IV and 5), I must say that it is a scandal that no one has modelled them yet.
So, being the curious (and lazy) guy that I am, I have decided to have a look into the sketchup model that you pointed me to, and I hve also managed extraxting some meshes from it. Here they are, after some basic reworks by me:

http://i.imgur.com/XEL6iHs.png

Far from being a perfect copy of the real guns, I think those models look pretty decent though. Indeed, besides the usual reworks imposed by missing polygons, normals facing the wrong direction, etc, they will require a good polygon reduction (they are way beyond the poly count limit you gave me).
What do you think? Should I go for it?

Something I have noticed, is that the the look of the 3"/50 gun varied quite a lot during its long service. The model above probably reperesents an interwar mark (Mk 20 maybe?), when New-York-class battleships were re-fitted with those guns. Do you think it is okay for your upcoming model, or we should go for a later mark?

the_frog 07-16-17 04:22 PM

Hello gap,

the 3 inch-50 was one of the most numerous pieces of equipment in the USN inventory and used especially on anti-submarine warfare vessels such as the DEs. So, yes, it's kind of funny that Ubisolft did no model of it :roll:

Those models are good enough for SH3 purposes but it is pretty clear they are based on cyclinders with far more than the 12 edges that give nicely smooth models in SH3.:hmmm:

Missing polygons, faces facing opposite directions and the stupid number of faces, these are the annoying features of meshes converted Sketch Up meshes. I think fine tuning such models needs more time than re-building them from scratch. But if you feel for starting the preocess I won't stop you :O:

I still have little time to dedicate to 3D stuff but I lost interest in the Treasury class cutters (those need the two guns) and went back to the Dido. Some progress ...

https://www.mediafire.com/convkey/bf...4iqhlbi06g.jpg

Top and bow-heavy they were.

Most fittings are ready and "just" need to placed ...
In addition, items left to do: funnels, masts, davits, shafts ... and those bloody ships had boats different from those of Southampton/Fiji ... well, at least the 27-ft whaler is same. :yep:

gap 07-16-17 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2500666)
the 3 inch-50 was one of the most numerous pieces of equipment in the USN inventory and used especially on anti-submarine warfare vessels such as the DEs. So, yes, it's kind of funny that Ubisolft did no model of it :roll:

Exactly my point: when I discovered that the two New York class battleships
had both guns in their late and mid-late war configuration, I thought I could rip them from SH5, but I was horrified to discover that Ubisoft guys fitted those ships with a fantasy armament :o

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2500666)
Those models are good enough for SH3 purposes but it is pretty clear they are based on cyclinders with far more than the 12 edges that give nicely smooth models in SH3.:hmmm:

Twice the needed number of edges to be more precise: 24 :yep:

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2500666)
Missing polygons, faces facing opposite directions and the stupid number of faces, these are the annoying features of meshes converted Sketch Up meshes. I think fine tuning such models needs more time than re-building them from scratch. But if you feel for starting the preocess I won't stop you :O:

Well, I see them more as a 3D blueprint than as a model ready to be fed in s3D. I think more than 3/4 of the time I spend for modelling complex objects, is used for figuring out shapes and proportions from photographs and flat drawing (and for looking for them), than for actually modelling. Sometimes I get stuck, and I can only proceed to the next step when I find a photograph from the 'right' angle, or when I have a mental illumination lol. So, for me, a good 3D template is always a good thing :)

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2500666)
I still have little time to dedicate to 3D stuff but I lost interest in the Treasury class cutters (those need the two guns) and went back to the Dido. Some progress ...

Have you seen the SH5 model of it? How does it compare to the real Didos? :03:

the_frog 07-17-17 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gap (Post 2500685)
Exactly my point: when I discovered that the two New York class battleships had both guns in their late and mid-late war configuration, I thought I could rip them from SH5, but I was horrified to discover that Ubisoft guys fitted those ships with a fantasy armament :o

Well, well, Ubi did several fancy fantasy items. One is the 4.5-inch guns in SH5, which is partly modelled after the US 4 inch-50. Or the director towers of the SH4/5 Dido :03:


Quote:

Originally Posted by gap (Post 2500685)
Twice the needed number of edges to be more precise: 24 :yep:

Great ...


Quote:

Originally Posted by gap (Post 2500685)
Well, I see them more as a 3D blueprint than as a model ready to be fed in s3D. I think more than 3/4 of the time I spend for modelling complex objects, is used for figuring out shapes and proportions from photographs and flat drawing (and for looking for them), than for actually modelling. Sometimes I get stuck, and I can only proceed to the next step when I find a photograph from the 'right' angle, or when I have a mental illumination lol. So, for me, a good 3D template is always a good thing :)

I understand. As templates they may work fine if to scale.


Quote:

Originally Posted by gap (Post 2500685)
Have you seen the SH5 model of it? How does it compare to the real Didos? :03:

The SH3 model was bad but was re-used in SH4, with some polygon-heavy nonsense added. This worsened model, with little changes, then made it into SH5 ...
So, it is about as close to reality as the equipment of the New York class :D

gap 07-17-17 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2500893)
Well, well, Ubi did several fancy fantasy items. One is the 4.5-inch guns in SH5, which is partly modelled after the US 4 inch-50. Or the director towers of the SH4/5 Dido :03:

...

The SH3 model was bad but was re-used in SH4, with some polygon-heavy nonsense added. This worsened model, with little changes, then made it into SH5 ...
So, it is about as close to reality as the equipment of the New York class :D

:o :Kaleun_Sick:

yamatoforever 08-13-17 04:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_frog (Post 2488972)
Seems you have not been here for a while:03:
Welcome back.

Still modding train simulations or are you returning now to the sea?

Both! And the great new ships are then installed in my DFW videos. :up:

(Schön wieder dabei zu sein und von dir zu hören)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:54 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2024 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.